2 ms·
[if we replace public with market education] we would have better schools at half the price, and be freer too. We would also be a more just society, with only t
by barrkel 17y ago
[if we replace public with market education] we would have better schools at half the price, and be freer too. We would also be a more just society, with only the customers of education bearing the costs..
There's a problem: the freedom of a market system is especially in contradiction to justice with respect to education. A child in a poor family will end up at the worst of the educational institutions, harming that child's equality of opportunity. With reference to Rawls' Theory of Justice and the original position, a just society should not put up with this.
- tokenadult 17y agoProviding subsidies to poor learners is a distinct policy from providing general subsidies to lousy oligopolistic providers.
- cperciva 17y agoA child in a poor family will end up at the worst of the educational institution Yes -- but only due to the ill-conceived ban on slavery. If it were legal to do so, companies would buy shares in the future earnings of children in exchange for funding their education.
- kiba 17y agoharming that child's equality of opportunity. Why make education all equal? Why not provide the best education as we can with what we can. Is voluntarism not a principle in your book? Can't church and charity help people? One way to look at this is that being rich beget more being rich. Those who have more money than others will have a head start in life, no matter how you spin it in any other way. Should people start taking money away from rich parents who want to provide their children with the best education money can buy? Look at it in another way, do you really think public school system really help people? Look at schools in the cities. They're seem to be providing an unequal education compared to suburban schools.
- Retric 17y agoI find it amusing that he is honestly arguing for the default throughout most of human history and calling it a bold move. Clearly the public education system can be improved. But, what is so often forgotten is private schools greatest strength is choosing their students. Harvard does not try to educate people of below average intelligence or poor academic backgrounds. And they are also willing to kick people out far faster than public schools. Because of this they can provide a level of education that is a step above, or at least graduate people who are better than average.