3 ms·
This leads to a strange outcome where the government needs to execute X people per year to ensure it retains the right to execute people in the future.
by tedunangst 10y ago
This leads to a strange outcome where the government needs to execute X people per year to ensure it retains the right to execute people in the future.
- dragonwriter 10y agoNot necessarily. If something is widely accepted, both domestically and globally, as the standard punishment for a particular crime that is itself infrequently encountered, than that punishment for that crime is not unusual, even if the crime itself is unusual.
- harryh 10y agoSo you're saying that the laws under which Americans are governed shouldn't be up to Americans but should be, at least for some things, up to people who live in other countries?
- dragonwriter 10y ago> So you're saying that the laws under which Americans are governed shouldn't be up to Americans but should be, at least for some things, up to people who live in other countries? No, I'm not making any normative statement about what laws should be. I'm pointing out a fairly direct reading of the plain language actually adopted in the 8th Amendment. Which, in any case, was drafted and ratified by Americans, and so, whatever interpretation of it is correct, is not an example of the law under which Americans are governed being up to anyone but Americans.
- lmm 10y agoIs that really so strange? (And you seem to be ascribing a level of intent/purposefulness to the government that I doubt exists)
- tedunangst 10y agoEver been in an organization with use it or lose it budget rules? The government, or the people in it, like to keep their options open.