4 ms·
Does this mean that there are now two Ethereum blockchains running concurrently?
by pavel_lishin 10y ago
Does this mean that there are now two Ethereum blockchains running concurrently?
- hakanderyal 10y agoYes, ETC(original) and ETH(forked). You can find some comparisons at http://www.etc-eth.com/ http://www.etc-eth.com/
- cypherpunks01 10y agoI suppose that implies that I can "double spend" my ETH that were bought pre-fork, then? Where can I do this?
- sputknick 10y agoYou'll need to use a splitter function. Shapeshift.io has one available. You will need to set up a new ETH and ETC address beforehand.
- DSMan195276 10y agoKinda. You can't do a regular double spend, where you spend the same currency twice (And thus get twice the value out of it, kinda). You could spend the coins in ETH, and then spend the coins in ETC, two different currencies worth different amounts. The catch is that there is no guarantee you come out ahead, like there would normally be with a double spend. The fork resulted in a price drop (That has now somewhat recovered), and ETC is not worth nearly as much as ETH (About a 10:1 ratio). So ETC+ETH is really not worth much more then ETH was originally before the fork, if it is at all - even if you spend both, you probably didn't make any money on the fork itself.
- gus_massa 10y agoI don't have hard numbers. Let's suppose that you had 1ETH(old), then now you have 1ETH(new) + 1ETC, and you can expend both. The 1ETC(new) in the forked chain and the 1ETC in the unforked chain. But the price dropped, so if you had $1 in the ETH(old) then now you have $0.80 in ETH(new) and $0.2 in ETC, so you didn't get free money, only free tokens that you can try to exchange for money in the right place. (Actually, I guess that the sum after the split is lower because some investor ruined away, so the numbers can be $1->$.7+$.2 or something.) And beware that since both have the same underlaying technology, then some can copy some transactions from one blockchain to the other, because the signature to transfer the coins is the same in both chains. The solution is to make two "tainted" versions of the coins that are disallowed to transfer in the other chain. Read the sibling comment about the "splitter function".
- lsseckman 10y agoYes. Though of course only one (ETH) is the 'official' Ethereum chain. But that in and of itself is being debated.
- ChrisClark 10y agoUgh, yes. The minority who didn't want the hard fork have continued to use the old chain. They constantly try to promote it and troll the 'bailout chain'. It was supposed to be a vote on whether to fork or not, then leave the deprecated chain behind. The vote for the fork succeeded, and all the developers of Ethereum and 99% of the developers for apps on the chain have decided to go with the vote. Everything is being done on the main chain, ETH, Ethereum. The old deprecated chain is now called ETC, they named themselves Ethereum Classic.
- vectorpush 10y agoWhy ugh? They want to support the old chain for ideological reasons, what's the problem with that? Isn't that the whole point of these blockchain systems (i.e. that a centralized authority does not control the system)? I am a pretty big blockchain critic, but schadenfreude aside, I think the eth/etc split is a decent demonstration of the fact that these systems have legitimate resistance to centralized authority, even when ethereum's influential creator is the authority. It's not stable and eth's buggy contracts are not reliable, but as far as blockchain money goes it has lived up to the ideals of the enthusiasts.
- joosters 10y agoThe vitriol in r/ethereum is an amazing sight. There are cult-like levels of declarations of support for either chain. It's astounding, considering both chains are basically the same system, and that prior to the DAO 'theft', everyone seemed to be proponents of the 'code is law' viewpoint. How quickly things change, and how little time it takes for people to switch their beliefs and villify those who still hold the old beliefs. It's certainly fun to watch the fallout...
- empath75 10y agoIt's about the same as your typical video game console war, really.
- 10y ago