4 ms·
I just thought of an even better example: liquor licenses. Those things cost a couple hundred thousand dollars in SF, and existing ones are typicaly valued at
by wahern 10y ago
I just thought of an even better example: liquor licenses.
Those things cost a couple hundred thousand dollars in SF, and existing ones are typicaly valued at tens of thousands.
Should I have a claim if I paid $250k for a liquor license to the state last year, but this year the state of California decided to rescind commercial liquor laws? What if they permitted cities the ability to rescind them; would SF owe me, or would the the state of California own me if SF exercised this ability? What if they were rescinded for all stores more than a 1000 feet from a school? Does it matter whether I was outside the 1000 feet zone and the license became useless, or if I was inside the zone by 10 feet and so it was technically useful but lost almost all commercial value? The resale value of a liquor store business can be a function almost entirely of the value of the license it holds.
Those are thorny questions, but I think in general there's much to be said for giving government carte blanche ability to reduce the scope of or entirely rescind monopoly schemes. I think it would be fair to say that relying on government-imposed monopolies is like making a deal with the devil; don't be surprised if you get screwed.
As long as it's not targeted at individuals (which is probably more an equal protection or due process issue), and isn't a bald faced scheme to expropriate assets, courts would be wise to let the chips fall where they may. I think there's an old common law axiom that the default rule is to leave damages where they fall unless there's a good public policy interest in shifting them. That seems applicable here where it's difficult to justify punishing the government for relaxing a restraint on trade. It's not at all clear to me that the greater public good benefits even collaterally, all things considered.