4 ms·
Huh? The judges quoted in the article seem to be concerned about the impact on the fairness of the justice system. --- > “It’s a loss,” Judge Kaplan said, “be
by jonas21 10y ago
Huh? The judges quoted in the article seem to be concerned about the impact on the fairness of the justice system.
---
> “It’s a loss,” Judge Kaplan said, “because when one thinks of the American system of justice, one thinks of justice being administered by juries of our peers. And to the extent that there’s a decline in criminal jury trials, that is happening less frequently.”
---
> “It’s hugely disappointing,” said Judge Jed S. Rakoff, a 20-year veteran of the Manhattan federal bench. “A trial is the one place where the system really gets tested. Everything else is done behind closed doors.”
---
> Judge Gleeson wrote that because most pleas are negotiated before a prosecutor prepares a case for trial, the “thin presentation” of evidence needed for indictment “is hardly ever subjected to closer scrutiny by prosecutors, defense counsel, judges or juries.” “The entire system loses an edge,” he added, “and I have no doubt that the quality of justice in our courthouses has suffered as a result.”
---
The "my kids didn't go to camp" quote is from a stenographer and was probably chosen by the reporter just to add another angle to the story.
- ekiru 10y agoThe first quote you've referenced doesn't make mention of the fairness of the justice system. So, there were two quoted judges bemoaning its effects on the fairness of the justice system, two talking about how their jobs are boring without trials (the quotes included below), and four that do not clearly talk about either of those. --- > “We’d love to have more trials; most of us enjoy trials,” said Judge Alvin K. Hellerstein, who joined the bench in 1998. --- > In April, when Judge Shira A. Scheindlin resigned from the bench after more than two decades, she said the decrease in trials was one consideration for her departure. “Trials are way, way down,” she said. “The building’s quite dead.”
- mooreds 10y agoekiru picked out the most flagrant quotes that got to me--no need to redo the work. But yes, you picked out some countervailing quotes--perhaps I was a bit harsh.