10 ms·
I don't think the Port Authority would like it if you looked at this photo
- pavel_lishin 10y agoGood on you. I wouldn't have taken the tripod down at all; if he thinks you're doing something illegal, he can call the police, and they can sort it out if and when they arrive. You're not obligated to hang around after taking a legal photo and wait for them.
- brianwawok 10y agoExcept that if the police decide to take you down to the station, inspect your memory card, and shake you down a bit.. then even if they let you go.. you lost an entire day for what gain? Do you think protesting against the security guard and him seeing you dragged off by cops is going to change the policy or his attitude in the future? The only way to "change" anything would be to follow up with a lawsuit if they harass you and get the port authority docked some money. Anything short of that and "you lose". Not sure it is worth everyone's time to follow through with a lawsuit.
- adn 10y agoIf the person doesn't get charged in the end, eventually the police will stop showing up when the Port Authority calls because someone takes a picture.
- pavel_lishin 10y ago> you lost an entire day for what gain? Well, for one, you might get $30,000 out of it. For two, this is America, and you'll gain the satisfaction of standing up for your rights. That particular employee's mentality is one of the worst outcomes of the disaster that was and continues to be the 9/11 attack - the constant paranoia that's more suited to East Germany or the former Soviet Union. For three, if enough people object and stand up for their rights, these pointless, bullshit harassment tactics might actually stop.
- brianwawok 10y agoI like my rights. I can't spend a full day in jail each time I want to protest against a right abuse. I have to pick and choose my battles. Tragedy of the commons says that even if you are right - if we ALL stood up against this it would stop.. for me specifically, it is more convenient to not. So most other people will not. And in fact I am not a photographer, so standing up for photography rights is pretty far down on my priority list.
- joemi 10y agoIn all likelihood, if the cops even bothered to show up after someone called this in, they'd probably laugh it off. I get that people have skepticism about police, but after living in NYC over a decade I've come to notice that NYC police usually don't care one bit about stupid stuff. Even in the "see something, say something" age, they usually have plenty of common sense.
- rasz_pl 10y agoThis is what happens when clown security calls cops in Alaska (Port Of Anchorage): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zDYMewJN8WE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zDYMewJN8WE
- brianwawok 10y agoThat was great. I wish that was the standard response.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoFor the tldr folks, I skipped past the security guards' posturing, because I assume that it's what we expect from this video. https://youtu.be/zDYMewJN8WE?t=1225 https://youtu.be/zDYMewJN8WE?t=1225 <-- This is when the police begin talking to the cameraman, and tell him he's doing nothing illegal or wrong. The police definitely seem like they reacted very well in this instance.
- nathancahill 10y agomemory card = 4x5 sheet of film. Good luck inspecting that.
- antonvs 10y ago> you lost an entire day for what gain? With this attitude, you are literally part of the cause of the problem. If you're not willing to stand up for your rights, you have no basis for complaint when they are removed.
- ascendantlogic 10y agoOk well how about you go out there and pick a fight with that security guard instead of typing about it on the Internet. It's real easy to say stuff like this when you weren't the one in the situation and it's not your life that's on the line.
- pavel_lishin 10y ago> not your life that's on the line. That's a bit hyperbolic. I'd wager that if most HN readers were in the same situation, they would not be in serious danger.
- Karunamon 10y agoThe only rational behavior when dealing with law enforcement of any sort is the same way you'd treat any other dangerous, and possibly violent wild animal - move slowly, don't be the least bit threatening. Any random cop does have the ability to ruin your day, or worse, and there's jack and squat you can do about it until after the fact, if then. That's not even hyperbole - it's rational, objective fact.
- ascendantlogic 10y agoPerhaps then you haven't been paying attention to the news. I'm not some alarmist that thinks every cop is looking to kill people but given the number of high profile fatal interactions lately I think everyone is more on edge and I wouldn't blame anyone for attempting to de-escalate a situation instead of taking some militaristic "high road" to prove a point. To be sure, I realize the initial interaction was with what presumably is a security guard and not an actual LEO. However if the OP had taken a belligerent attitude it's not unreasonable to assume that law enforcement would have become involved quickly.
- Intermernet 10y agoIsn't their reasoning obvious? That stretch of water is perfect for terrorists to mount a dam-busters style assault on that building! What were you thinking publishing a photo like that? You'll only have yourself to blame when that building is knocked out by the bouncing bomb!
- dmreedy 10y ago> It was decided, I was going to take this photo. However, I was not going to take my time taking the photo. > The Port Authority's policy is not law. This is a public place, and I can photograph whatever I want. The rebelliousness seems a little hollow in the light of admission of being cowed. Of course, I'dve had similar thinking. Is this a known thing, that the Port Authority doesn't want this building photographed? I am unfamiliar with the situation.
- poidog22 10y agoIt's almost like he was more pissed off at himself for packing up originally. lol
- jrockway 10y agoYes, I am mad at myself for not just ignoring him, or not calling the police myself. However, I do like to sit down and consider things before making a decision. Did I want to get arrested? Not really. I got my photo and I didn't get arrested, so this is almost the best-possible outcome, right?
- headShrinker 10y agoI think some people don't understand that these corporations and the government have strong legal teams, that can do serious damage to an unsuspecting individual. jobs can be lost, public reputations can be ruined, not to mention financial damage and fines, or worse prison time for innocuous offenses, or physical harm and property damage from reckless violent police. edit: regulation -> reputation
- jrockway 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fort_Lee_lane_closure_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fort_Lee_lane_closure_scandal "The prevailing theory was that the lane closures were retribution against Fort Lee's Mayor Mark Sokolich (D) for failing to endorse Christie in the 2013 gubernatorial election. That motive was alleged by federal prosecutors in May 2015, in charges against Bridget Anne Kelly, former Deputy Chief of Staff for Christie, and Bill Baroni and David Wildstein, both of whom had been Christie-appointed officials at the Port Authority. Wildstein pleaded guilty. The indictment charged that the three conspired to commit fraud by illegally exploiting Port Authority resources for political ends." I don't have the resources to contend with the Port Authority.
- eykanal 10y agoCan someone clarify what the hell happened here? Why would anyone think that it is appropriate to object to a random person taking a photo of a random public building in one of the largest cities in the world, particularly given that there are tens of thousands of photos of this building already available freely online from virtually every angle?
- jrockway 10y agoNo idea. If I were being very cynical, I imagine that he had a "security training" and wanted to get an extra gold star. The Port Authority seems to think that photographers are Public Enemy Number One, even prohibiting selfies on their trains, technically. He seemed like a nice guy who cared about his job, maybe a civil engineer or something. He wasn't dressed as though he were in a security position, or anything. (His badge didn't say.)
- solotronics 10y agoThis whole scenario comes across as very dystopian.
- jrockway 10y agoIt's just one individual acting on his own authority. I don't think we're quite at dystopian levels yet. Merely annoying at this point.
- stcredzero 10y agoI don't think we're quite at dystopian levels yet. Oh no, we are. If you would consider the plight of a peasant in Tsarist Russia dystopian, then we are in the 21st century industrialized 1st world version already. We're definitely not too close to THX-1138 or 1984. But we are in the same quadrant as Brave New World and The Machine Stops.
- rbcgerard 10y agoafter 9/11 basically every employee of a federal building/critical piece of infrastructure + the associated security/police were on the look out for people "casing" their facilities, i.e. planning an attack, taking pictures etc. This eventually morphed into hassling, arresting anyone taking photos of these sites...link below has some good info https://stateimpact.npr.org/texas/2012/09/24/homeland-security-focuses-on-suspicious-activity-outside-refineries/ https://stateimpact.npr.org/texas/2012/09/24/homeland-securi...
- codingdave 10y agoThis is one of those situations where one's gut reaction to always respond to others is misplaced. This is NYC. I've only spent a few months there, but I saw my share of crazy people yelling at others. That is all this is. Someone who has no authority over you is yelling that some 3rd party wouldn't like what you are doing, even though what you are doing is legal, and you are not on their private property... so treat it like you would any other time you get yelled at by a stranger in NYC. Just ignore them and carry on.
- drzaiusapelord 10y agoA security guard with an pre-existing relationship with the cops who might pepper his statement with some drama that might or might not have happened to make sure you get either arrested or detained certainly has an authority over some random guy with a camera. Also, many police run on informal quotas and if there's a "letter of the law" arrest here then the cops will probably take it. The police not here to advocate for you and most are fairly ignorant of many important legal issues, especially in regards to civil rights. Why does everyone think calling the cops will magically solve everything and every cop is a honest truth teller immune from politics, bullshit, and bias? As someone who is classified as 'white' but has much darker skin than your average white person (I pass as arab easily), I can tell you, shit gets real when the cops are bothered and the guy closer to the bottom of the potem pole usually gets fucked, regardless of merit. The cops will just let the courts figure it out, so now you're in a cell, spending money on lawyers, etc because some high school drop-out making minimum wage as a security guard thinks you're a terrorist. Its just easier to just accept the bullying and go away. That's what the guy in the blog post pretty much did. He took a half-assed picture instead of the one he wanted and felt terrible after. How exactly did any of this make us safer? Who can he complain to? And if he did, who would even care? This shouldn't be the status quo in America.
- enraged_camel 10y agoNot sure why you were downvoted. I suppose some people just can't handle the truth, because you're absolutely correct. The police have the power to make your life hell, especially if someone reports you for "suspicious activity" and there is an even remotely plausible reason (e.g. "he is taking photos because he's planning a terrorist attack!").
- mc32 10y agoAs long as you're on public property you can take almost any photo --some exceptions exist for military installations, research facilities, etc. Private property owners can and do have the right to deny you the ability to take pictures from their land --so, as long as you are on public land (i.e. no restrictions to the public) you should be ok, in the US. Other countries can have different laws.
- sfrailsdev 10y agoWell, there are some provisions in California and other states meant to prevent photos only possible telephoto lens being taken of private property, because of photos of celebrities. Not sure what the legal consensus is on these, but I suspect there will be more consideration of such laws as drones become more normal and provide viewing angles that let you see over privacy fences. But a building without a private residence is fair game.
- ShakataGaNai 10y agoThe tldr on most laws about telephoto/private property/etc is "reasonable expectation of privacy". For example: If you stand on the sidewalk and take a picture of someone sunbathing nude on their front lawn, 10 feet away. Assuming there is no fence, you're perfectly in the right. Flip side someone sunbathing nude in their backyard with 10 foot fences, if you took a picture of them say using a drone... then they can go after you because they had a "reasonable expectation of privacy". Same thing with famous people in their backyard and the paparazzi who get out the 800mm lenses and take pictures from the next mountain over. The famous person could reasonably expect some privacy in their backyard.
- gohrt 10y ago"reasonable expectation" constantly changes in response to technology. The police and courts are fond of reminding citizens that they have no reasonable expectation of privacy when they store documents in cloud storage, for example.
- Finnucane 10y ago
- daveloyall 10y ago"The Port Authority" is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Port_Authority_of_New_York_and_New_Jersey https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Port_Authority_of_New_York_and... (There are, of course, many port authorities all over the world. This one is a big deal.)
- Roboprog 10y agoGoogle maps shows a nice view of it: https://www.google.com/maps/@40.7265257,-74.0139319,158m/data=!3m1!1e3 https://www.google.com/maps/@40.7265257,-74.0139319,158m/dat... May need to adjust the framing a bit.
- jrockway 10y agoWikipedia also has a picture. The Holland Tunnel is a civil engineering marvel, the first tunnel of its size to be built successfully. The ventilation towers are what allow cars to drive through such a long tunnel without asphyxiating the drivers. We should celebrate what we've achieved as a society, not try to hide them for vague security reasons.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Finnucane 10y agoWhen I lived in NYC, this sort of thing would happen every now and then. And never a real cop--always some pseudo-authority figure who thinks he's a cop and knows the law better than you. Got into quite an argument with a ConEd guy once. _Usually_ the easiest way to deal with it is the way this guy did--wait for the a-hole to go away, then come back for your photo. It happens less now that I don't live in New York any more, even when I am out with a big, conspicuous camera like an RB67 or one of my 4x5's. (Actually, then people are more curious than aggressive!)
- jrockway 10y agoEvery time I go out with my 4x5, I meet people that are interested in it. I took 6 photos yesterday and met three other photographers who were interested and were of course very pleasant and enjoyable to chat with. I also have a GW690ii that people ask me about all the time. I was even "stopped" by the police once (while in a somewhat precarious position to get the angle I wanted)... to tell me how cool the camera was. Film photography is really great for meeting people in public. The world is not all bad; it's 99.9% good. But the negatives tend to have a larger effect on your world view than the positives, so you should be careful to not bias yourself away from being different.
- Finnucane 10y agoI have one of those Fujis too--they're great. One time I was walking through downtown Boston with it, passed a family of tourists, and I hear the kid say "Dad! Did you see that guy's camera!" Yeah, most of the time, people are cool with it. Just, you know, people are people and some have to be difficult. And it's a common problem for photographers--some really have had dangerous run-ins with cops, physical threats, and so on.
- JoeDaDude 10y agoFWIW, the ACLU has some information about the legality of taking photographs in public spaces of objects that are in plain view [1]. See also, this guidance [2] issued by a law firm about taking photographs. Note that I am not a lawyer, or even a photographer, so I submit these as available information to consider, but I cannot offer any experience or guidance in using the information. [1] https://www.aclu.org/know-your-rights/photographers-what-do-if-you-are-stopped-or-detained-taking-photographs https://www.aclu.org/know-your-rights/photographers-what-do-... [2] http://www.krages.com/phoright.htm http://www.krages.com/phoright.htm
- Dowwie 10y agoIsn't that building where the Holland Tunnel's ventilation system is? I don't think they've adequately guarded this vulnerability too well if photographers are a concern.
- brianvan5155 10y agoIt is the ventilation building for the Holland Tunnel on the New York side; it's located directly above the tunnel, near the Manhattan portal. It's not accessible directly via the street. It sits out on a long pier in the river, with a gate at the pier head. The public isn't allowed on the pier, but the gate sits along the Hudson River Greenway, a very big and very-highly-trafficked park. (With plenty of tourists) It is common for both misinformed law-enforcement types and infrastructure agency employees (outside of the legal system) to hassle people for taking photos of infrastructure - construction sites, ventilation towers, power substations, sensitive landmarks, subway areas, aqueduct facilities, etc. As a matter of fact, since the WTC is itself treated as a VERY sensitive and vulnerable site, it seems weird for a PA employee to tell you to take pictures of it instead. The site is a fortress! And yes, these people issuing warnings and making threats are all wrong. You can stand in a public place and take a photograph anytime, there are very few restrictions on this. It's also fairly safe; there aren't any reasonable vulnerabilities to public infrastructure that a single photograph from a public park can uncover. (If there is such a vulnerability, it's not a reasonable one; it should be mitigated through security hardening, not by hassling park-goers)
- jrockway 10y agoThe pier on the left-hand side of my picture is actually a jogging path now; you can walk almost all the way down to the building. (The careful observer will also note that the public side of the path has nicer light fixtures than the private side.)
- dmourati 10y agoDetails from photojojo about photographer rights: http://content.photojojo.com/photo-technique/tips/legal-rights-of-photographers/ http://content.photojojo.com/photo-technique/tips/legal-righ... Reading between the lines a bit I suspect this passerby was relaying instructions he got in some kind of "security" training ostensibly about terrorism. If he discourages you from taking the photo, and a real security incident can be avoided, so much the better. If he overplays his hand and, for example, tries to restrain you at the scene, this causes a bigger story and a blemish to his employer at the very least. I think you handled it correctly. Bend, but don't break. Know your rights. Understand what is at stake and then decide if you want to risk standing your ground.
- blaze33 10y agoThis is an issue of freedom of panorama [1], there's the following citation for the US: The copyright in an architectural work that has been constructed does not include the right to prevent the making, distributing, or public display of pictures, paintings, photographs, or other pictorial representations of the work, if the building in which the work is embodied is located in or ordinarily visible from a public place. — 17 U.S. Code § 120(a) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_panorama https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_panorama
- smilekzs 10y agoI wish every time someone tries to assert too much authority on me (or any ordinary citizen) there is a way for me to quickly find these citations to my legal rights that I can point to them and tell them to F off......
- pfooti 10y agoKeep a few printouts of the PDF from here handy. Not saying that you'll be listened to, but at least you'll have resources to assert your rights. http://www.krages.com/phoright.htm http://www.krages.com/phoright.htm
- CaptSpify 10y agoI have a vague recollection of the EFF making an app to do this, but I can't seem to find it ATM. I wish someone would though!
- ShakataGaNai 10y agoAt one point in time I was taking pictures of random things around BART (SF Bay Area's medium rail system) stations... because... bored photographer. I had a employee first attempt to confiscate my camera and later threaten to call the BART cops (who are notorious for shooting first... and covering ass later). Ironically they do have a photo policy http://www.bart.gov/about/business/permits/photopermits http://www.bart.gov/about/business/permits/photopermits which isn't that different than it used to be. Basically as long as its non-commercial and you aren't sneaking in somewhere, it's fine. However that gate employee insisted what I was doing was illegal, private property (ha! PUBLIC transit), yada yada yada. Of course, this was only because I had a DSLR. I've taken way more informational photos with my phone and no one ever noticed.
- carapace 10y agoYou should have offered to take his picture. ;-) --- A guy I met who's an American-born Muslim (from Palo Alto) was returning to the US after a trip abroad (post 9/11) when he was pulled for a "random" extra discussion with some official. They sent him into another area and when he got inside, he told me, he looked to the right and there was one of those huge pictures of the then-President George W. Bush flanked by flags and everything and he just started cracking up. He turned to the official behind the desk and said, still laughing, "Can I ask you a question? Did you guys put that up there or did they make you put it up?" The official replied, "Go on through sir, I can tell you're really American."
- ergl 10y agoThis happened to me a few years ago. I was minding my own business taking pictures, when a police car stopped over and an officer asked me what I was doing. Apparently, I was near an official building, and they told me not to photograph in that street. I was told to "visit the website" if I wanted to look at pictures of that building. They then asked me to show them the pictures in order to check that I hadn't taken any photographs of that building, to which I replied that they were welcome to try, as I was using a film camera. They replied "okay, we believe you", and went away. Truly bizarre.
- musgrove 10y agoTalk about paranoid. I would have politely reminded that person this is America, and I'll take a picture of whatever I want. Have a nice day!
- criddell 10y ago> I don't think the Port Authority would like it if you looked at this photo Fortunately for them, it's on Google Plus. I kid. Kind of.
- rasz_pl 10y agoIf you like this stuff take a look at those: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQD8EVx5LZM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQD8EVx5LZM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sFSxxi7D4mM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sFSxxi7D4mM
- wheresvic1 10y agoThis is incredible. I read the article and I found it really hard to digest! Who uses Google+ anymore?
- paparush 10y agoFunny. You can Google Street View the shit out of it.
- mohaps 10y agoHmm, I wonder how's the pokemon population out there? That'd drive them nuts too! :D
- tombrossman 10y agoFor a truly ridiculous example of this, see this "Chaser's War On Everything" clip is which the same guy films a few different sites dressed as an American tourist, and later as a Saudi (in a thobe and gutra - had to look up the terms). The security response is hilarious in how differently they react when the clothing changes. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xxq4Y7QUdPA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xxq4Y7QUdPA (Bonus, watch the same clowns hire a limo + guys in suits jogging alongside and use that to get into a 'secure' conference site in the related video in the sidebar. Comedy gold.)
- slr555 10y agoIn the US virtually all public places and people are fair game for photographs. One has no legal expectation of privacy in public place in the US. That said, I am more qualified to be on commenting on petapixel than Hacker News. On photo web sites there are endless stories of overreach by individuals and institutions that attempt to limit a photographers right to take photographs in public. The situation in the USA is different than many other countries where photographing anyone associated with the military, any military installation and a great amount of "infrastructure" sites are off limits to photographers. So while the Port Authority probably has no legal standing to limit photography it is interesting to ask if they have any logical standing for doing so. In numerous texts on the topic of physical security this issue is addressed. Security experts typically say that persons taking video or photos of secured locations with particular regard to photos of perimeter security, lighting security and cameras might be viewed as suspicious actors. That common sense advice is taken to an absurd extreme here as it is highly unlikely that a threat actor would utilize a 4x5 camera, which is cumbersome, obvious and reliant on labor intensive film processing, on a tripod to take surveillance photos. I experienced a similarly absurd episode when taking a photo of the weathered hopper control levers of a NYC garbage truck. A sanitation worker informed me that it was not allowed to take photographs of NYC vehicles. While I was tempted to inquire what the strategic import of the garbage control levers was, I held my tongue, finished my pictures and left. As an example of how crazy people get at photographers check out: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=97hfxth3aas https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=97hfxth3aas
- lgleason 10y agoNice to see 4x5 photography. Love the look you get from t-max.
- jrockway 10y agoThanks! Tmax 100 is a difficult film. I tried overexposing it like crazy at first (which usually works well for B&W film if you're in doubt), but it doesn't respond well to that. You end up with no tonality; everything is black or white, and very contrasty. Now I meter the shadows, underexpose those by two stops, and check that the highlights are not too contrasty. This yields very good results. (My previous algorithm would be to take an incident light reading in the shadows, or expose the shadows as middle grey. It ends up being too much light for the film, you do have to take advantage of its "underexposure" range to get full tonality.) Acros seems to respond well to whatever exposure you throw at it, but it's significantly more expensive and yields identical results to Tmax when exposed carefully. (I save Acros for my pinhole pictures, where its amazing reciprocity characteristics are much appreciated.) Tmax 400 is a little different. Basically... if you expose it to light you'll get a great picture. It's my favorite film, but if I have a tripod, I might as well aim for a little bit more resolution. In some tests I did last weekend, the MTF-limiting function of my setup is actually the film, which is a nice place to be. These used large format lenses I've randomly acquired are some fine equipment.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoMy thing is watching trains. (Hey, everybody needs a hobby.) So I was in Salt Lake, at a place where I can watch both the UTA Frontrunner (commuter rail, but heavy rail, not transit) and the freight tracks, because they're side-by-side. There are some signals on the freight tracks that tell me when something's coming, and there's a station there on the passenger rail. I park on the opposite side from the passenger platforms, in the parking area for an abandoned business. One day these two UTA security guys came over to talk to me. They see me just sitting there watching their platform, and they're responsible for its security, so that's fine. But when I explained that I was just there watching trains, they tried to pressure me into leaving. I told them that I was on private property, and it wasn't their private property, so I didn't care what they preferred that I do. They backed off. I've been approached by police several times, asking what I was doing. Once I said that I was just watching trains, I was sometimes cautioned to be careful because I was in a drug trafficking area. Once I was hassled by railroad security, but in that instance I had parked on their property, so they were not out of line. They just asked me to move my car. Disclaimer: I am middle aged, white, and fairly conservative in appearance. I'm going to get the benefit of the doubt as much as anyone ever does.