4 ms·
I wonder who's being affected by this law. Very few people buy designer furniture costing thousands of Euros. Furthermore you can have 100,000 songs, 1,000 movi
by pmontra 10y ago
I wonder who's being affected by this law. Very few people buy designer furniture costing thousands of Euros. Furthermore you can have 100,000 songs, 1,000 movies, 100 clothes but only a few chairs. So the Chinese will keep selling cheap furniture with some changes to the design and the EU manufacturers won't make much more.
Example
This chair is extremely popular in cheap restaurants, plastic made https://dearchiworld.wordpress.com/2014/10/14/no-14-chair-michael-thonet/ https://dearchiworld.wordpress.com/2014/10/14/no-14-chair-mi...
The Thonet company still sells it (couldn't find the price) and I found it on Alibaba starting from $25. It's so old that's out of the reach of the law but if it wasn't do we really think they're not going to tweak the design and that their EU customers will care and go buying from Thonet instead?
- toyg 10y agoIf cheap manufacturers were forced to significantly tweak the design, it would become easier to spot a fake, which means expensive restaurants would more willingly pay the difference to get originals. If everyone could just slap the same glowing apple on their laptop lid, there would be less incentive for people to get original Apple laptops. Same here.
- VLM 10y ago"it would become easier to spot a fake" For a theoretical example look at the situation with Wooton desks and their multiple trim levels. They'll just be more trim levels to work around the copyright. Obviously the specific example of Wooton desks don't matter because that design is about 150 years old. But it is an example of a general class of problem. In my infinite spare time I enjoy fine carpentry for relaxation, as do a couple other people here, and on my infinite list of things to do is make either a copy of a Wooton or make a Wooton / 43 folders mashup. And running off extra copies doesn't take much extra time, and selling extra copies is an interesting way to pay for your supplies. So this kind of thing could theoretically impact small craftsmen not just Chinese factories.
- toyg 10y ago> They'll just be more trim levels to work around the copyright. Which is why there are judges and court cases to decide if design patents are infringed, otherwise we'd have machines that simply compare pictures. If your desk is exactly the same as the original bar a few trim levels, a judge will likely find you're infringing. > So this kind of thing could theoretically impact small craftsmen not just Chinese factories. That's entirely possible, but not a new phenomenon. Can small craftsmen make and sell statues of Han Solo without infringing Disney's copyright?
- VLM 10y agoWoodworking is smaller than you think. If I take a Chippendale table and replace the (creepy) animal like curvy legs and those (creepy) ball and claw feet with straight square footless legs, that both is, and is not, a minor trim variation on a Chippendale. On one hand its just different actions at my workbench, on the other hand that's an entirely different product that being a Hepplewhite style table. Both styles are over two hundred years old and being free for all to use has increased the size of the economy not collapsed it. I like the analogy with Wooton from 150 years ago. I should be able to make and sell copies of a Wooton to my hearts desire. I don't think retroactively increasing copyright to 151 years will suddenly retroactively make Wooton invest more in fancy desk designs thus retroactively increasing hiring in his plant in the late 1800s or whatever ridiculous mantra is recited in favor of imaginary property. Likewise in 2170 I should be able to sell Han Solo figurines, although I'm willing to bet if our corrupt system is still even operational then, I still won't be able to do so legally and unfortunately Hollywood will probably still be churning out sequels remakes and reboots. Copyright duration needs something like the Laffer Curve.
- toyg 10y ago> being free for all to use has increased the size of the economy not collapsed it Considering the sad state of English manufacturing, including furniture, that's a controversial statement. It was undoubtedly a good thing as the English industry was small and growing, much like loose open-source code sharing is a good thing for the still-burgeoning software industry. But that industry is mature now; profits are razor-thin and fundamental innovations are very rare. In such a scenario, commercial viability in high-cost countries usually hinges on design and marketing differentiating you from competitors. > I don't think retroactively increasing copyright to 151 years will suddenly retroactively make Wooton invest Yeah, I agree that retroactive application looks stupid with such long terms. Still, the concept overall is consistent with the long-term industrial direction that developed countries are set on. I don't think established interests would be so aggressive on copyright if they could see other realistic alternatives to "let's just leave it all to the Chinese".
- pmontra 10y agoI don't think expensive restaurants are really in competition with cheap ones (or Mercedes with VW) but I got your point. Still I believe the effect will be close to nil: expensive restaurants and luxury houses already buy originals. Everybody else care more about the price of what they buy. As long it's not too expensive and it looks good enough it's a sell. My point is that this is going to force Chinese companies to do some design, maybe hiring European designers first then learning to do it themselves. No extra sales for European furnitures and it's still a long shot to 3D printing your own furniture copying a famous one. Think about leather, steel, wood, springs, hinges, etc.
- EdHominem 10y agoThat's what a trademark is for. To keep the knockoff from being confused for the original. And it does it without making the essential features unusable by others. A trademark would let me slide to unlock, just not slide a little apple icon..