3 ms·
I started writing some point-by-point comments about your essay, but that ended up long enough to just make me seem like a jerk. Anyway, I have issues with eve
by jacobolus 17y ago
I started writing some point-by-point comments about your essay, but that ended up long enough to just make me seem like a jerk.
Anyway, I have issues with everything from your premise (“generating insight is trivial”), through your specific structure (how you classify these argument styles), and the examples you use to back them up (several of which I think are either trivial or wrong), to the language at the word level (words like “actionable” are just MBA technobabble).
My suggestion would be to read a couple books on rhetoric, or maybe on construction of philosophical arguments. These topics have been studied intensively (insightfully!) since at least the Greeks.