5 ms·
Typical example of poor graphics at work. You only have data once every 4 years yet they draw curves between each dot as if there was actual data in between. Th
by ekianjo 10y ago
Typical example of poor graphics at work. You only have data once every 4 years yet they draw curves between each dot as if there was actual data in between. This is extremely misleading.
Plus, I don't understand the necessity to put "Nazi Germany" after 1933. Based on all facts it was still a single, unified country at the time, no matter who was ruling it.
The "Other countries in Europe" represent a huge chunk of medals and should be separated at least by major countries, leaving only smaller amounts unseparated.
- Gravityloss 10y agoYou can think it the other way around. There's going to be some continuity as many athletes compete in many olympics during their career, even if it's "sampled" every four years. Also most often some sports scenes and countries experience cycles. I find it a lot easier to see those kind of things from continuous curves. Even if it's not so exact.
- yiyus 10y agoThe graphs are really bad. The problem I have is not the continuity, which as you say can help to identify trends, but the huge gap between two real data points. It should be clear what is real data and what is not (for example, using a linespoints graph), it really looks like there were medals won in non-onlympic years. The author focused too much on making beautiful graphs instead of just presenting the data.
- stinos 10y agoAnd maybe it's just me but I think colored lines would be clearer than those colored surfaces which seem to originate at 0 after the gapss.
- jameshart 10y agoBut when the big variations are caused by things like boycotts and the fact that games simply didn't take place, then this continuity argument doesn't really make sense. US Sports didn't slowly collapse from 1976 to 1980 then gradually recover through to 1984.
- pluma 10y agoRegarding "Nazi Germany", it's complicated: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_Reich#Divided_Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_Reich#Divided_Germany The Third Reich was legally the continuation of the Weimar Republic (both of which are just colloquial names, not formal identities of Germany at the time). Neither part of post-WW2 Germany was a full successor to the Third Reich until the Reunification (in which the Allies effectively ceded most of their control to what was formerly West Germany and East Germany ceased to exist). I'm not really sure under what basis "Nazi Germany" can be considered a separate legal entity from the pre-existing Weimar Republic without also considering the Weimar Republic a separate legal entity from the pre-existing German Empire of 1871.
- jameshart 10y agoCertainly feels like interesting stories about the changing fortunes of eastern european countries, and the fate of former soviet republics get subsumed into a blob which otherwise makes it just look like Europe mysteriously got much stronger from 1988 to 2000.