4 ms·
I think parents have to actively and persistently encourage their children in valuable habits (e.g., reading, drawing, outdoor exercise, music practice, etc.) b
by tokenadult 17y ago
I think parents have to actively and persistently encourage their children in valuable habits (e.g., reading, drawing, outdoor exercise, music practice, etc.) before the first computer games are allowed in the house. The computer games are very well designed indeed to be a time-consuming form of playful engagement. They rob time from the deliberate practice young people need to become expert in something valuable. Fortunately, my oldest son now likes to actually program, in a variety of languages, rather than spend much time playing childish computer games. And my second son likes to write creative fiction, although the computer games haven't lost their charm for him.
- pragmatic 17y agoGames develop critical thinking skills. Problem solving would seem to be "something valuable." Do you see chess/backgammon/go as something to be discouraged also? Is it the medium you object to or the game playing itself?
- MichaelGG 17y agoMaybe it's that many "video games" tend not to have much in the way of problem solving. The latest race car or shooting game probably doesn't require much thinking at all. (And yes, there are games that do require thinking and should be applauded.)
- tokenadult 17y agoGames develop critical thinking skills. Problem solving would seem to be "something valuable." I agree with the general proposition that problem-solving skills are well worth developing. I also agree with the reply you have already received that how much problem-solving there really is in computer games depends on which game we are talking about. Games are like many other things in life--the calling of but a few, but good in moderation for many. I just don't like seeing learners let computer games, especially the computer games without much deep problem-solving, crowd out of their schedule other worthwhile activities. Thanks for asking.
- esspem 17y agoScientific American 1859 http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=100-years-ago-baseballs http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=100-years-a... A pernicious excitement to learn and play chess has spread all over the country, and numerous clubs for practicing this game have been formed in cities and villages. Why should we regret this? It may be asked. We answer, chess is a mere amusement of a very inferior character, which robs the mind of valuable time that might be devoted to nobler acquirements, while it affords no benefit whatever to the body
- cia_plant 17y agoMy parents were quite irresponsible, and let me waste my time playing video games and reading escapist fiction, instead of doing valuable effortful practice. When I went to MIT, I found that many of my classmates had been neglected in the same manner.
- swombat 17y agoReading "escapist fiction", as you call it, is probably one of the most valuable things you can do with your young mind.
- cia_plant 17y agoAny discussion of education seems to bring up a whole raft of ideas about what does and does not effect the young mind, and in which direction. Plato, who was rather more observant and intelligent than you or I, felt that young people would be best served by learning only valorous stories, which showed just and good men triumphing and so on. He felt that the basic components of education ought to be music and gymnastic; and that an overemphasis on music would produce an overly intellectual and sentimental adult (an overemphasis on gymnastic would produce a brute). Views seem to have completely shifted, to the point that Plato's program strikes one as absurd. However, I am not aware of any breakthrough in our understanding of the nature of education: our modern ideas are based, like those of Plato, on an observation of society, and of children, and of education, all colored by our assumptions about what is and is not valuable. When I tell people that I played video games and read novels, they are no doubt inclined to think that I must have become smart and capable thanks to the novels and despite the video games. Why do we think that way, and not in the opposite way - that I became smart by playing video games, and despite reading lots of books? When I solve a hard problem, it feels more like the feeling I have in Quake, when I'm holding the entire playing field in my head and keeping track of where my opponents could be, than like the feeling I have while reading a book.
- swombat 17y agoPlato was certainly smarter than both of us put together, but he also lived in a very different cultural landscape than we do. What books were available to young people then? Not many, I'd wager. The lack of suitable mass publication mechanisms certainly reduced the importance of literature. And the vast majority of the authors that I would think of as "great" had not been born yet. It is debatable whether a landscape devoid of mass publication means would still produce a healthy supply of great literature. Since the printing press, we've had an explosion of amazing literature produced and distributed throughout the world. Many of the greatest thinkers of the last three centuries left their thoughts behind for us to build on. As an added bonus, many of them left those thoughts in highly entertaining forms that entertain and delight as much as they instruct. It would really be looking the gift horse in the mouth to the extreme, to demand that impractical scientific studies be conducted to "prove" that humanity's great books make your life better. Of course, we may have a difference of definition here. By "escapist fiction" I assume you included most fictional works, including such masters as Gabriel Garcia Marques, Herman Hesse and Jorge Luis Borghes, who definitely have the ability to transport one outside of the real world into that of imagination.
- stcredzero 17y agoAs someone who had an Apple II+ in the living room when he was 11 years old, I can attest that getting a computer strongly motivates a kid to play games and acquire games. I can also attest that this often leads to tinkering with computers and seeking to write your own computer games. The OLPC folks had this right. Kids are going to chat and play games on their new machines, but if you make it easy to stumble on the programming environment and source code, you're also going to enable a lot of tinkering and genuine learning. The Apple II seemed to be exquisitely designed for this. Its command line was pretty much a prompt to the Basic interpreter.
- protomyth 17y agoWhen I was young my Dad got us an Atari 400 with the BASIC cartridge. He then told me I could "program" the computer to solve my math problems. Learned a lot, didn't save any time. :) -- on the game front the 400 version of Pac-Man looked like the arcade game, not the plumber tools the 2600 version looked like.