3 ms·
You can't just wave a wand called "emulation" to hypothesize whatever speed, precision, or rate of calculation you want. Emulators are physical objects and you'
by snowwrestler 10y ago
You can't just wave a wand called "emulation" to hypothesize whatever speed, precision, or rate of calculation you want. Emulators are physical objects and you'd need to show that it's possible to build an emulator that calculates the same amount of information as the Earth's biosphere, but faster, more precise, etc.
Then, once you have the attributes of that emulator, you'd have to calculate how long it would take that emulator to deliver the same information that can be harvested today on Earth with simple observations. And even if it completed, how would you confirm it is indeed the same information without traveling here to check?
The energy budget would be immense of course, but heat management might be the limiting issue on how fast it can run. It's hard to dump heat into space.
I'm not intending to argue one or another about hypothetical god-like alien civilizations. It's just a pet peeve when programmers make open-ended claims about simulations or emulations without considering physical constraints. We tend to think of electronic computers as powerful, but their information handling capabilities are quite slow and diffuse compared to what biology has produced on Earth so far.