7 ms·
Bitcoin Bail-Ins and Yuan Bets
- chollida1 10y agoOhh a Matt Levine post, so I guess the top 10 comments will be people recommending that everyone subscribe to his daily news letter:) On a serious note.... > Engineers at Sydney-based Metamako LP and Exablaze Pty. Ltd., and Chicago-based xCelor LLC are rolling out switches that take around four nanoseconds—four billionths of a second—for messages to transit from one side to the other, sending data from exchanges to electronic traders. Wow, can anyone shed some light on how they time this? What sort of clock, I'm assuming its some fancy hardware that you use to benchmark at the 4 nano second level? Or do you just claim this and assume that no one can prove you wrong? As to Bitfinex, on the weekend a few friends and I were batting around ideas on how to reliably trade bitcoins without having to worry about being robbed by the exchange^H^H^H^H^H err worrying about the exchange being hacked and passing their mistake onto you. The top ideas we had were: - only trade on US domiciled exchanges, the US government tends to poke their nose into everything and this is one case where you benefit. - phone the exchange before you start trading. If you can't get someone on the phone, that's a very bad sign:) - Similarly, if the C level executives of the exchange aren't well known and always around at the regular bitcoin industry conferences then that's a bad, though this fails the Mt Gox test. - we tried to figure out if you could pull the coins out each night and put them back in each day, but even then, you'd run the risk of the hack happening while you had coins held by the exchange. But we came to the conclusion that there just isn't any sane way to trade bitcoins currently where you can eliminate "exchange risk". If anyone does know of a way please let me know.
- droffel 10y ago> But we came to the conclusion that there just isn't any sane way to trade bitcoins currently where you can eliminate "exchange risk". If anyone does know of a way please let me know. There are decentralized exchanges that are becoming more popular (Bitsquare for one, check out http://www.bitsquare.io http://www.bitsquare.io), but there's a chicken-and-egg problem for liquidity. Not a lot of people currently trade on the decentralized exchanges, so liquidity is thin (and until there's liquidity, larger traders will likely not trade there). However, there isn't any counterparty risk, other than if you buy BTC for USD, and the person on the other end charges back the bank transfer. When you trade crypto-to-crypto, the risk is minimal (barring a 51% attack reversing the history on the cryptocurrency you purchased).
- pjc50 10y agoHowever, there isn't any counterparty risk, other than if you buy BTC for USD, and the person on the other end charges back the bank transfer (Sell BTC for real money, surely?) So there isn't any counterparty risk apart from when it's most critical, actually cashing out?
- blueprint 10y agoHow about a decentralized exchange, like, say, Bitsquare?
- compil3r 10y ago+1 bitsquare
- gnaritas 10y agoFar too slow for any real trading. Exchanges exist for trading quickly, they must be centralized due to this.
- blueprint 10y ago> Far too slow for any real trading. Maybe if you're a day or mechanical trader. Although, I personally don't know if that's actually true. Have you tried it? Can you share any data or citations? > Exchanges exist for trading quickly Agreed > they must be centralized due to this. Have you encountered any definite proof of your conclusion?
- gnaritas 10y ago> Maybe if you're a day or mechanical trader. Or swing trader or any kind of trader looking to time the market. Trading requires the ability to execute in near real-time. Block chain transactions and worse, fiat transfers between parties, takes far too long for trading to be effective. > Have you encountered any definite proof of your conclusion? They must be centralized to obtain the necessary speed because currently block chain transactions are too slow. Proof is unnecessary, logic is more than ample. One can't trade effectively if ones capital is hung up in "transit" between parties. Exchanges exist specifically to provide fast trading. There wouldn't be any exchanges if block chain transactions were fast enough.
- blueprint 10y agoSwing trading does not require the ability to place an order in near real time. You need to have done your DD and generally you just place your order the day before you expect your event. We don't know that blockchain transactions are inherently slow and we haven't verified that no decentralized architectural/algorithmic/structural solutions exist to coordinating trades. In fact, I can think of one or two. So I'm asking you for data, not hypothesis. Do you have any info from your research about trade order execution times on p2p exchanges over time or userbase size? Or is it just your conclusion from anecdote?
- pjc50 10y agobenchmark at the 4 nano second level That should show up on your 10GHz scope, although the probe setup is a little fiddly. Or you could just ask your 10G network card to timestamp packets for you. Only valid for packets sent back to the same card, unless you go to heroic lengths to synchronise between systems. (The exchange issue is called "counterparty risk", and it's the one area Bitcoin advocates tend to handwave away with reputation systems)
- revelation 10y ago4ns is only 250MHz. That's pretty much DC nowadays ;)
- toth 10y ago> Wow, can anyone shed some light on how they time this? What sort of clock, I'm assuming its some fancy hardware that you use to benchmark at the 4 nano second level? Or do you just claim this and assume that no one can prove you wrong? There are some expensive hardware solutions to capture all network traffic and timestamp it at nanosecond level. E.g., https://www.endace.com/endace-high-speed-network-recorders.html https://www.endace.com/endace-high-speed-network-recorders.h...
- HairyGing3r 10y agoSocialising the losses couldn't work with us customers. Since bitfinex' biggest market is in the US I don't see how this (bitfinex tokens) could fly without many lawsuits
- wmf 10y agoThey're going to be sued regardless of what they do, so they might as well nudge people in the direction they want.
- HairyGing3r 10y agoI'd be happy with their deal but I wasn't a customer. Back when MtGox collapsed (and I was a customer) we all wished for something like this.
- merkleme 10y agoBut I thought Bitfinex was a global exchange... Does an exchange just need to have a few US customers to face US lawsuits?
- HairyGing3r 10y agoIn the case of the US even 1 big client is enough
- Isomatik 10y agoYep. If you're open for business to US citizens, or even really just moving USD around, you can't escape the USA's jurisdiction. And it appears Bitfinex compiled fully to AML/KYC laws for US customers dealing in USD, so everything's definitely documented. "In prosecuting money laundering offenses, the US Department of Justice takes the position that jurisdiction exists over a financial transaction if the laundering is completed by a US citizen anywhere in the world, or by a foreign national or non-US corporation if the criminal conduct occurs in part in the United States—even if the foreign individual or company never themselves took an action in the United States, or intended for an act to occur there... US enforcement authorities increasingly operate on the assumption (unless convinced otherwise) that they have jurisdiction for such offenses whenever a suspect transaction is denominated in US dollars. http://www.whitecase.com/publications/insight/how-us-laws-can-apply http://www.whitecase.com/publications/insight/how-us-laws-ca... https://www.mayerbrown.com/files/Publication/577b946b-8ad0-445d-b566-8b4a9682c373/Presentation/PublicationAttachment/ad366972-a841-447e-bd23-86883403a000/understanding-reach-jurisdiction.pdf https://www.mayerbrown.com/files/Publication/577b946b-8ad0-4...
- jbapple 10y agoA big contributor to the GFC was pension funds ("dumb money") buying CDOs with rates that were way too low for the risks. Do I need to be worried about the same thing for cat bonds?
- joeyspn 10y agoThe bitfinex hack stinks. A lot... Still waiting for a proper post-mortem/post-hack. They must be gaining precious time and lawyering up before all the details are released and SHTF...
- devishard 10y ago> It is easy to make fun -- and I do make fun -- of bitcoin/blockchain enthusiasts for naively re-creating everything that has existed for decades or centuries in the traditional financial system. From a "blockchain enthusiast"'s perspective, this is exactly why Bitfinex and other centralized Bitcoin businesses are idiotic. If we're just implementing centralization on top of Bitcoin's decentralized structure, Bitcoin has literally no benefits over the traditional financial system. It's actually worse, because when a major traditional financial institution gets hacked, they reverse the charges instead of going bankrupt. Bankruptcies happen all the time in the Bitcoin world because creating a centralized Bitcoin puts a target on the business that grows as the business grows, and the damage when they get hit is irreversible. The benefit of Bitcoin is decentralization, and businesses that don't understand this are always going to come across as naive. Sometimes so naive that they fail.
- John23832 10y agoPlaying devil's advocate, the thing that these exchanges can, and often do, try to hang their hat on is anonymity. While through hard work (and lots of money) it can be "had" on the mainstream markets, financial anonymity is not something that you average joe really has access to on the major markets. That being said, is that added benefit worth the (much MUCH bigger) risk of your money going up in smoke? Personally, I don't think so. Overall, I agree... The reinvention of the wheel for the sake of it is laughable.
- devishard 10y agoYou're right, they do try to hang their hat on anonymity, but when they do that, it's pretty much an outright lie. Centralized Bitcoin services are regulated and tied to other financial services. Coinbase knows exactly who I am. And while you can break the identity chain with tumblers etc., that requires going outside centralized Bitcoin services. Bitcoin isn't trivially anonymous, and centralization almost universally comes with regulation that prevents it from being anonymous.
- oolongCat 10y ago>The benefit of Bitcoin is decentralization, and businesses that don't understand this are always going to come across as naive Businesses understand this really well and they are using this to their advantage, there's not much regulation around crypto-curruncies as of now, so these companies can operate in a legally gray area. It is the customers of these businesses who has no idea what is going on. Many are happy to buy and sell the whole utopian view of how the block chain is going to liberate them all, how its going to end poverty and and kill all the evil bankers, but everyone saw what happened then the DAO got hacked, that whole utopian view of the irreversible something something was somehow now the responsibility of a central group. If anyone wants to see examples of how most of these users have no idea of how to handle money, look at all the ponzi schemes that are build around crypto currencies. Its insane thinking how easily people give away their money for a piece of the moon.
- compil3r 10y agoBFXCoin isn't totally without precedent, as BitcoinBuilder (created in the wake of MtGox) was recognized by the Japanese courts.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- CydeWeys 10y agoI don't believe this is accurate: > So when hackers stole about 36 percent of the bitcoins at Bitfinex, they didn't just steal 36 percent of each customer's bitcoins: They stole, basically, all of the bitcoins owned by 36 percent of the customers, and none of the bitcoins held by 64 percent of the customers. (Weighting customers by account size; you know what I mean.) I think that all, or almost all, of Bitfinex's Bitcoins were stolen. Certainly more than 36%! The hackers generated all transactions and then simultaneously broadcast them. There's no reason they wouldn't or couldn't have gone after every last Bitcoin that was accessible to them. Bitfinex did not realize the attack was occurring in time and did not send out any counter-transactions to attempt to spend all of their coins first (realistically they had on the order of seconds to minutes for this). We know that Bitfinex wasn't using cold wallet storage like they should have, instead opting for some multi-sig scheme using BitGo that didn't actually work, so essentially all of their Bitcoins were available to be stolen, and were. What's happening is that the 36% haircut is across all values in all accounts, including fiat currencies that were on deposit such as USD, as well as other cryptocurrencies that Bitfinex trades such as Ethereum. So Bitfinex lost all of their Bitcoin, which represented 36% of the total value on deposit with them, most of the rest of which was fiat currencies.
- dzdt 10y agoInteresting speculation. Any references to support this?
- zeven7 10y agoJust to fill in a couple gaps: The attack lasted approximately 3 hours, starting by draining the largest accounts and moving down from there over time. It's known not all of them were stolen. I've seen estimates (by outsiders) that approx. 60+% of bitcoins were stolen. It was certainly more than 36%. Edit: Sources: https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/4wizdn/txid_and_bitcoin_addresses_connected_to_the/d67dtk3 https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/4wizdn/txid_and_bi... https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/4wmpzt/bitfinex_assets_remaining/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/4wmpzt/bitfinex_as...
- 10y ago