8 ms·
Cathedrals are beautiful. They represent the vision of one person or a very small group made real by the hard work of hundreds or thousands of skilled and semi-
by dsr_ 10y ago
Cathedrals are beautiful. They represent the vision of one person or a very small group made real by the hard work of hundreds or thousands of skilled and semi-skilled workers over dozens of years.
Cathedrals are not, generally speaking, profitable. They represent the expenditure of lots of capital over a long period of time.
Bazaars don't cost much to start. You can start quite small and have a functioning system that does useful things for people. They can grow quite large, and when they grow too large it becomes difficult to find exactly what you want without a really good map. But you can probably quickly find a bunch of things that are more or less close to what you want.
Cathedrals are not easy or cheap to repair, but the investment is so large that people usually prefer to repair them. A bazaar that doesn't work out makes some local people sad, but they will go to another bazaar that is a little less convenient for them, and perhaps do better there.
It's nice to have some cathedrals, because they feed the soul. But you need to eat every day, so there will always be bazaars, and if you need to make a choice, the bazaar is going to win unless you have a lot of resources stored up to fall back on.
- derefr 10y agoYou can build a cathedral around the stalls of a successful bazaar, no? Like OSX or Android.
- Ologn 10y agoAndroid a cathedral? If you wanted tabs in Android prior to 13, you'd setup a TabHost with a LocalActivityManager ( https://developer.android.com/reference/android/widget/TabHost.html#setup(android.app.LocalActivityManager) https://developer.android.com/reference/android/widget/TabHo... ). Then in version 11 ActionBar.Tab is added and LocalActivityManager is deprecated in version 13. By version 21 they became bored with that and deprecated it ( https://developer.android.com/reference/android/app/ActionBar.Tab.html https://developer.android.com/reference/android/app/ActionBa... ). You wouldn't know it was deprecated though as the most current training documentation still recommends using this now-deprecated method ( https://developer.android.com/training/implementing-navigation/lateral.html#tabs https://developer.android.com/training/implementing-navigati... ). All you are left with is a pointer to a vague, ambiguous page in the context of the deprecation method. Welcome to the cathedral of Android developing. BTW the release dates for these APIs: API 11 - February 2011 API 13 - July 2011 API 21 - November 2014 The annoyance isn't that they changed it, it's that they didn't like the old way, so they changed it, then three years later they changed it again. They do this all the time. Plus they deprecated it, but still recommend the deprecated method in the tutorial, and leave it as a mystery how it should be implemented in current best practices. The current most up-to-date tutorial on their web site is chock full of recommending things which they deprecated already.
- anabis 10y agoI wish they would at least put dates on the documentation. I find myself reading halfway through a outdated tutorial before some names or versions makes me realize it.
- flukus 10y agoI wish google would favor newer, more accurate solutions. Or at least provide away to flag no longer useful content.
- HillaryBriss 10y agoAgree. Definitely no cathedral. And what about customizing a Spinner's font and background color and popupBackground color and putting a non-standard element at the top? And the amount of time it took before Android got percentage based spacing in layouts? And the fun of remembering what UI attribute-values like android:gravity="center_horizontal", android:layout_centerHorizontal="true" and android:layout_gravity="center" mean? And the awkwardness of using non-standard typefaces and using things like the RecyclerView and it's weird Adapter? And the fact that for some reason they used an XML element named "layout" when they implemented their data binding feature? And the fact that some attribute names are camelCased while others are underscore_cased? And the ease with which memory leaks are introduced by inadvertently closing around context instances because you need context instances all over the place because the Activity is a god object? It's all so very ... not ... like ... a cathedral.
- pjmlp 10y agoSometimes I have this feeling that they just offshore everything and just do some kind of integration at Mountain View.
- HillaryBriss 10y agointeresting. i often wonder how the Android SDK got the way it is too. my hazy guess was that Google simply hired a bunch of extremely smart programmers and let them code whatever they wanted. but there is no equally smart architecture/design team to guide, organize and filter the work. there's just a build system. maybe that's essentially the same as your theory.
- adamnemecek 10y agomacos (nee osx) is the result of combining freebsd and the mach kernel, both very cathedraly technologies.
- mturmon 10y agoAnd now we see just how confused this discussion is. It's conflating a bunch of concepts via a historically weighted analogy, which itself has a lot of baggage at this point. For more, see this perceptive comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12251705 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12251705
- nickpsecurity 10y agoI'd consider what's on top the more cathedraly part. It has the consistency in design and implementations. Merging FreeBSD with Mach might have been centralized developers looking for good results but actual results seem a bit more bazaar. QNX was the older cathedral of mixing UNIX and microkernels with good design + performance. There were others but it stands out.
- josteink 10y ago> macos (nee osx) is the result of combining freebsd and the mach kernel, both very cathedraly technologies. Not to mention the remains of NextStep. Also very Cacthedraly. Edit: thinking about it, I wonder why Apple didn't keep using that name/brand. It's obviously there all over the API. Was the NextStep name/brand tainted as a doomed technology at the time?
- CookieMon 10y ago> Cathedrals are not, generally speaking, profitable. This is getting lost in the metaphore, instead of the topic. Architected software is profitable.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoArchitected software would be profitable in fewer scenarios if we (software developers) didn't maintain such a high barrier to entry. We design our tools for ourselves and other professional programmers so that we don't have to compete with non-professionals with a better sense of the requirements. We force people to come to us, to defer to our understanding of how much architecture is necessary. We make our codebases just easy enough for a pro developer and no easier, refactoring and simplifying only when it becomes painful for a pro developer, and no sooner. That way they have to keep us as gatekeepers to all code. It's essentially like you only made building tools for cathedrals, and no tools for thatched stick homes, and you create a culture around always building a cathedral so no one really knows how to build a thatched home. Essentially, creating a market irregularity through cultural expectations about how serious software has to be and who is going to be writing it. (The complaint people always make when I say this is that making software isn't easy, it's hard, and notices couldn't possibly build useful software. I would half agree: some software problems are hard, and require a grizzled developer and some hard planning. But much of software involves no difficult computer science problems, and is more about understanding requirements well enough to be able to assign them to the right basic programming primitive, or a handful of common libraries. This is the kind of code that we use cultural friction to keep inside Engineering, and build cathedral-style, even though it could be done in thatched-home style by notices, if we structured our codebases for that.)
- dietrichepp 10y agoI almost spit out my drink. High barrier to entry? The barrier is lower than it ever has been. Any nut-job with a few weeks of training can make a shitty website with PHP or Node.js and have it instantly accessible to the most of the English-speaking world. Most of the tools I see for software development seem to be organized around the needs of the bazaar (or thatched huts) not the needs of the cathedral. A million toy languages which might solve your problem well, but don't scale to a million users. Websites like GitLab and GitHub so you can share last week's 1 kloc project with collaborators. Libraries that do that one weird thing you need for your project, and nothing else. By comparison, the cathedral builders (Google, Facebook, Apple, Microsoft, etc.) seem to be building a lot of their own tools. This includes programming languages, frameworks, build systems, version control, operating systems, and so many other things. They build their own stuff because the tools of the bazaar don't work quite well enough for cathedrals.
- Clubber 10y agoA few points just for fun: 1. Christianity, the group who builds Cathedrals, is probably the most profitable organization in the history of mankind. 2. Bazaars blow away when the wind picks up. If too many people show up, things start falling down. Cathedrals, and their close cousins, castles, last centuries. 3. I think Bazaars have their place, when you really need to ramp up something to show. We used to call that prototyping. If it gets past that, you gotta build it right eventually.
- hexane360 10y ago2. Bazaars pop back up seconds after they blow away. http://youtu.be/MENjFkEAj9g http://youtu.be/MENjFkEAj9g
- happyslobro 10y agoAn epic win for cross platform compatibility ;)
- taneq 10y agoYeah, but nothing's quite where you left it, your favourite curry stall is gone for good, and you'll never be able to get a refund on that thing you bought that stopped working the day before the storm.
- aaron695 10y ago> 1. Christianity, the group who builds Cathedrals, is probably the most profitable organization in the history of mankind. I don't need to be the richest organization ever. I'd be happy for 1000th place and those billions rather than overreaching for number one and the risk that entails.
- eggy 10y agoPoint 3 is what I consider a good model for the building metaphor. Let Bazaars spring up where needed and wanted. When the ground is proven, then clear and build a well-architectured Bazaar, not necessarily a full-blown cathedral unless it really calls for it. This sometimes happens when codebase if re-written from scratch with the old code as reference, not just cleaning up old code. I think AutoDesk did this when Inventor came along, but I am not sure. A big re-write if ever there were one.
- jaza 10y agoPerhaps what we need are shopping malls. Aren't they, after all, the modern cathedrals of consumerism? (And aren't they just what we need more of in this world?) :P Shopping malls aspire to be beautiful (primarily on the inside), but they can never be as beautiful or as well-architected as cathedrals, in form or in spirit. Shopping malls have a bigger overhead than bazaars, and are less flexible. But their overhead is much less, and their flexibility much greater, than that of cathedrals. Shopping malls provide more foundation and infrastructure than bazaars do. A bazaar minus its stalls is just a dusty field. A shopping mall minus its shops still has multiple levels, maps / directories, elevators / escalators, parking, loading docks, etc. It costs more to set up shop in a mall than in a bazaar, but your shop will be more trusted, you won't have to squabble for space with your neighbours every day, and you won't get blown away by the next storm. Shopping malls are designed with dedicated spaces that are tailored to different businesses. A supermarket has very different needs compared to a shoe shop. Shopping malls are bazaars with a tonne of design, engineering, and regulation thrown in. But they're still bazaars. They're still where you get your groceries.
- HillaryBriss 10y agoyou're on to something good are you the one who writes "The Shopping Mall and the Bazaar" and leads us into a better era?
- DonHopkins 10y ago"Software development is hard. Let's go shopping!" -Tech Talk Barbie
- cvs268 10y ago> Software development is hard. Let's go shopping!" -Tech Talk Barbie ...or Yahoo, or Google, or IBM, or Hooli, or <Big-Fat-Tech-Giant>.
- mbrock 10y agoA shopping mall is also an example of what some theorists call "antimarkets": places which resemble a typical market with competition and choice but which are heavily regulated and controlled to exclude open participation. Kind of like if the iOS App Store only had room for 15 apps, and Apple Inc decided which, and the roster was only updated every few years at most.
- caseymarquis 10y agoCathedrals are very profitable; as long as there's religion.