12 ms·
Result of Giving Poor Households Computer Vouchers
- frederickcook 17y agoI've got to say, thinking back on my own K-12 education, almost the entirety of which I had access to a computer at home, I don't think I did a whole lot of homework on it, and I definitely played a lot of computer games. Additionally, if the teachers weren't giving out assignments that required the use of the computer, which seems unlikely if not everyone has access to a computer, then the computer won't be used for homework. Obviously, that wasn't the goal of the program, and I"d be interested in hearing more about the "increase in computer proficiency and perhaps some improvement in a cognitive test." Personally, I know that access to computers and computer science classes in high school probably had a much larger impact on my interest and aptitude in computer science. Perhaps the program would be more effective by bringing computers into school at an earlier age (combined with useful curriculum). I remember playing Oregon Trail in computer class in elementary school (early nineties) and thinking back, I really wish the instructor had shown us (me) a command prompt and some Fortran or BASIC.
- tshtf 17y agoI found Oregon Trail educational when I was young, but maybe in different ways than the game's authors intended. In the early versions of the game, you had to purchase food, clothing, and what not. I recall the prices of these changed as you went to various forts. The obvious way to win the game was to buy a negative amount of clothing when the cost of clothing was high - the game performed no numerical checks when purchasing items. You could survive the journey between two forts with a negative amount of clothing, and when visiting the subsequent fort you could purchase all the goods you would need for the entire journey.
- moultano 17y agoIt was just trying to teach you about short-selling and credit default swaps.
- halostatue 17y agoI remember typing in the code for SpeedScript (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SpeedScript http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SpeedScript) to be able to write papers.
- tokenadult 17y agoI think parents have to actively and persistently encourage their children in valuable habits (e.g., reading, drawing, outdoor exercise, music practice, etc.) before the first computer games are allowed in the house. The computer games are very well designed indeed to be a time-consuming form of playful engagement. They rob time from the deliberate practice young people need to become expert in something valuable. Fortunately, my oldest son now likes to actually program, in a variety of languages, rather than spend much time playing childish computer games. And my second son likes to write creative fiction, although the computer games haven't lost their charm for him.
- pragmatic 17y agoGames develop critical thinking skills. Problem solving would seem to be "something valuable." Do you see chess/backgammon/go as something to be discouraged also? Is it the medium you object to or the game playing itself?
- MichaelGG 17y agoMaybe it's that many "video games" tend not to have much in the way of problem solving. The latest race car or shooting game probably doesn't require much thinking at all. (And yes, there are games that do require thinking and should be applauded.)
- tokenadult 17y agoGames develop critical thinking skills. Problem solving would seem to be "something valuable." I agree with the general proposition that problem-solving skills are well worth developing. I also agree with the reply you have already received that how much problem-solving there really is in computer games depends on which game we are talking about. Games are like many other things in life--the calling of but a few, but good in moderation for many. I just don't like seeing learners let computer games, especially the computer games without much deep problem-solving, crowd out of their schedule other worthwhile activities. Thanks for asking.
- esspem 17y agoScientific American 1859 http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=100-years-ago-baseballs http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=100-years-a... A pernicious excitement to learn and play chess has spread all over the country, and numerous clubs for practicing this game have been formed in cities and villages. Why should we regret this? It may be asked. We answer, chess is a mere amusement of a very inferior character, which robs the mind of valuable time that might be devoted to nobler acquirements, while it affords no benefit whatever to the body
- jcl 17y agoNot surprisingly, with all that game playing going on, the authors find that the voucher program actually resulted in a decline in grades This is a little surprising, actually. The study showed the amount of homework done is pretty much constant across both groups, and I'd expect that to be the main influence on grades, not what they do in their leisure time. One has to wonder what the non-game-playing students were doing in their spare time that increased their grades, or what aspect of the games is hurting grades.
- JeffJenkins 17y agoI believe that graph is about the time spent on the computer doing homework, so it's possible the increased computer game playing took away from non-computer homework.
- jcl 17y agoI took a look at the paper, and that is not an unreasonable explanation... It seems that the increased computer use did indeed reduce the time spent doing non-computer homework a bit, although the data is quite noisy and may not be statistically significant; TV viewing was similarly impacted. But what really took a hit was time spent reading recreationally. I can't help wonder what influence the reading had on grades relative to the homework. Another thing in the paper that I found somewhat surprising was that slightly different parental rules had markedly different effects: Interestingly, we find evidence that the presence of parental rules regarding homework mitigate some of the negative effects of winning a computer voucher without affecting the gains to computer skills and cognitive ability. On the other hand, the presence of rules regarding computer use reduce the positive impacts on computer skills without improving academic achievement. http://www.columbia.edu/~cp2124/papers/computer.pdf http://www.columbia.edu/~cp2124/papers/computer.pdf
- sophacles 17y agoAlso, there is a disturbing bit on the labels of the graphs: the word everyday. Even if I used my computer for homework a lot, it is feasible I don't have homework to do everyday, but there are always games....
- dschobel 17y agoReminds me of the program planned by the great Rod Blagojevich here in Illinois (and made famous in Freakonomics) to send one book each month to the homes of low-income families based on a prior study which found that there was a very high correlation between kids having books in the home and their performing well at school.
- tjic 17y agoIdiot politician gets causality backwards; film at 11.
- pragmatic 17y agoA different take: How much "homework" can you do on a computer? In college and high school the only homework I did on the computer was typing (and later with access to the internet, researching papers). I gamed a lot more. It's really a condemnation of computers in education. You really can't do that much homework. Obviously today anything you want to know and learn is available online. So as a reference tool the computer is unbeatable. However, as a learning tool does the computer (much like the TV before) remains underutilized?
- prewett 17y ago> It's really a condemnation of computers in education. I've never understood this whole computers-in-classrooms push. I can't see how it would help kids learn reading, 'riting, or 'rithmatic better than the traditional methods. Like you say, it's a great reference tool. But if my school library didn't have any reference books (the World Book Encyclopedia, back in my day), the only impact to my learning would have been that research papers were harder to write. (Man, I hated those things. And those stupid note cards)
- stcredzero 17y agoThe best educational boost a computer can give is in the area of using computers and programming computers. Measuring the effect of computers on homework presented primarily on dead-tree media makes no sense. Alan Kay and also the OLPC folks had this right: the biggest opportunity computers give to expand a young person's mind lies in tinkering with computers.
- protomyth 17y agoGiven the current fears (Chemistry Set = Terrorists), I wish simulators were much more available. The current iPod touch, iPhones, Android, and iPads would be good toys to have school bought simulators.
- tkahn6 17y agoProbably more valuable would have been the statistic of computer use devoted to educational activities (browsing wikipedia, learning how to program, etc.). Comparing "time spent doing homework" to "time spent playing games" is silly. There is a constant amount of homework (once you're done, you're done) and nearly unlimited amount of time to play games.
- barrkel 17y agoMy first computer had a broken cassette drive, so the only thing I could do with it is program it, and I had to write a new program every day. On the other hand, before I got the computer, I used to hang around at a friend's house and program on his, even though he did have games that worked. I think a happy medium might be some kind of Smalltalk system with a handful of very basic games, to serve as some motivation to those not as empowered by "READY." as I was, but with an open architecture so that everything can be tinkered with. That, and versioning or forking so things can easily be brought back to a working state.
- bnomis 17y agoSource article http://blogs.worthpublishers.com/seetheinvisiblehand/2010/03/22/human-capital-is-not-found-in-a-box/ http://blogs.worthpublishers.com/seetheinvisiblehand/2010/03...
- rlivsey 17y agoWhen I was at school I seem to remember that we weren't allowed to use computers for most homework in order to encourage developing handwriting skills etc... Not that it helped, my handwriting is atrocious! That's mainly because in the past 10 years or so I've hardly written a thing which wasn't meant to be read by anyone other than myself.
- lsc 17y agoyeah, me to. I wonder what I would have been able to achieve if I did something useful during the handwriting drills that ate 4-8 hours of my week. hell, after all that work, at this point, I can't even read my own handwriting.
- sshumaker 17y agoI can do better. My third grade teacher was a lovely woman but very old-fashioned, and at the time very few people had a personal computer. When I handed in my first paper, typed up using a word-processing program, she refused to accept it. Why? Because she was convinced "the computer wrote the paper for me." I tried to explain to her that computers as portrayed by the media (this was 1985) and computers in fact were quite different, but she was firm. So I spent the rest of the semester typing up my papers and then re-copying them by hand to hand in. It's funny to think that twenty five years later, the computer STILL can't write my papers.
- aarghh 17y agoI could not get to the original study, but the article seems to be cherry-picking data. What was the time-line of the study? Is this a short term or long term effect? Perhaps homework isn't the only thing that counts? Also, what was the availability to broadband/internet access?
- voidpointer 17y agoThis leaves quite a lot of questions... Were the homework assignments of a type were using a computer to prepare them would actually help? Did the computers include the appropriate software that was needed to do the homework? Had the homework to be submitted in paper form and did the computers come with printers?
- jcl 17y agoI found a copy of the paper here: http://www.columbia.edu/~cp2124/papers/computer.pdf http://www.columbia.edu/~cp2124/papers/computer.pdf The homework assignments are not described, but given that many students do not have computers, it is reasonable to assume that the assignments at least did not require computers. The computer vouchers came with free "educational software", but few households installed it, and essentially no one spent time using educational software, in either group. Printers are not mentioned.
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoWhat is the message (or "punch line") that is supposedly clear here? It seems poor households have higher computer ownership percentage than even the richest in this study, wich seems odd. It also appears that while the poor have much higher ownership levels, they proportionately play less video games (though it's hard to judge from the graphs, note the scale changes from ownership proportion going up to 100%, to play ever day proportion only going up to 40%). I've read several other studies which claim introducing computers in homes or schools is actually counter-productive if not done right but the rich/poor thing seems just to confuse this issue, and I'm really not sure what point is being made here. Is he against computers or vouchers?
- youngian 17y agoI believe the graphs are all post-voucher numbers. In other words, those below the red line are the ones who qualified for the vouchers, thus the jumps in ownership. The punchline is that while computer games increased substantially because of the program, using computers for homework did not.
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoI considered that, but since we don't have the pre-voucher numbers, how do we know if it increased or not? It all seem to rest on there being a discontinuity between those that are nearly the same level of income but some get a voucher and some don't but, strangely, the ownership level decreases as you approach the line, then increases again. The very poorest, with the highest computer ownership, appear to have the highest computer study time too.
- youngian 17y agoQuite possibly it's just quirks in the trendlines caused by small sample size or something. I would imagine the original paper has more numbers and information on methods, but sadly it looks like it's behind a paywall.
- coffeemug 17y agoThe effect of giving computer vouchers to poor people in Romania is that they go to places that will exchange the vouchers for money, and then lie on the questionnaire about what they're doing with the computers.
- tjstankus 17y agoMy wife studies multi-modal literacy as part of her PhD studies. She was, at one point, staunchly against letting our young daughter play too many computer games, but as a result of her studies has done a complete 180. We monitor what our daughter is exposed to, for the most part, but we find that introducing her to games that stretch her skills in literacy, music, logic, etc. has been really beneficial. The result? She was reading at 3 years old and reading well by 4 years old. She just turned 5 and is into chapter books. Is this result completely due to her game playing? No. But the games have definitely helped. tl;dr version: in my opinion, based on experience, the right kind of games will help literacy development
- klipt 17y agoWould you mind giving an example of the right kind of game?
- tjstankus 17y agoMost of the Nintendo DS games involve a lot of text. One example of a game that she played quite a bit recently is Fossil Fighters. The Nintendo DS games pretty much all assume you can read, though, so it's not hard to find ones that develop literacy. She used to play the Leapster quite a bit. There are many educational games for the Leapster. They develop skills that lead to reading, but they don't assume you can read. The browser-based games are hit and miss.
- steamer25 17y agoWhile I am generally opposed to government welfare programs, playing computer games back in my day meant futzing with Extended Memory Managers, IRQs and Hex Editors.
- Groxx 17y agoA perfect example of the dangers of differently sized graphs. The graphs were clearly sized to imply that the increased use was almost all gaming, as they sized them to line up nearly perfectly with the 10-hour charts. Note that the computer-voucher side has roughly 2 hours more non-game, non-homework use, and that in both, the majority of the time is still non-gaming and non-homeworking. What was it used for there? Browsing? Youtubing is not so useful, but there'd definitely be some educational-browsing, and that's not testable in the classroom. Giving someone a tool doesn't guarantee they'll use it properly, but some do, and they're the ones who are more likely to try get out of poverty, instead of getting stuck where they are. As to the decline in grades, I'd definitely argue that an improvement in a cognitive test - usually based around learning skills, not whatever is taught in class (typically rote memorization) - is far more valuable in the long run. The ability to learn is invaluable and persistent, they'll probably forget most of what was in the classes at that time anyway. Scaled size comparison of the two voucher-charts: http://img687.imageshack.us/img687/9271/clearedup.gif http://img687.imageshack.us/img687/9271/clearedup.gif