3 ms·
The problem is, that I want to make games.
by kiba 17y ago
The problem is, that I want to make games.
- gfodor 17y agoAt some point in the last 10 years I realized not only are video games a waste of time but transitivity working on building them is nearly as much a waste of time. They're fun, but ultimately are just entertainment. I still play them occasionally. But the entire gaming industry from the players up to the executives at the end of the day are just providing people means of escaping from reality. Beating a game is a false, manufactured sense of accomplishment: it's like getting a "participation" ribbon in the game of life. Fun, yes, but ultimately I think it becomes as satisfying to beat a game as it is to eat a pastry from starbucks: in either case you're consuming a wholly manufactured experience that provides slim to nil real value for your mind or your body. In other words, there are much more interesting, difficult, and worthwhile problems to solve than how to build a better RPG or FPS. You're just not looking hard enough.
- almost 17y agoIt sounds like you maybe played games too much (forgive me if I'm wrong there, obviously your one comment is not enough to know that). I don't think there's anything wrong with recreation for its own sake and games are a form of recreation. They're fun, and it's good to have fun things in your life. Just so long as they're not the only (or, I'd say personally, the major) thing in your life. By creating games you are helping other people have fun and relax, that doesn't seem like a worthless thing to me.
- HeyLaughingBoy 17y agoYou must be so much fun at parties! I don't play video games either, but that hardly gives me the authority to deprecate them for creating merely a "manufactured sense of accomplishment." There are many people for whom games are the only practical release from daily drudgery and that alone makes their existence, and by extension their creation, worthwhile. Not everyone aspires to solve "interesting, difficult and worthwhile problems." Sometimes we just want to have fun!
- gfodor 17y agoI never said everyone did aspire to solve interesting problems. But the point of this thread, as so many others, is what do you do with opportunity given to you to work on whatever you want. I'm of the opinion that working on video games, generally speaking, is not much more rewarding both to yourself and society as it is to play them. If you had $500k, 2 years, and many ideas on how to make the world better, why would you waste it on building something that serves no purpose other than sheer escapism or entertainment? I get a very negative reaction when I criticize certain pursuits as not being worthwhile, as has happened before, but it's due to a misunderstanding of context. I say this not in the context of life in general (as I said, I play video games and don't always work on interesting, difficult problems) but instead in the context of having the opportunity to change the world. The truth is, these opportunities come across very rarely, and when they do, it's important to deeply consider how you spend your time. Sometimes you want to have fun, but that goes hand in hand with the fact that life is short.
- kristiandupont 17y agoI think that video games can be said to make the world better in some sense. My life is a little bit richer because of them - just like it is because of films and books and music. Maybe not in a philantropic sense of the word but I don't get the feeling that you are saying that he should be attacking AIDS or world hunger? And even if you are, the sun is going to explode one day, wiping out all legacy anyway. I am not saying that you shouldn't try and do good, but I think that the kind of statement you are making provokes these questions.
- _delirium 17y agoI guess I'd rate making interesting videogames at considerably more worthwhile than many of the startup ideas we see around here. I mean, ultimately most web 2.0 sites are kind of a waste of time, except for the potential to get rich off them. If anything, social media is a bigger unproductive time-sink than videogames or TV are these days. I do agree that building just another clone of an existing game (say, a new FPS with no real innovation) is a bit of a waste of time though, just like building a Twitter clone or reddit clone or something would be. But that's true in all media: most Hollywood films are derivative crap good for nothing but mindless entertainment, but that doesn't mean the entire idea of making a film is pointless. Of course, others have talked about this at greater length: http://www.colbertnation.com/the-colbert-report-videos/91012/august-07-2007/ian-bogost http://www.colbertnation.com/the-colbert-report-videos/91012...
- chipsy 17y agoIn the Scott McCloud-ian view of "ultimate goal of the art," I'm either trying to push the bounds of the medium, or developing a message within it. Right now I lean towards the medium, as I still feel there's a lot for me to learn. I don't think I'm succeeding at it yet, but what if I do? What if others do? "Ultimately just entertainment" comes from a linear mode of thinking about the nature of the industry and its potential for immediate utility. The utility of an entertainment medium stems from a balance between the inspirational and the functional - something that can say more about our world. Most of the products, just like most businesses, are going to completely fall flat at this. That does not subtract from the good ones.
- reitzensteinm 17y agoI make games for a living, and I agree with what you're saying, but I would cast a net much wider than just games. Ultimately, a ton of stuff the Hacker News community is working on falls into the 'want' category - not the 'need' category. I accept that what I'm doing isn't making the world a better place in any meaningful way. But I see you work as an engineer at Etsy, and I would suggest that you're in a glass house throwing stones.
- yters 17y agoWhat will people do once there are no more survival type problems to solve for anyone? If we can't play games with each other and socialize, life is going to be pretty boring unless we start introducing survival problems again.
- DenisM 17y agoImagine a person who wants to work on large volumes of search data. How many opportunities in life does such person have? Not many: work for Google, work for Bing, work for Ask.com, and that's it. By narrowing down your scope of interest you're making it a lot harder or even impossible to make money beyond wages. Another point to consider is that you will do much better if you focus on a demographic instead of technology (like most geeks do). Ask yourself - do I want to make teenage gamers happy? Well, how about elderly gamers? What kind of games could they want to play? Something from their childhood? Something to play with grand-children? What kind of problems do they face - font size? Pace? Demographics > technology.
- _delirium 17y agoIf you want to design games, as opposed to working as an engineer on some small part of them, you probably are actually better off doing it indie, or finding an indie company to work for. If you work a normal game-industry job at a place like EA, you aren't really going to be designing games, but more likely will be debugging a texture mapper somewhere deep inside an engine, or something equivalent. Plus, all the interesting stuff is happening in indie games anyway! --> http://www.igf.com/02finalists.html http://www.igf.com/02finalists.html
- jerf 17y ago"The problem is, that I want to make games." Have you tried anything else? Everybody thinks they want to make games (at some point). But while the end product is more fun than most end products, the sausage making process ranges from the same to below average in enjoyability. If you are going to enjoy being a programmer, you're likely to enjoy it working on any number of other things as well. If you can't stand working on those other things, you probably won't make it as a games programmer either. I'm not trying to discourage your from going into game programming, I'm trying to encourage you to notice that there are any number of other fun problems and tasks out there. In particular, if you are on a small team, rather than a programming sweatshop, almost everything should ultimately be a fun task with at least some new element to it; if you are doing the same thing every day, you are a terrible programmer! Not every programming job outside of gaming is a sweatshop job. For that matter, not every job inside of gaming isn't a sweatshop job. Unless game making is really truly your passion, and indeed, really truly your only passion, I really don't recommend it; you'll be competing in a market where supply is too high, and that means only one thing.
- plinkplonk 17y ago"The problem is, that I want to make games." If you want to make games, make them. Don't let anyone tell you they are impractical and you should work on accounting systems or card games for grannies or whatever. It is not that they are necessarily wrong (or right), but it is your time and your life Make some small games first. Only the actual making (especially completing) of games will teach you if it is something you want to do fulltime. You can think of business aspects once you have some tech chops.
- kiba 17y agoMake some small games first. Only the actual making (especially completing) of games will teach you if it is something you want to do fulltime. You can think of business aspects once you have some tech chops Want to see the 14th revision(Version 0.1.3) of an increasingly tricked out tetris clone? Or for that matter, want to see my in-progress network branch of my tetris clone? I also have some experience with canvas and javascript, which will become the future of gaming. I already took your advice and have some technical chops. Some knowledge I am missing is mostly mathematics, less so web application development, and most importantly business acumen.
- gaius 17y agoIt doesn't really matter what you're working on, 99% of software is the same. A race condition is a race condition, and you've got to find it and fix it before you can go home. The environment you do it in, your cow-orkers and so on, is the only real variable.