3 ms·
This blog post is the reason why the NSA or any other government agencies do not want to declassify documents at all. What the blog post fail to understand is
by dogma1138 10y ago
This blog post is the reason why the NSA or any other government agencies do not want to declassify documents at all.
What the blog post fail to understand is that:
a) Intelligence operations run for years and decades, you wouldn't be hard pressed to find 5 documents over a period of 90 years which are cross referenced / linked by CODEWORD level programmes.
So if this document was referring "SPRING CRICKET" which references "SPRINGROLL" which references "CHINATOWN" which references "BOUNCY CASTLE" which might reference "PRISM" for all we know.
You don't give people bread crumbs.
b) Intelligence operations involve human assets, even if it was in the 1920's it can still have human assets who are alive or their descendants, and it doesn't have to be a US agent, it could be some soviet mathematician who passed information to the US (willingly or not) that has living descendants in modern day Russia and there is absolutely no reason to colossally fuck up their lives today by revealing that fact.
Declassifying information is a very expensive process you need to do a full impact analysis on every word in every paragraph and cross reference it with any other materials that are revealed, considering the age of these documents many of them might not be digitized which makes this process even more expensive and time consuming.
Beyond that once a document is set for release a very expensive process of document recovery is kicked off, all copies and revisions of the document must be collected to ensure that no revisions other than the approved for declassification and no unredacted copies remain to be found or leaked.
And once you release some document which is redacted if by some coincidence it is missed by the OSINT departments of foreign intelligence agencies some 'BuzzFeed' "reporter" that his next meal of cup ramen noodles is dependant on his daily blogspam quota will dig it up and make a click bait out of it and depending on how sensational they make out to be going to be picked up by some bigger news outlets and by then every counterintelligence outfit will step up their game if only to have a response to this for their next oversight hearing and if they kick their bug sweeps and mole hunts into high gear they might actually find something even it's completely unrelated.
The likelihood of a tool/method/source that has been used in 1925 being relevant today is about zero, the likelihood of them not being able to complete an impact analysis on that paragraph and hence having to redact it or not wanting to get the grandchild of some Russian asset harassed by the FSB the media and the immediate public is considerably more likely.