3 ms·
I support the idea of open government enormously. We make too many things secret, and a government with so much secrecy is not responsive to its citizens. Havi
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
I support the idea of open government enormously. We make too many things secret, and a government with so much secrecy is not responsive to its citizens.
Having said that, I also support the idea that some things -- some very few things -- should be kept secret.
Wikileaks does not seem to discriminate between these things.
Therefore I cannot in good conscience support Wikileaks with their mission to make everything they find public. If, as the article indicates, they're in it for personal kicks then that makes it all the worse.
It's 2010. You'd think the average person/whistleblower would have enough ability to self-publish for the entire world to see, right? If Wikileaks isn't providing some kind of independent, third-party vetting or creating some standards for what can be published or not, what value do they bring to the table?
- rbanffy 17y ago> Wikileaks does not seem to discriminate between these things. And how can someone without a clear view of the whole picture distinguish between both? And who do you want to arbitrate what should and what should not be secret?
- dkimball 17y agoI think the test should be whether the document has moral or just tactical significance. To give examples from the article: Guantanamo Bay interrogation manual? Moral significance; leak. Possible US use of chemical weapons? Moral significance; leak. US order of battle for 2009? No moral significance; don't leak. And in the interest of fairness: Al-Qaida interrogation manual? Leak. We need a picture of both/all sides' dirty laundry, and Wikileaks doesn't really give that.
- rbanffy 17y ago> We need a picture of both/all sides' dirty laundry, and Wikileaks doesn't really give that. Just don't expect Wikileaks to be a one-stop-shop for leaked documents. And, BTW, I doubt Al Qaeda has such a document. That's not their style to document everything. One may interpret that as one of their major tactical strengths.