4 ms·
I think maybe you had just one non-friend - the one that told you that caustic lie. Just a thought.
by JoeAltmaier 10y ago
I think maybe you had just one non-friend - the one that told you that caustic lie. Just a thought.
- throwanem 10y agoThat is the parsimonious conclusion.
- Feuilles_Mortes 10y agoI'm unclear as to what you mean by parsimonious.
- throwanem 10y agoRequiring the fewest or simplest assumptions. Specifically: Either the statement is true, and a lot of people you've regarded as friendly acquaintances in fact wish you ill, or the statement is false, and one person (the one making it) wishes you ill, as demonstrated by his having decided to tell you a lie which, if believed, will probably harm at least some of your social relationships within the context. Ceteris paribus, the latter requires fewer assumptions (ill will on the part of one person, rather than of many), and is therefore likelier to be accurate. This use of the adjective originates in the philosophical concept of "ontological parsimony", which is basically Occam's Razor with lots of the sort of added complexity you generally find in epistemological analysis.
- zach-kuhn 10y agoWithout knowing the situation, it's reasonable this "non-friend" may have thought they were protecting the original poster. Assuming this person wasn't lying, there is no right answer here. Are you a better friend because you look out for your friend when they're not around and are willing to share a painful truth? Or are you the better friend because you protect your friend's happiness by not telling them? I tend to take the former approach, but experience has taught the latter works better. Inflicting pain on a friend, even with their best interest at heart, is a good way to lose friends.
- etrevino 10y agoI think that this is correct. Even if the person thought that they were correct, they had to have known that saying that would have hurt you. If anything, that person isn't your friend. If the other people chat with you, eat with you, or just otherwise interact with you ... they're your friends. Perhaps they're not close friends, but that doesn't mean that there isn't some level of mutual respect and enjoyment of your company.
- zeveb 10y ago> If the other people chat with you, eat with you, or just otherwise interact with you ... they're your friends. That really doesn't follow. I've had to maintain a pleasant working relationship with folks I've cordially loathed (and I'm certain the feeling was mutual). In every situation, we were friendly, pleasant and worked together well — but at the end of the day, we couldn't stand one another. Sometimes you don't get to choose your colleagues: your only choice is to quit or to continue.
- zeveb 10y agoBut what if it's a caustic truth? Seriously, the world isn't all fluffy fuzzy happiness. Sometimes people honestly dislike and even despise one another, but they can still produce good work together. Gilbert & Sullivan are a good example.
- throwanem 10y agoWhether it's a caustic lie or a caustic truth, it's still caustic. Either way, what good do you see coming of its revelation in this context?
- bm5k 10y agoPut yourself in OP's position: would you rather _not_ know?
- throwanem 10y agoYes. Edited to expand: I already sandbox my personal and work lives thoroughly, so it's not going to cost me anything of significance beyond the job if I lose the job - not that that's not significant, but it's not my whole life, either. If, to a good first approximation, everyone where I work hates me, then I'm already going to lose the job, because with that many people looking to put a knife in my back, someone is going to succeed. The odds that knowing this is true will make it possible for me to change it are effectively negligible; on the one hand, if everyone where I work hates me because of my own behavior, I'm not equipped to change anyone's mind, and on the other, if everyone where I work hates me because of something that isn't actually under my control, everyone where I work still hates me and I'm literally the last person in the world who's going to be able to do anything about that. Either way, I'm screwed in a way that foreknowledge isn't going to do anything to help; the best that'll happen if I find out ahead of time is nothing, and the worst is that I'll make my situation even worse. So where's the benefit in being told?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]