3 ms·
>A ban on ex post facto law is such a core concept in Western civilization that it's pretty shocking anyone would actually think such a rule is a good idea. No
by mthoms 10y ago
>A ban on ex post facto law is such a core concept in Western civilization that it's pretty shocking anyone would actually think such a rule is a good idea.
Not really a fair comment IMHO. Western Civilizations also have the core concept that intent matters and that not every potential conflict/problem can be foreseen. Thus, you have vaguely worded laws that are subject to human interpretation (courts).
I understand that ETH billed itself as being above all that. So I can see why some are justifiably upset. I just think your comment about ex post facto law is a little misleading given that there is, in fact, a great deal of wiggle room afforded to the courts in the West.
- grandalf 10y agoFair point. While I think smart contracts are somewhat modeled after Western courts, the beauty of them is that they are predictable and deterministic. Doing various sorts of forks is quite messy, so perhaps the ideal smart contract system would have another layer between VM and forking.