3 ms·
> Most of the tools I see for software development seem to be organized around the needs of the bazaar (or thatched huts) not the needs of the cathedral. A mill
by paganel 10y ago
> Most of the tools I see for software development seem to be organized around the needs of the bazaar (or thatched huts) not the needs of the cathedral. A million toy languages which might solve your problem well, but don't scale to a million users
Not the OP, but when I see comments like this one I do realize that sometime HN has a very strong echo-chamber. The world doesn't need more than 100 (give-or-take, maybe 1,000, maybe 10,000) apps/websites which need to scale to "millions of users", a situation which doesn't keep that many workers occupied (Google&FB and the like employ much less people compared to the industrial giants of the early 20th century).
But the world does need millions of apps for the 10-100-1000 users, if needed built using the "toy languages" you decry. If we make it easy enough for people to build these apps, using "toy languages" if need be, the world would be in a much better place (we'd have higher productivity).
I'll give you my example at the company I used to work for in the early 2000s (when the "Cathedral and the Bazaar was written"). I was doing some office work, along with my other 20 or so colleagues, which involved having to check that two separate folders on our computers had the same files. This took each of us about one-hour each, so, there were 20 man-hours spent each working day on this mundane task. Lucky me I was a (already close-to-dropout) CS student, and I had heard about Python and about how easy it was to do stuff with it, and lo and behold, it really was. Just:
> import os
> l1 = os.listdir('first folder')
> l2 = os.listdir('second folder')
>a_call_to_a_custom_function_which_was_comparing_l1_to_l2() //which was probably quadratic, but it didn't matter
then use py2exe to put it all up in an .exe file which could be also run on my colleagues' computers (along with some inputs and the like) and that was about it.
A task that used to take an hour each day now was only requiring a script/program call. I fail to see how this program would have required a grown-up language which would need to be scaled to "millions of users", even though it proved to be pretty useful. And there are countless examples like my anecdotal one I gave above, you just need to go into any institution or company office, look at how people work on their computers and realize that the world needs millions of small programs like mine that would substantially increase productivity. The problem is, like the OP said, that us, "programmers", like to keep the playing field only for ourselves.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoI think there's a huge unmet gap there that's actually being blocked by big businesses for business (not engineering) reasons. The ability of end-user to quickly and simply tune their device to their needs and automate stuff. The very concept flies in the face of what is today's accepted UX "best practices", i.e. to make software trivial, engaging and masterable in 5 seconds. It naturally happens by removing any kind of thing there is to be mastered. The task you performed with Python should be easily scriptable at the OS level. It shouldn't require one to know complex programming languages and toolkits. Similarly, I think that a tool like Tasker[0], maybe with a bit better interface, should be available by default in vanilla Android. We're vastly underutilizing the power of computing devices by restricting end user's ability to work with them. [0] - https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=net.dinglisch.android.taskerm&hl=en https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=net.dinglisch....
- thwarted 10y agoAnd there are countless examples like my anecdotal one I gave above, you just need to go into any institution or company office, look at how people work on their computers and realize that the world needs millions of small programs like mine that would substantially increase productivity. The problem is, like the OP said, that us, "programmers", like to keep the playing field only for ourselves. You're going to need a better example than that. This program already exists, it's called diff(1), md5sum(1), or cmp(1). You could wrap its use up in a shell script to make it even easier, or the companies/people could spend some money/time to learn how to use the tools already at their disposal. In a lot of cases, lack of training is the issue that should be addressed. I've said before "Those who don't learn /bin are doomed to reinvent it, poorly" This isn't to say you're wrong about a lot more little, customized programs that could be written. The focus needs to be on the specific processes of a particular company, because every company's processes are unique (maybe not on all axes, but on more than one). Enterprise software often errs in either of the two extremes: either it's overly customizable and doesn't fit anyone's needs completely; or it's highly specific and tries to force working its way. And this is done out of a desire, from the software vendors, to capture market share. Customized software is highly expensive, and people are expecting something tangible for that purchase. What they should be concentrating on (at least from an efficiency standpoint) is empowering their own people to automate the processes they do: after all, they are the experts in these processes.