11 ms·
I think a very important point was raised though. Before crypto, basically all guarantees where conditional on a judge's say so. With crypto this changes. The
by rocqua 10y ago
I think a very important point was raised though.
Before crypto, basically all guarantees where conditional on a judge's say so. With crypto this changes. The issue also comes up, in a clearer way, with crypto currencies. There is no way to deal with fraud or mistaken tranfers in bitcoin.
That loss of intervention hurts, and we gotta think about it. Even though no government has given a satisfactory solution, that doesn't mean there isn't a problem in need of solving.
- Semiapies 10y agoBefore crypto, basically all guarantees where conditional on a judge's say so Tell that to J. Edgar Hoover.
- rocqua 10y agoThat just shows they were conditional on things beyond a judge's say so. I.e. security can also be broken by people willing to break the law.
- Semiapies 10y agoOne day I will actually see someone write a response starting with "that just shows" that doesn't boil down to "My being wrong shows that I'm actually right. Somehow."
- wongarsu 10y ago>There is no way to deal with fraud [...] in bitcoin Don't we have an extensive legal system to deal with fraud? The fact that a lot of payment providers elect to deal with fraud themselves probably shows that that legal system isn't working as smoothly as it should; but that's really something that should be fixed in the legal system, not in the payment channel.
- sliverstorm 10y agoPart of the way the legal system deals with fraud is by recovering money (where possible). With bitcoin, unless the destination wallet can be obtained, that is not possible. With cash, you seize the cash. Bank accounts can be frozen, Credit card transactions canceled, wire transfers flagged (http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2016/01/29/464859624/episode-680-anatomy-of-a-scam http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2016/01/29/464859624/episo...).
- icebraining 10y agoWith cash, unless the wallet in which it resides can be obtained, that is not possible. I fail to see the difference.
- mediaman 10y agoI agree, the legal system doesn't do well when it comes to recovering cash from entities that can hide it. You can get a legal judgment against a company, but if it's fly-by-night, it winds up being a worthless piece of paper, and can become very difficult to recover.
- cbsmith 10y agoThe law does actually have ways of extracting cash from people even when it can't locate the cash in question. It's harder, and less effective, but overall it works more than it doesn't.
- icebraining 10y agoYes, but that works the same for Bitcoin.
- cbsmith 10y agoIt could work the same for Bitcoin. It actually works better with Bitcoin as there actually is a complete transaction log. However, the law has frequently decided it can't treat Bitcoin like it treats cash, which has created problems...
- cbsmith 10y ago> Before crypto, basically all guarantees where conditional on a judge's say so. Sadly, they weren't. > With crypto this changes. Actually, with crypto it is much harder to claim that a judge's authorization isn't required to even try to subvert the privacy intent. > There is no way to deal with fraud or mistaken tranfers in bitcoin. There's no way because legally the system (for the most part) considers it outside the scope of fraud laws. > That loss of intervention hurts, and we gotta think about it. TLS doesn't create a real loss of intervention. It requires that the intervention be far more explicit and/or targeted.
- rocqua 10y ago> with crypto it is much harder to claim that a judge's authorization isn't required to even try to subvert the privacy intent. No doubt, but the issue is that a judge's authorization can be ineffective in the face of crypto. > TLS doesn't create a real loss of intervention. It requires that the intervention be far more explicit and/or targeted. That targeted intervention is really easy to block for those who want too. All it takes is not revealing a key/passphrase. > There's no way because legally the system (for the most part) considers it outside the scope of fraud laws. Not just that though, it is also impossible because the conditionals introduced by a court system are very hard to encode in a crypto system, even more so if you want to do this and be able to retain trust.
- cbsmith 10y ago> No doubt, but the issue is that a judge's authorization can be ineffective in the face of crypto. Only when it should be. Crypto just means you need a secret to access the data. If you can't compel the secret, why should you be able to compel the data? > That targeted intervention is really easy to block for those who want too. All it takes is not revealing a key/passphrase. You say that like it is an easy thing. Try keeping your key/passphrase protected against an adversary that can replace/intercept your keyboard, your touch screen, your mouse, your network, etc. It's just a lot more intrusive and a lot more work, which is why it has to be far more explicit and targeted. > > There's no way because legally the system (for the most part) considers it outside the scope of fraud laws. > Not just that though, it is also impossible because the conditionals introduced by a court system are very hard to encode in a crypto system, even more so if you want to do this and be able to retain trust. Those conditionals were all choices made by the legal system. Those rules can always be changed if so desired. If they aren't... maybe it is because they shouldn't be. ;-)
- mindslight 10y agoThis point is a tired falsehood. There have always been phenomena with physical rules that supersede any human decision. The legal system recognizes and works with such boundaries - some even end up codified in our highest laws such as the 5th amendment. We're only in this present quandary because of professionally irresponsible "web 2.0 services" that siloed up user data for their own surveillance goals, creating enticing targets for governments' desires of control.
- EGreg 10y agoWhen everything is decentralized, it's going to be much harder to enforce any rules about no-crypto. For now things like social networks are cenetralized, leading to all these temptations to mine the data. It's not just government who wants youd data - it's every organization! http://magarshak.com/blog/?p=169 http://magarshak.com/blog/?p=169
- Retric 10y agoUntil very recently 99.99% of conversations where completely private and society functioned just fine. Even with crypto everywhere the governments have far more access to what people say and do than they had for thousands of years. People with power pretend if they just had more power everything would be better. But, reality is if everything on a computer where private not much would change.
- ori_b 10y ago> Until very recently 99.99% of conversations where completely private and society functioned just fine. Until very recently, most conversations were plausibly deniable, and off the record. The internet and cryptography changes that. Edit: [Both plausibly deniable in the formal/cryptographic sense, and in the informal "You're misremembering, there's no record in writing of me saying that" sense]
- djsumdog 10y ago> The internet and cryptography changes that. By Internet, I think you mean phonographs, magnetic tapes and pocket recorders. Cryptography brings some of that back.
- Taek 10y agoTo get access to those, you needed warrants, and you didn't get to listen in on every conversation, only targeted conversations. On the Internet, you have full access to pretty much everything I've ever said to somebody. They aren't equivalent.
- dpark 10y ago> Until very recently 99.99% of conversations where completely private and society functioned just fine. In fairness, until very recently it was also extremely difficult for two people to privately plot to murder hundreds. Technology has changed the balances on a lot of scales. To be clear, I'm not advocating for government back doors in encryption here. But I am saying we should not pretend that encryption just puts things back "the way they were". It most definitely does not.
- bsder 10y ago> There is no way to deal with fraud or mistaken tranfers in bitcoin. This is a social problem of bitcoin. The bitcoin people consider this a feature. However, it can be dealt with at an exchange. "MyBitcoinExchange(tm) only allows transfers to other members of MyBitcoinExchange(tm) and yourself. All transfers will be escrowed for 5 days to ensure that they are not fraudulent." The problem is: nobody in bitcoin would use that exchange. People who want non-traceable will stay away. People who are using it to sequester wealth out of countries will stay away. People who want fast liquidity will stay away. etc. So, who's left? Um, people who are perfectly adequately handled by existing credit cards, thanks.
- Taek 10y ago> With crypto this changes. It shouldn't. Listening in on a conversation should be illegal whether or not the conversation is encrypted. But we realized that if we weren't encrypting our conversations that our rights were being illegally infringed upon, so we started taking matters into our own hands.