4 ms·

Crazy idea - but perhaps news.ycombinator should have limited registrations. I wonder what the outcome of that would be.

zach 19y ago
Leaving aside the question of whether filtering users upfront is desirable, you don't need to simply limit registration. There are a lot of intermediate steps you can take. MetaFilter is a classic example of reasonable but comparatively high barriers to registration: $5 for an account and you have to wait a week to post. Seems very clever, but I'm not a MeFi regular, so I'm not sure how well that's worked out.
- jazj 19y ago
  I think paid barriers to entry just amplify the positive or negative effects of other administrative measures; in and of themselves, all they do is reduce the rate of people coming in without much affecting its make-up. It doesn't even work that well for filtering out teenagers any more with the advent of prepaid gift cards (and before that they could just ask the 'rents to stump up the cash anyway). I say that paid barriers don't do that much good or bad themselves based on the fact that on MeFi they seem to have been an asset whereas on, say, Something Awful they seem to've just turned the place into an echo chamber, and on Kuro5hin all it's done is drive the site further into stagnation. Paid barriers aren't risk-free either; it makes account gaming even more fun and makes your site a juicier target for attacks, especially if it means you end up storing people's personal details.
Kaizyn 19y ago
By restricting registration, you cut off your community from potentially beneficial new members and ideas. While news.yc wants to keep the news quality up, I don't think anyone wants to turn it into an elitist club of people who 'got in on the ground floor'.
- simianstyle 19y ago
  What if we made them pass a test before being able to register?

4 ms·

Crazy idea - but perhaps news.ycombinator should have limited registrations. I wonder what the outcome of that would be.

by simianstyle 19y ago

zach 19y ago
Leaving aside the question of whether filtering users upfront is desirable, you don't need to simply limit registration. There are a lot of intermediate steps you can take. MetaFilter is a classic example of reasonable but comparatively high barriers to registration: $5 for an account and you have to wait a week to post. Seems very clever, but I'm not a MeFi regular, so I'm not sure how well that's worked out.
- jazj 19y ago
  I think paid barriers to entry just amplify the positive or negative effects of other administrative measures; in and of themselves, all they do is reduce the rate of people coming in without much affecting its make-up. It doesn't even work that well for filtering out teenagers any more with the advent of prepaid gift cards (and before that they could just ask the 'rents to stump up the cash anyway). I say that paid barriers don't do that much good or bad themselves based on the fact that on MeFi they seem to have been an asset whereas on, say, Something Awful they seem to've just turned the place into an echo chamber, and on Kuro5hin all it's done is drive the site further into stagnation. Paid barriers aren't risk-free either; it makes account gaming even more fun and makes your site a juicier target for attacks, especially if it means you end up storing people's personal details.
Kaizyn 19y ago
By restricting registration, you cut off your community from potentially beneficial new members and ideas. While news.yc wants to keep the news quality up, I don't think anyone wants to turn it into an elitist club of people who 'got in on the ground floor'.
- simianstyle 19y ago
  What if we made them pass a test before being able to register?