3 ms·
A few points just for fun: 1. Christianity, the group who builds Cathedrals, is probably the most profitable organization in the history of mankind. 2. Bazaar
by Clubber 10y ago
A few points just for fun:
1. Christianity, the group who builds Cathedrals, is probably the most profitable organization in the history of mankind.
2. Bazaars blow away when the wind picks up. If too many people show up, things start falling down. Cathedrals, and their close cousins, castles, last centuries.
3. I think Bazaars have their place, when you really need to ramp up something to show. We used to call that prototyping. If it gets past that, you gotta build it right eventually.
- hexane360 10y ago2. Bazaars pop back up seconds after they blow away. http://youtu.be/MENjFkEAj9g http://youtu.be/MENjFkEAj9g
- happyslobro 10y agoAn epic win for cross platform compatibility ;)
- taneq 10y agoYeah, but nothing's quite where you left it, your favourite curry stall is gone for good, and you'll never be able to get a refund on that thing you bought that stopped working the day before the storm.
- aaron695 10y ago> 1. Christianity, the group who builds Cathedrals, is probably the most profitable organization in the history of mankind. I don't need to be the richest organization ever. I'd be happy for 1000th place and those billions rather than overreaching for number one and the risk that entails.
- eggy 10y agoPoint 3 is what I consider a good model for the building metaphor. Let Bazaars spring up where needed and wanted. When the ground is proven, then clear and build a well-architectured Bazaar, not necessarily a full-blown cathedral unless it really calls for it. This sometimes happens when codebase if re-written from scratch with the old code as reference, not just cleaning up old code. I think AutoDesk did this when Inventor came along, but I am not sure. A big re-write if ever there were one.
- hexane360 10y agoInventor is still pretty much a Bazaar. If you go far enough down you'll find dialogs and menus at least a decade old. Very similar to Windows, actually. Like someone else said about Python, "it's a cathedral where it counts".
- wiz21 10y ago2. Cathedrals, and their close cousins, castles, last centuries Business problem spaces don't last centuries. Algorithm do.
- slang800 10y ago> Cathedrals, and their close cousins, castles, last centuries. Is that even a good thing? Aside from being beautiful artistic and historical works, I think that Cathedrals have outlived their usefulness. Just look at St. Patrick’s in NYC - that thing cost 177 million USD over 3 years just to restore it. I mean, obviously it's nice, but in terms of functionality it's a huge waste. You could build another 2 Lakewood Churches (each with a capacity of 16k people), using modern steel building techniques, just for the restoration costs of St. Patrick’s. I can see the case for over-engineering on things that are effectively "solved" problems (hashing algorithm implementations, knife design, non-electrical hand tools, JSON parsers...) but when it comes to complex systems like buildings or operating system architectures, I don't think we're at a point of stability where anything should be expected to last centuries (or more than a few decades, in the case of software). We're still seeing fundamental shifts in the assumptions that these systems are built on - whether it's the Cathedral that couldn't have possibly foreseen its stone arches being replaced by steel girders or the early mainframe OS that was designed before cheap computer clusters became the norm.