6 ms·
+1 for IRC, the interface is clunky and the protocol hasn't aged particularly well (especially for mobile devices who may not be able to hold a connection forev
by dijit 10y ago
+1 for IRC, the interface is clunky and the protocol hasn't aged particularly well (especially for mobile devices who may not be able to hold a connection forever). But the social aspect of easily accessible chatrooms and the plethora of clients/tools surrounding IRC is really second to none.
You can put a pretty skin on it (slack,discord) but at the end of the day it's going to take years to bring up the level of tooling and at the end you wind up in a closed loop on someone elses platform.
FWIW; I dream of electric sheep so I'm completely biased. I run an IRC network if anyone is interested in joining.
host: irc.darkscience.net/6697 (SSL required)
chan: #darkscience
- josteink 10y ago> +1 for IRC, the interface is clunky and the protocol hasn't aged particularly well (especially for mobile devices who may not be able to hold a connection forever). Weechat and it's Android relay client is for you.
- lmm 10y agoIRC is great for a world where people have one account on one computer that's permanently switched on, but it inherently fails to handle use from multiple devices. All "solutions" to this end up involving running your own server (or, more likely, having someone else do it) and talking to that via a probably-proprietary (or at least nonstandard) protocol at which point you no longer have the benefit you're talking about. (That protocol is often layered over an open protocol, but commands-over-ssh is very hard to interoperate with if not standardized) Good UI is not just "pretty", it's also about having commands be discoverable. Traditional IRC clients are terrible in this regard. There's no reason the platform has to be closed - I'm friends with the people working on http://matrix.org/ http://matrix.org/ (though not involved in it myself) and hope they succeed.
- dijit 10y agoI agree about the discoverability of commands, but that's inherently a client issue and not one against IRC itself. You're right that there's not much in the way of offline messaging without running something like znc (which you can run at home on anything), but there is also Memoserv on most networks- if you absolutely have to notify someone. Or, there's email.
- scrollaway 10y agoI recommend IRCCloud.com to people. I'm a huge fan of IRC but it's true the IRC protocol has many issues (I talked about them before on HN; can't find the link now). IRCCloud may be (slightly) proprietary but at least it still only talks to IRC, and it's a good alternative to Slack&Friends (which are 100% proprietary) and webchat (which have the same issues as desktop clients and are generally atrociously ugly). Free IRCCloud accounts stay online 2 hours when shut off. I pay for mine, which stays online forever. It's a fairly similar experience to slack except I can still use the same open protocol as everyone else. Matrix is extremely promising but IMO not there yet.
- lorenzhs 10y agoI run WeeChat in a tmux and connect to it with Glowing Bear. It's a similar experience, and it's all free software. It also leverages the whole power of WeeChat in a nice interface (triggers, scripts, etc), so it can do some nice tricks that IRCcloud can't. Oh and there's also a Matrix script for WeeChat, so you can use matrix from WeeChat (and thus Glowing Bear)!
- scrollaway 10y agoGot some examples? I never tried WeeChat. I used to use Quassel (I liked the client a lot), but after my server died I figured it wasn't worth the trouble of maintaining it.
- lorenzhs 10y agoExamples for what? There are some screenshots of Glowing Bear on the GitHub page (https://github.com/glowing-bear/glowing-bear https://github.com/glowing-bear/glowing-bear) and in a blog post I once wrote (https://4z2.de/2014/04/10/glowing-bear https://4z2.de/2014/04/10/glowing-bear, probably outdated). I use it with a sans-serif font on the Desktop, too. The UI is quite hackable, you can add custom CSS rules to override things to your liking in the settings (simply changing the font doesn't require that, though). Some useful scripts include colorize_nicks.py (colourises nicks in messages, to make them stand out over the text) and grep.py (easily and efficiently search logs). Matrix.lua (https://github.com/torhve/weechat-matrix-protocol-script https://github.com/torhve/weechat-matrix-protocol-script) allows you to use the Matrix protocol with WeeChat, and by extension Glowing Bear. Trigger-wise, I have triggers that remove colour from status messages (most of them are just noise) or replace (lenny) with ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) when I send a message, mostly because I can ;) Getting push notifications requires a bit of setup, but there are scripts for Pushbullet/Pushover/..., or irssi-notifier (which also works with WeeChat) to do that. It's a bit complicated because we don't run any servers (Glowing Bear is just a bunch of static files, everything happens in your browser or your WeeChat), so we can't provide push notifications out of the box. Disclosure: I'm one of the Glowing Bear devs, so I may be biased :)
- kqr 10y ago> the interface is clunky The reason I prefer IRC after all these years is that the interfaces available have not been beaten by any other product so far. Sure, IRC has an unfair advantage in being 20 years old so there's 20 years of development behind the current interfaces, but still. Yes, I have a set of particular requirements which aren't in line with what a "regular customer" would want in their communication app, but so? IRC gives me the freedom to get my interface while someone else can get a different interface.
- exadeci 10y agohttps://www.irccloud.com/ https://www.irccloud.com/ does a good job at being a painless client and it adds a slack/discord coating with features like inline images/videos. I've been using the free version for a while and I'm pretty happy with it.