9 ms·
Interesting regarding USB devices. When US DoD systems were infected with a virus someone brought from home on a USB stick, I remember hearing there were going
by rdtsc 10y ago
Interesting regarding USB devices. When US DoD systems were infected with a virus someone brought from home on a USB stick, I remember hearing there were going around filling USB ports with epoxy. There was some method behind the madness I guess.
There is also a market for routers and other devices which are produced as much as possible in US (are they rolling their own capacitors I am wondering...). I saw some of those devices come with a 100x markup. $400 device from China vs $40k from US. Those who sell the $40k know how hard it is get on the list they are milking it for all its worth (the sales person was quite frank about it).
It was also funny to see "Windows" as an approved security blessed OS and then Debian, Ubuntu, OpenBSD rejected (with only ancient version of RHEL's approved for Linux).
- dghughes 10y ago>I remember hearing there were going around filling USB ports with epoxy. And we all laughed at PS/2 keyboards and mouseeses
- 13of40 10y agoYou can boot an original IBM PC off the keyboard port. Look for the MFG_BOOT function here: https://www.iee.et.tu-dresden.de/~kc-club/DOWNLOAD/DISK401/ROMBIOS.ALL https://www.iee.et.tu-dresden.de/~kc-club/DOWNLOAD/DISK401/R... Basically, the device connected to the keyboard port has to reply with code 0x65 when it's initialized, then the BIOS will read some bytes into memory and jump to it. Not sure whether this was brought forward to newer models or clones, though so it's just some fun trivia...
- rangibaby 10y agoThe original IBM PC switch was like the back switch on current PSUs. If it were on it would be booting anyway, right?
- fl0wenol 10y agoI wouldn't call RHEL 6 ancient. Thankfully this may be going away at some point in the future, leaving it up to agencies to certify products or stacks on their own merits, or to instead have them be evaluated for specific purposes if sold as solutions: https://www.niap-ccevs.org/Documents_and_Guidance/ccevs/GPOS%20Position%20Statement.pdf https://www.niap-ccevs.org/Documents_and_Guidance/ccevs/GPOS...
- drzaiusapelord 10y ago>filling USB ports with epoxy This seems apocryphal. Its trivial to disable USB for a mass storage (or all devices) via things like group policy or other security controls. Or disable the controller. Those USB ports aren't perfect boxes, the epoxy would just run out all over the place. More than likely you'd have an OS-level security policy and bios block, which is trivial to do in a managed environment. I hear this type of story from time to time and frankly its the sysadmin version of "he hacked us with a visual basic gui!" >$400 device from China vs $40k from US. I'd rather trust my network with a warrantied Cisco with same-day replacement than a $400 Abibaba sourced ROUTER PLUS SHENZEN SPECIAL with two weeks delivery. I suspect you've never managed a non-trivial network before, let alone one with real security policy if you'd consider running that and thinking you're secure.
- Florin_Andrei 10y ago> This seems apocryphal. Its trivial to disable USB for a mass storage (or all devices) via things like group policy or other security controls. Or disable the controller. The question is - where do you stop? The controller could be re-enabled from a lower level, etc. The rabbit hole goes very deep. Sometimes it's best to just take control of the physical layer and call it a day. > Those USB ports aren't perfect boxes, the epoxy would just run out all over the place. Epoxy putty would work pretty well, and it's widely available.
- wlesieutre 10y agoThere's also value in being able to visually inspect it and say "Yep, that USB port's disabled" versus digging through EFI settings. Every motherboard is going to have that option in a slightly different place, but if you can put epoxy in one USB port you're pretty well set for any piece of hardware.
- viraptor 10y agoThis scales to ${number_of_devices_you_can_see}. A hundred or more? Easier to manage remotely. You're also likely to have a very limited number of models in that case.
- Endy 10y agoToo many people without security clearance can access and modify Linux. In any real security environment, open-source is poison. Period, end of story.
- jjbiotech 10y ago^ As if any amount of security clearance can erase human fallibility. In any real security environment, humans are poison. Period, end of story. This is not an issue exclusive to open-source.
- 794CD01 10y agoOf course not, but it's exacerbated by open source. Humans are indeed poison, which is why it's normal to involve as few humans as possible. Unfortunately AI is not sufficiently advanced so you still need some of them in order to get the job done.
- jrowley 10y agoSo security through obscurity?
- PeCaN 10y agoOr maybe security through, you know, actual security. Closed source does not mean obscurity–– and open source does not mean clarity (see OpenSSL, that one Linux 2.6 thing¹, etc). It's not like being proprietary suddenly means the only security is through obscurity. Why do you think that? Are you just a zealot? Did you not consider that closed source software could be well-engineered and secure? You're welcome to read about some of the security features in Windows NT² (that article is a bit old but still relevant), which are considerably more thorough than (non-SE)Linux (I think SELinux has auditing now, so it's at least comparable to NT). Now, don't get me wrong, I generally prefer open-source tools (for a variety of reasons) and tend to trust them more, but saying stupid stuff like you are just gives open source a bad name. On top of that, obscurity is a perfectly valid layer of security. To use a mediocre analogy, of course you want your safe to be strong enough that nobody could break in even if it's in plain sight—but it's certainly not a bad idea to hide the safe as well. ¹ https://lwn.net/Articles/341773/ https://lwn.net/Articles/341773/ ² https://www.microsoft.com/resources/documentation/windowsnt/4/workstation/reskit/en-us/security.mspx https://www.microsoft.com/resources/documentation/windowsnt/...
- AWildDHHAppears 10y agoAnd that's why you can still buy new i7 and Xeon motherboards with PS2 keyboard connectors--because some sites don't want there to be USB ports on the computers.
- Ntrails 10y agoMy computer is locked in a mesh cage anyway. Well, the thin client is.
- AWildDHHAppears 10y agoThat's another great idea! Like the cages around thermostats!
- WalterBright 10y agoJust put the software in the device in ROM, a forgotten technology. No malware will survive a power cycle. It's like I read that malware could infect your "internet of things" thermostat and then hackers could remotely turn off your heat until you pay ransom. Just put the dang thermostat code in ROM. Power cycle, goodbye malware. For more critical stuff, just have it regularly power cycle itself.
- infinite8s 10y agoThen you can't do over the wire updates, which means no fixes after it's been manufactured and installed, which would probably increase the costs quite a bit.
- WalterBright 10y ago> Then you can't do over the wire updates, Which, of course, is the whole point. If ROMs do cost more, I bet people who want secure systems would be quite willing to pay a bit extra. It would be too expensive to put an OS in ROM, but the ROMs could contain the hashes of the OS on disk, and can verify the disk image before booting. And besides, why would I want over-the-air updates to my freakin' thermostat?
- WalterBright 10y agoAnother way is to have a jumper that is required to enable the write cycle to the flash ROMs. That enables the manufacturer to update the ROMs before shipping, then remove the jumper. Anyone trying to compromise the device would then require physical access.
- mikeash 10y agoMake it a button, so the customer can apply updates, but they need to press a button to make it happen. Add another button which, using only software stored in ROM, reloads the firmware from ROM. Then you have updates, but only when the customer knows and wants it, and if they ever screw it up then they can get back to a known good state.
- olympus 10y agoPart of the reason that Windows is an approved OS is enterprise support. When you pay for hundreds of thousands of licenses for a product you can demand features. If the DoD went with Debian they would need an entire corps of developers to maintain government specific patches. Ubuntu offers enterprise support but it's from an African country and that is undesirable as you mentioned above. I've seen government systems running Windows (USA), Mac (USA) but the strangest I've seen is SUSELinux (Germany). I have no idea how they got SUSE approved when Red Hat is more "American" but some agencies don't have to follow the rules.
- psykpsyk 10y agoLike Germany isn't an extension of the USA. Only Russians got kicked out of there...
- digi_owl 10y agoSUSE is owned by Novell.
- krylon 10y agoNot anymore, IIRC. When Novell was acquired by ... that company whose name I forgot (AttachMate?), SUSE was spun off as an independent company again. At least that is how I remember it.
- digi_owl 10y agoYeah it seems things have gotten a bit more complicated than i remembered. Novell bought Suse, then Novell merged with Attachemate, in the process Suse became a business unit (wholly owned company?) under Attachemate, then there was a merger between Attachemate and Micro Focus in 2014. Anyways, i suspect that as Suse is FOSS, and was initially Germany based, and now is UK based, both being NATO allies, that DOD has few issues with continued usage.
- powertower 10y agoIt's well known that all of Germany's media, intelligence services, and politics was set up by the US after the war. From what is seen on the geopolitical landscape, Germany is a vassal state of the US.