4 ms·
However tasteless and ineffectual in the long run, I think it is a logical response to the existing problem. Frankly I'm surprised it took this long, given that
by tremon 10y ago
However tasteless and ineffectual in the long run, I think it is a logical response to the existing problem. Frankly I'm surprised it took this long, given that there is more than 20 years of documented case history of government officials being unaccountable for homicide.
- TallGuyShort 10y agoNo it's not. People shooting random police are bullies as much as police shooting random people. Stand up to both. Police aren't the only people who get away with murder.
- angersock 10y ago> Police aren't the only people who get away with murder. Sure, but they are the only people (other than soldiers) endorsed explicitly by the state to commit acts of physical violence. If you cannot see the issues with using the same standards in regards to them as to normal citizens, you do not understand human nature.
- AnimalMuppet 10y ago"First take the log out of your own eye..." - Jesus If police violence is the problem (and it is), then my violence isn't the solution. Worse, it removes me from any kind of moral high ground where I can try to help end police violence by trying to change police policy, training, or character. Instead, it leads me in the direction of civil war. Is starting a civil war really your best answer to police violence? Or do you think "just kill a few and things will straighten out"?
- angersock 10y ago> Is starting a civil war really your best answer to police violence? I have not advocated for that position here, because like you I think that there are better ways of fixing the problem--policy, training, and recruitment. That all said, I think we have to acknowledge that we can't use the same moral calculus for officers (read: agents of state violence) that we do for common citizens. You even mention as much when you invoke "the moral high ground", because there is a qualitative difference between an act of violence committed by a citizen on their own (presumably limited to their own resources and defensible only by circumstance) and a one committed by an agent of the state (limited only by the resources allocated by the state and defensible by the blank check of "I'm a police officer"). For what it's worth, I don't have a strong alternative code to present at this time--I merely think that one is necessary. One could make the argument that, for example, officers forfeit the right to appeal in the event of a complaint against them, that they should be imprisoned immediately if found doing wrong and executed publicly if found falsifying evidence. This heavy burden--especially if eagerly applied--would serve to help limit the number of people who merely want to be a thug with a badge. And that's not a great plan for a number of reasons--consider the case where criminals just cry foul to remove officers from circulation. But we have to start thinking beyond the simple idea that an officer is in the same moral calculus as a citizen. It's precisely to avoid civil war that change has to happen: when a private citizen commits murder, it is an isolated tragedy. When an agent of the state that does the same, it is cause to question the validity of that state. A lying citizen is not a sign of societal decay, but a lying officer or agent of the state is.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoPolice officers and other agents of the state need to be held to a higher standard. On that I think we agree. Criminals will try to game the system. I agree on that as well. > A lying citizen is not a sign of societal decay, but a lying officer or agent of the state is. A lying citizen is a sign of societal decay. A lying officer or agent of the state is a bigger sign.
- angersock 10y agoI think we agree on all salient points here. A pleasure chatting with you. :)
- pavel_lishin 10y agoHow is it logical? It is 100% an emotional response, an angry response born of frustration. What is logically gained from dead policemen? You will suffer, since you'll be in prison, or possibly dead. Your community will suffer, since if the police were brutal before, they're certainly not going to hold back now.
- tremon 10y agoIsn't it logical to expect emotional responses after 20 years of not dealing with the problem?
- pavel_lishin 10y agoIt's logical to expect emotional responses, but it's not logical to get carried away by your emotions to the point of murder, and pretend like you're doing something great.
- tremon 10y agoJust to be clear, I am not defending the use of excessive force in any circumstance. But when we ignore the reasons behind the violent reactions, we perpetuate the problem. The first step towards change is acknowledging you have a problem.