2 ms·
> Let me ask you, what if you and I enter a contract where I will pay you $10 to pull a string of my choice and you agree. After you enter the contract I show y
by pavel_lishin 10y ago
> Let me ask you, what if you and I enter a contract where I will pay you $10 to pull a string of my choice and you agree. After you enter the contract I show you the string and it is tied off to a trigger on a gun pointed to someones head
I think this analogy is very flawed, because I could inspect the DAO code before investing in it. The string doesn't lead off-stage.
- logfromblammo 10y agoEven if it is flawed, the contract never said I couldn't untie or cut the string before pulling it (or move the head away from the gun). So I remove the string from the trigger, pull it, and walk away with $10. This illustrates the difficulty with rigid computer-enforced contracts. Clearly, both parties violated the intent of the contract by strict, bloody-minded adherence to its literal terms. The cleverest, most obfuscated contract writer thus wins against everybody but the cleverest, most analytic contract disassembler.
- pavel_lishin 10y ago> Even if it is flawed, the contract never said I couldn't untie or cut the string before pulling it (or move the head away from the gun). So I remove the string from the trigger, pull it, and walk away with $10. Again, this is not an accurate analogy to the DAO contract, which I could fully inspect, and even theoretically run in a sandbox environment myself. Your analogy is more akin to what actually happened, which is that people said, "nah, we didn't mean that", and re-tied the string to something else.
- h1d 10y agoI agree that is the current state but if that is going to be the case for time to come, I doubt it will fly as every investor needs to be the cleverest. If nothing is learned by the devs and if all they do is make investers look less angry, this project is not going anywhere.
- logfromblammo 10y agoThe same problem exists in non-networked investment vehicles. Clever people can create derivatives and convince less-clever people to buy them, not realizing that the math actually simplifies out to "heads, I win: tails, you lose". The capital markets industry has never been able to keep clever people from making a little more money for themselves at the expense of a lot of money that would otherwise have gone to investors. At least with ETH and its future competitors, the specific sort of cleverness that is required to profit is very close to the cleverness that I now possess. Not saying I'd put a dollar that I can pay actual bills with into ETH right now, just that it seems more approachable to me than traditional investment, barring only the low-fee index funds. But those are plenty good enough for me right now, as I tend to shy away from games of skill where merely good players are routinely slaughtered by expert hustlers.
- will_brown 10y agoThe analogy was not to reflect the DAO but for the moral question: >Do I have a moral obligation to perform a contract that I entered only as a result of fraud? Further, I acknowledge it is an extreme, and offered a more real world example (which coincidentally includes the opportunity for review)...I represent the contents of a Will to your parent and they sign over everything to me because I told them it would go to you, sure they were on their death bed so it was more practical to rely on my representations (DAO marketing material) than read the Will/contract (DAO code) but they had the opportunity. Also lets assume there was no separate issue of lack of capacity in this example, because the would be a separate legal defense. What is your moral obligation?
- EdHominem 10y agoYour questions posit that you're offering a deal you know is bad because you yourself rigged it. We have no reason to think that Slock.it took the currency, or intended to (unfairly) get any share of it. Their statements look stupid but honest. A better question would involve: "... but without me knowing, the banks simultaneously crashed, devaluing our currency so the payout is worthless ..."
- pavel_lishin 10y agoAgain, caveat emptor. The code is readable and runnable by everyone. In this case, the analogy is entering a contract without reading the contract.