3 ms·
SOPA's defeat was a big win. There is almost no political engagement from the technology sector, as compared to others (like pharmaceuticals, finance, telecoms
by theandrewbailey 10y ago
SOPA's defeat was a big win.
There is almost no political engagement from the technology sector, as compared to others (like pharmaceuticals, finance, telecoms, entertainment). If there had, the DMCA might not be so onerous, the CFAA would be gone, and SOPA would never have gotten as far as it did.
- Bartweiss 10y agoSOPA is probably the biggest recent achievement from activism (unless you want to count Wheeler and the Title II decision). But tellingly, activism has failed to solidify a victory there. It was COICA, then SOPA, then PIPA, then ACTA, and now TPP, all pushing a bunch of the same core changes. Whenever there's resistance, the thing goes into hiding and comes back wearing new clothes. Lately, it's been handled in settings where debate happens behind closed doors and domestic activism has little power. And yes, that might look different if major corporate players were more involved. But their stances are varied and inconsistent at best, and to the extent that this is for the benefit of private citizens the political approach appears to be an endless defensive fight.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoI wonder. I've seen people on HN saying that Google is one of the biggest lobbyist, so apparently tech sector is very much present in Washington. So maybe it's not that there is no engagement, but that those who engage have different goals in mind than your average HNer?
- icebraining 10y agoGoogle (Alphabet) has been spending way more than previously, but the "Internet" industry as a whole doesn't even reach the top 20: https://www.opensecrets.org/lobby/top.php?showYear=2015&indexType=i https://www.opensecrets.org/lobby/top.php?showYear=2015&inde...
- sliverstorm 10y agoPerhaps even inherently opposite goals. Google, Facebook, et al make it their business to peel away your privacy and know everything about you.
- Grishnakh 10y ago>There is almost no political engagement from the technology sector, as compared to others That's because the tech sector is busy actually doing useful stuff and inventing world-changing technologies. Pharma only does some of that (their pace of innovation is quite lackluster, and they spend more on marketing than on R&D, the real medical innovation is being done by other entities), finance is figuring out how to make money from a bad economy with hedge funds, telecoms are just exploiting their monopolies and screwing customers over, and entertainment is just rehashing old stuff with never-ending low-quality remakes, reboots, sequels, and prequels. Instead of trying to use politics to make more money by screwing people over (which is how other industries mostly work), the tech sector makes money by creating new technologies. It's a fundamentally different mindset.
- phkamp 10y agoNo, that is not why. The reason why the tech sector does not engage in politics, is that people feel they are above politics and "don't want to get dirty". Further more, they're sure the laws doesn't matter on the Internet anyway, right ?
- throwanem 10y agoJohn Perry Barlow has a hell of a lot to answer for.