4 ms·
Medical device software is subject to a level of rigor in development process that little else is. Exactly what patient need do you believe open source would m
by HeyLaughingBoy 10y ago
Medical device software is subject to a level of rigor in development process that little else is.
Exactly what patient need do you believe open source would meet that is not being met by the current closed-source development process?
- llukas 10y agoWhat happens in closed source development model if pacemaker company ceases to develop one or goes belly up?
- unimpressive 10y agoWell now, this isn't quite the same thing as your normal IoT device. You would need to be Really Damn Sure any updates are bug-free before you could push them, which would take actual financial resources. Open source would help here, but not quite as much as it normally would.
- HeyLaughingBoy 10y agoManufacturer must support the product for 10 years after the last sale. In the case that they go belly up, that I don't have experience with, but it's likely that another company would step in to fill the role. Support can be quite lucrative.
- abraae 10y agoThe need to avoid Therac-25 [1] type bugs in the proprietary code that are fatal to the patient. Open source in conjunction with a bug bounty would make me far more confident than simply trusting that some large corporate has got their shit wired tight when history throws up so many counter-examples. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Therac-25 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Therac-25
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pdonis 10y ago> Medical device software is subject to a level of rigor in development process that little else is. How do you know this?
- HeyLaughingBoy 10y agoSpent 15+ years developing code for medical devices. I doubt very much that opening the source would have much impact on quality. For starters, without access to the hardware and understanding what it's supposed to be doing, how do you know if the code is right or not? Let me clarify that I'm not opposed to open sourcing the code, once issues around Trade Secrets are handle. But I don't think it would have even remotely the impact this group believes. The vast majority of device problems I've seen were system issues, not just a coding error.
- pdkl95 10y agoI don't need to know much about what it's supposed to be doing to critique a data channel that transmits plaintext over a radio, or accepts commands without cryptographically authenticating the sender. I also don't need to know much about the intended function of the device to find coding styles that cause problems in an embedded environments.
- pdonis 10y ago> what patient need do you believe open source would meet that is not being met by the current closed-source development process? The need to know, and be able to control if necessary, what a device that affects your life and health is doing. I'll give an example from my own experience. I have sleep apnea and have to use a CPAP machine. There is a nice little SD card in the machine that records detailed data from every use--which means it records how long I sleep, how soundly I sleep, how many (if any) apnea episodes I have, etc. This would be very useful information to me, but I have no way of getting it, because the software and data inside the device is proprietary. The only way for me to have anyone look at this data is to pull the SD card out and take it to a sleep therapy doctor, and even then I won't see the actual raw data; the best I'll get is some proprietary analysis report designed by the device manufacturer. Furthermore, the ostensible use for the data is to be able to adjust the pressure the CPAP machine is set at in order to improve the therapy. If I had access to the data and the settings inside the machine, I could easily do this myself. Instead, if I want any adjustment made, again, I have to go see a sleep therapy doctor--which means I need to make an appointment, which usually means waiting weeks or months, and I need to take off from work to go to the appointment, etc., etc. It should be obvious how open source would greatly improve this situation.