3 ms·
What is the message (or "punch line") that is supposedly clear here? It seems poor households have higher computer ownership percentage than even the richest
by ZeroGravitas 17y ago
What is the message (or "punch line") that is supposedly clear here?
It seems poor households have higher computer ownership percentage than even the richest in this study, wich seems odd.
It also appears that while the poor have much higher ownership levels, they proportionately play less video games (though it's hard to judge from the graphs, note the scale changes from ownership proportion going up to 100%, to play ever day proportion only going up to 40%).
I've read several other studies which claim introducing computers in homes or schools is actually counter-productive if not done right but the rich/poor thing seems just to confuse this issue, and I'm really not sure what point is being made here.
Is he against computers or vouchers?
- youngian 17y agoI believe the graphs are all post-voucher numbers. In other words, those below the red line are the ones who qualified for the vouchers, thus the jumps in ownership. The punchline is that while computer games increased substantially because of the program, using computers for homework did not.
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoI considered that, but since we don't have the pre-voucher numbers, how do we know if it increased or not? It all seem to rest on there being a discontinuity between those that are nearly the same level of income but some get a voucher and some don't but, strangely, the ownership level decreases as you approach the line, then increases again. The very poorest, with the highest computer ownership, appear to have the highest computer study time too.
- youngian 17y agoQuite possibly it's just quirks in the trendlines caused by small sample size or something. I would imagine the original paper has more numbers and information on methods, but sadly it looks like it's behind a paywall.