4 ms·
So what constitutes a digital currency? I mean, I've heard arguments that BTC is really an asset being traded. Didn't see that Also: looks like proposed fee
by r00fus 10y ago
So what constitutes a digital currency? I mean, I've heard arguments that BTC is really an asset being traded. Didn't see that
Also: looks like proposed fee has been increased to $5000 from $500 (didn't look for other details).
Amusing that legalese is essentially similar to code, but without variable declarations (ie, $digitalcurrency := "currency that's traded online, including but not restricted to BTC, etc") it's a bit of a nightmare to parse.
- dragonwriter 10y agoFrom the proposed law: “Digital currency” means any digital representation of value that can be digitally traded and is used to facilitate the sale, purchase, and exchange of goods, services, or other digital representations of value among its users. Digital currency does not include fiat currency, e-money, or currency value of which was fixed by its issuer to the value of a fiat currency.
- jsprogrammer 10y agoMissing is a definition of what "value" is. My Bitcoin is a digital representation of the bits needed to solve a particular block. It doesn't represent value, but a numerical solution to a mathematical problem.
- dogecoinbase 10y agoPlaying dumb only makes you look dumb. Judges/legislators/basically everyone can see right through this kind of pretense and aren't particularly sympathetic to the "b...but I'm technically correct!" stance.
- jsprogrammer 10y agoTechnically correct is the only kind; no pretense needed. >Playing dumb only makes you look dumb.
- smokeyj 10y ago> and aren't particularly sympathetic to the "b...but I'm technically correct!" stance. That stance is called the rule of law and being technically correct matters. That's the whole point of that court thing. http://time.com/money/4421955/bitcoin-miami-judge-money-laundering/ http://time.com/money/4421955/bitcoin-miami-judge-money-laun...
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> the rule of law and being technically correct matters As one of many factors. The rule of law does not suspend human reason and common sense. SCOTUS recently ruled in favour of original intent over a strictly structural in an ACA case, where the later would have meant literally interpreting a likely typo [1]. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/courts_law/obamacare-survives-supreme-court-challenge/2015/06/25/af87608e-188a-11e5-93b7-5eddc056ad8a_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/courts_law/obamacare...
- shepardrtc 10y agoIt represents the resource and infrastructure investment needed to calculate the solution to a block. The resource being electricity, and the infrastructure being the computer and any peripherals needed (i.e. expensive video card).
- Spivak 10y agoIt represents the resource and infrastructure investment needed to produce the note. The resources being ink and paper, and the infrastructure being the machinery, labor, electricity, gas and trucks needed. You're not really arguing that currency derives its value from the material cost of producing it, are you? Because then everything is a currency. Modern currencies are special precisely because they have much more value than their material cost.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Missing is a definition of what "value" is. Laws typically don't incorporate definitions of words used when they aren't used in a special sense in the law. > My Bitcoin is a digital representation of the bits needed to solve a particular block. No doubt. > It doesn't represent value, The "X needed for Y" have value to the extent Y has value; I would suggest that there is considerable evidence which might be marshaled that solving Bitcoin blocks has value. So, I would think that your explanation of what Bitcoin does represent supports the conclusion that it is a digital representation of value, not that it is not such a representation.
- jsprogrammer 10y agoThe word is very special to this law as it is the core word defining "Digital Currency": >“Digital currency” means any digital representation of value You can't classify something as digital currency without knowing what value means or how to measure it.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> The word is very special to this law as it is the core word defining "Digital Currency": It may be important to this law, but that doesn't mean that it is used specially (as in, in any but its most contextually-obvious general-use sense) in the law. I mean, the meaning of "is" is also very important to the meaning of most laws, but is rarely defined in the enactment. > You can't classify something as digital currency without knowing what value means True, but that doesn't take a non-standard, law-specific definition. > or how to measure it. Untrue -- quantification of value is not relevant to the definition.
- jsprogrammer 10y agoIf you show me a method of quantification, I can derive the definition. Value is being discussed (even though you appear to be using an unrevealed definition) as a quantity (maybe, I am wrong, and it is not a quantity), which means there must be a way to quantify it.
- 10y ago
- r00fus 10y agoSo do things like Microsoft points or rewards work the same way? What about stocks/bonds? I find it amusing that the exempt e-money while targeting "digital currency". What exactly is the distinction?
- dragonwriter 10y ago> So do things like Microsoft points or rewards work the same way? Well, they might be digital currency under the definition, but that kind of rewards program appears to be excluded from the (rather lengthy) definition of "digital currency business", which would mean the regulations would generally not apply to them. > What about stocks/bonds? What about them? > I find it amusing that the exempt e-money while targeting "digital currency". What exactly is the distinction? Again, from the proposed bill at the link: “E-money” means a digital representation of fiat currency used to electronically transfer value denominated in fiat currency.
- lijason 10y ago>I find it amusing that the exempt e-money while targeting "digital currency". I think this is because financial institutions dealing with fiat currencies already have significant regulations that is not intended to apply to.
- milcron 10y agoLegalese does have variable declarations, they just look a little different and are used more sparingly. For example, look at section 17 of Facebook's terms of service: https://www.facebook.com/terms https://www.facebook.com/terms The interesting part about legalese is that you get to argue with the compiler.