8 ms·
It can get weirder, when you are talking third party conversations. Alice considers Bob a friend, Bob tells Charles that he dislikes Alice because he needs some
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
It can get weirder, when you are talking third party conversations. Alice considers Bob a friend, Bob tells Charles that he dislikes Alice because he needs something from Charles and Charles has expressed dislike for Alice.
Charles then tells Alice that Bob dislikes her which surprises Alice. (and is not actually the truth)
I got an opportunity to research workplace relations in depth and one of the courses cautioned about third party information for exactly this reason. They had surveyed several people and their supervisors about whether they "approved" or "disapproved" of one of their peers. When the survey was completely anonymous they got one answer but when the survey was said to be for their supervisor, the results skewed toward the supervisor's biases. The inference was that if a person's supervisor dislikes someone, the people they supervise are more likely to say they dislike that person to, regardless of their actual feelings. It can be seen as a loyalty reflex, or kissing up, it doesn't really matter, but if some supervisor tells you the people that work for them dislike you, the only information that offers is that the supervisor person dislikes you.
- nostrademons 10y agoI think it's important to distinguish between the supervisor saying that one person dislikes you and could you please change X, Y, and Z behavior to get along with them, vs. them saying that everybody dislikes you and please stay away from their team. The former likely is a problem with either you or that one person (or both). The latter is a problem between you and the supervisor. Remember that it's a supervisor's job to take the bullet for members of their team, so if someone on their team really does have a problem with you but doesn't like dealing with conflict, it's their duty to raise it with you. I feel like this also dovetails with the advice that "If somebody hates you, it's probably a problem with them. If everybody hates you, it's probably a problem with you." Not exactly the same situation - in this case, if everybody talking to a person hates you, it's probably a problem with that person - but in both cases, you get very useful information out of the specificity of the complaint.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoThat is a really valid point. I remember back in middle school that was the "big" insult, "Hey, everybody hates you!" which really meant the person insulting you had a problem with you.
- derefr 10y ago> and is not actually the truth Is there any "truth" about such things? Maybe I get sociopathic when I get philosophical, but it seems to me that my opinion of people is entirely due to who I'm around at the time, and "the person by themselves" is just one such group. There's no "there" there, under the set of masks; I don't really have any opinion on people when I'm on my own.