5 ms·
I'm a software developer who focuses on operational automation, and this brings almost nothing to the table which I could want. Especially replacing the functio
by falcolas 10y ago
I'm a software developer who focuses on operational automation, and this brings almost nothing to the table which I could want. Especially replacing the function keys with a touchpad; why would I want to replace dedicated keys with muscle memory attached to them with soft keys that can change on whim?
Better graphics may be nice, if it's enough to allow me to drive a pair of high-resolution displays in addition to the laptop's screen itself. I'm not hopeful, though, due to the power and heat requirements.
As for thinner, at what cost? Battery life? Active cooling? A nasty keyboard like those in the new macbook? Losing even more ports?
Here's what I want in a MBP refresh: More power. Enough battery life to allow me on a hangout all day long; or at least enough battery life that I can have Chrome running and still be able to code all day long. A strong enough graphics card to smoothly drive a pair of 4k monitors in addition to the internal monitor. No loss of existing ports. More CPU power for compiling code. A touch screen.
- joshkpeterson 10y agoOh god. That function keys replacement has the potential to be SO BAD. Please don't force something down our throats unless it's actually more useful and usable Apple, we're trusting you. Please don't make software development a non-starter on Macbooks.
- NegatioN 10y agoWhy the touch screen? That seems like an odd addition to the list.
- ojbyrne 10y agoThe article describes a "secondary display" that is a "touch screen strip for function keys" No indication that the main display is going to be touch-enabled, at least not that I can see.
- dillera 10y agoI agree, a touch-screen on a 'pro' laptop (unless it's a 2-in-1) is useless. Also: Please don't ever, ever touch my laptop's screen.
- mason240 10y agoI have a Surface Pro with a touch screen and found it to be very useful and natural to use. The Surface is plugged into a dock for all my heavy work, so I'm not using the screen anyway. If I am using it as a laptop for more internet-browsing related work, the touchscreen is so useful that I don't need a mouse.
- mason240 10y agoI have a Surface Pro with a touch screen and found it to be very useful and natural to use. The Surface is plugged into a dock for all my heavy work, so I'm not using the screen anyway. If I am using it as a laptop for more internet-browsing related work, the touchscreen is so useful that I don't need a mouse.
- partisan 10y agoI had a co-worker who made threats against anyone whose hands came close to his screen. Even pointing at the screen was enough to get a look of death.
- realworldview 10y agoI am that person.
- partisan 10y agoRandall?
- criddell 10y agoI can't stand fingerprints on my monitor, but I don't even notice them on my phone or tablet. Before I got my first touchscreen phone, I was pretty sure the dirty screen would drive me bonkers, but that never happened.
- _JamesA_ 10y agoThat's probably because phones and tablets usually have oleophobic[1] surfaces. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lipophobicity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lipophobicity
- jon-wood 10y agoEspecially in a pro Macbook I could see it being really useful - think of all the people developing iOS applications on them. They can now run the simulator on the laptop display and have it pass touch events through to the simulated device.
- w0utert 10y agoAnd in addition to that, they should add an accelerometer for even more fun when testing shake and tilt gestures. ;-)
- evan_ 10y agoMacBooks have always had accelerometers, originally it was called the "sudden motion sensor" and was ostensibly used to park the hard drives in the event of a dropped computer. I'm pretty sure they're still in the modern MacBooks, though Google seems to be mixed on the matter.
- intoverflow2 10y agoIt is not because there is no need to park the HD
- mikestew 10y agoThat sensor was taken out with the SSD MBPs: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201666 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201666 (under Note at the top of the page.
- falcolas 10y agoSince I use an iPad on a relatively regular basis, I find myself reaching for the screen on my MacBook when it's on my lap and I'm reading the web. Scrolling through webpages with a touch on the screen is a natural gesture now; having to pull my hands back to the touchpad feels clunky in comparison. It's a minor wish, but a worthwhile addition, IMO.
- mikestew 10y agoIt's interesting that I hear these anecdotes, because as a user of touch screen devices pre-dating iOS, and every iOS device from 2nd-gen iPhone onward, not once have I ever caught myself reaching to touch the screen of my laptop or desktop monitor. I dunno, in my mind "handhelds are for touching, things with keyboards are not to have their screens touched under threat of bodily harm."
- smartcar 10y agoThe touch screen would be quite an exciting addition to a Macbook. Why? If you are an iOS developer, wouldn't it be great to try your app in the simulator directly on your monitor? You wouldn't have to keep an iOS device right besides you to try it out or use a cursor to simulate touches.
- xlayn 10y ago+1 We had a post about "we want a modern macbook" and your post was my post. As you I want a PRO version as in quad core, better graphics gazzillion of ports and cooling solution to keep everything running smoothly. But I think the PRO update will be inclined toward flashiness. I strongly believe we only have incremental updates to the pc as we know it. I have an ASUS ROG and it has a pair of HUGE fan vents on the back, that's the only way of keeping power running. Let's see what happens.
- Someone1234 10y ago> I have an ASUS ROG and it has a pair of HUGE fan vents on the back, that's the only way of keeping power running. Ditto. It isn't very mobile but holy heck is it an incredible developer machine. You really hear the huge cooling fans kick in when you hit compile on a large project.
- yoodenvranx 10y ago> "we want a modern macbook" All I want is a modern IBM T42 or T61 with a 14" screen. I don't care if it is ugly, big or weighs a ton. The only thing I care about is a good keyboard, a robust chassis and the fact that I can rebuild the whole thing with just a screwdriver.
- xlayn 10y agoWith you, I own an x220 and a x200t that has been running as a server for more than 2 years non stop. I'm in love with the magnesium industrial construction and as you mention the keyboard. In fact the keyboard is the thing that would prevent me from upgrading to a newer thinkpad. As for opening and maintaining the elitebook 2560 with it tool-less chassis is an option as well as possessing the eraser head option and good keyboard.
- lorenzhs 10y agoI recently swapped the mainboard of my T420, it was quite easy to do with just a screwdriver (and the maintenance manual and some thermal grease). Extended this five year old machine's life by another year or so for ~50€. It was very easy to do with the manual. I'm not sure how much harder it is with the newer models, but maybe a ThinkPad meets your requirements better than a MacBook?
- msravi 10y ago> or at least enough battery life that I can have Chrome running and still be able to code all day long Shouldn't that be an action for Google rather than Apple? Of late, I've found Google's applications to be big battery hogs - Chrome and Google Drive for example (on OS X)
- falcolas 10y agoHonestly, if it wasn't Chrome, it would be any of a number of other applications finding their way into our daily milieu. One of a dozen Electron based "desktop" apps. Firefox. Eclipse. I can even spin up the processor with VIM, if YCM or Anaconda addons have to do a lot of work. As developers, we use CPU for work, and we use it hard. A battery in a "pro" laptop should support that need.
- Alphasite_ 10y agoFirefox is nowhere near as big an offender as chrome. Chromes absolute disregard for me frankly offends me. Also, programs like IntelliJ do have low power mode, which does help significantly in my experience.
- falcolas 10y agoI won't argue that point - Chrome is a huge offender - but compared to Safari, they both leave a lot to be desired on the energy consumption front.
- specialist 10y agoAre there any knobs or dials (for any OS) for controlling how much battery (amps) an app (or task) is allowed to use? That'd be more directly useful to me than controlling CPU % utilization and so forth.
- anexprogrammer 10y agoYou've said what I was going to type. I don't want reason to look at the keyboard. I type faster when I keep eyes on screen. Responsive OLED display might be useful if on the bezel either side of the Macbook Pro logo, but it's really just more screen acreage there. Pro should be more of a powerhouse, with a decent keyboard I can actually type on for hours rather than minimalist chiclet keys with no travel. Enough that I can be encoding a movie, or compiling a big code base without it threatening to catch fire. Let me have a decent all day workload, not just email, editing and browsing. More power, more ports, 1/8" thicker if it gives me an all day workstation with better graphics and CPU horsepower. definitely no touchscreen for me though. Something more like a Thinkpad W series without the 2" thick brick effect. What I don't want is a bigger Macbook Air with pointless keyboard gimmick.
- acjohnson55 10y agoAgreed, the pre-Retina thickness is alright with me, assuming I get all these things in return.
- prh8 10y agoI agree with what you would like for the new MBP. One note, the 2015 MBP does smoothly drive dual 4Ks plus the internal. That's the set up I have at work right now. I just have the base model, and I'm not sure about the 2014 ones.
- acjohnson55 10y agoDon't forget storage! My home MBP is going on 6 years old, with no replacement in sight, because it can house an extra hard drive (in lieu of the optical) big enough to store my photos.
- coldtea 10y agoSo, to recap: place for extra hard drive, big enough battery to last all day, big juicy graphics card, very powerful cpu, ability to drive 1 pair of 4k monitors + internal screen, and all existing ports left. That would also need a shopping cart to carry it around, and oven mittens to touch it.
- coldtea 10y ago>I'm a software developer who focuses on operational automation, and this brings almost nothing to the table which I could want. Especially replacing the function keys with a touchpad; why would I want to replace dedicated keys with muscle memory attached to them with soft keys that can change on whim? For several reasons which are obvious to me. 1) You can of course leave the soft keys as the current function keys are -- and retain the "muscle memory", with losing nothing at all. 2) You can tune them to a specific app (e.g. Logic, Cubase, Premiere, Photoshop) and get a second (or third, etc) app-specific set of muscle memory for its shortcuts. People pay $50 or even $200 for custom app-related controllers for such apps, with buttons mapped to "transport controls" etc. I guess you don't suddenly lose your muscle memory when you press "SHIFT" and the number row becomes a different row (e.g. 3=>#, 4=>$ etc). So you shouldn't lose it with 2 or even 3 or more sets of soft keys to change depending on context. 3) You can even get behaviours that aren't possible with actual keys -- e.g. have the soft panel display a volume bar you drag on. 4) You can show information that's not related to keys -- e.g. the current cpu temp, new emails, notifications, "batch jobs completed" etc. Which could far more useful that "change brightness" that one does how often? Twice a day at most? >Here's what I want in a MBP refresh: More power. Enough battery life to allow me on a hangout all day long; or at least enough battery life that I can have Chrome running and still be able to code all day long. A strong enough graphics card to smoothly drive a pair of 4k monitors in addition to the internal monitor. No loss of existing ports. More CPU power for compiling code. A touch screen. Except the loss of ports, the others are not doable without ending up with a hotter and bigger machine, and some work against each other (better cpu + graphics VS better battery life). If they used a more powerful Intel CPU it would eat into the battery life, and same for graphics card -- especially when it would be driving "a pair of 4K + the internal monitor". In other words you want a desktop class workstation -- which would translate to something like a 4kg "laptop" -- and then you (or others) will complain that it's weighty, it gets too hot, etc (and nobody will buy it, except the kind of people who want the latest nvidia power card + pair of 4K monitors, that is, outliers). Lastly, even the touch screen doesn't make much sense without a detachable screen for ergonomic reasons. 5 minutes with your hand raised and it's off to the doctor for some painkillers. If they'd ever do it, they'd need something like the Surface Book's turnaround scheme, which would probably sacrifice sturdiness.
- 10y ago