3 ms·
There is a valid argument that the postmodernists bring up that the author of this article (and science in general) seems to be ignoring. This is certainly obfu
by jcranmer 10y ago
There is a valid argument that the postmodernists bring up that the author of this article (and science in general) seems to be ignoring. This is certainly obfuscated by the postmodernist tendency to misuse terminology all over the place, so it's best to use a specific example to illustrate it.
Recently, as I'm sure everyone here knows, the LHC found the Higgs boson. Imagine an exchange between EP, an ecstatic physicist, and SP, a skeptical postmodernist.
EP: We did it, we found the Higgs boson!
SP: Why should I care?
EP: Well, knowing that the Higgs boson means that we finally know that the Standard Model is correct.
SP: That's cool, I guess. So you saw the Higgs boson with your eyes?
EP: No, that's impossible.
SP: How do you know it exists?
EP: Well, there's this cool thing in the LHC called ATLAS. We get beams of protons to collide in the middle of it, and the resulting products set off little signals inside the detector. By processing the results of these signals, we can figure out what byproducts must have been involved...
SP: How can you find that out?
EP: Embarks on particle physics that goes over SP's head
SP: This is the Standard Model you've talked about?
EP: Uh, yes...
SP: So, what you're telling me is that you've just verified the Standard Model by assuming that it was true in the first place?
EP: ...
SP: Walks away in smug satisfaction
What the postmodernist gets right in the argument is that our evaluation of the validity of scientific tools to make observation is based on a model of how science works, and that, without care, you risk creating a circular argument that boils down to proving models correct because you assumed them. What they get wrong is the assumption that this circular argument is unavoidable, and that thus the entire edifice of science is built on shaky ground in the first place (ultimately being simplified down to "there is no such thing as objective reality"). Ironically, what the Sokal exposed is that the postmodernists were just as guilty of the crime they accused scientists of committing: they didn't criticize that which would have proved them correct.
The message for scientists should be that you should always strive to make sure that the tools are working properly. If there were a serious bug in the code used in ATLAS, do you think that the scientists on the project would have been equally diligent in finding and fixing that bug if it made a Higgs boson appear where it didn't actually occur than if it hid the appearance of the Higgs boson?
- Natsu 10y ago> If there were a serious bug in the code used in ATLAS, do you think that the scientists on the project would have been equally diligent in finding and fixing that bug if it made a Higgs boson appear where it didn't actually occur than if it hid the appearance of the Higgs boson? Actually, the scientists trick themselves by injecting fake signals to avoid bias on their part. So they have that covered. They're well aware at how badly one can goof up when looking for a really rare signal. The statistical standards they set are incredibly high. The more completely scientists are able to control the experimental conditions, the better science works. Things like psychology end up probing an extremely complex system (our brains) with a lot of constraints on what they can do for obvious, ethical reasons. Add in a side of politicization of certain results and you end up with a larger amount of replication problems than you would in particle physics where we can carefully isolate effects on significantly simpler systems.
- jonathanstrange 10y agoI don't think this circularity exists or plays any substantial role. Skeptics and some philosophers seem to have a hard time understanding how dreadfully difficult it is to come up with theory of anything that is analytically insightful and makes even remotely correct predictions. I would be fine if someone came up with a theory of, say, electromagnetism based on assuming the existence of the flying spaghetti monster or, to stick to the topic, based on assuming that our reality is mostly constructed by culture. The only thing I ask for is that those claims actually play a role in the theory, rather than being a mere addition, and that you can you can actually use the theory to build a transistor radio.
- LolWolf 10y ago> I would be fine if someone came up with a theory of, say, electromagnetism based on assuming the existence of the flying spaghetti monster or, to stick to the topic, based on assuming that our reality is mostly constructed by culture. The only thing I ask for is that those claims actually play a role in the theory, rather than being a mere addition, and that you can you can actually use the theory to build a transistor radio. I cannot upvote this more. It seems all too easy to criticize scientific methods as being baseless or assuming some odd construction about the universe or the context or whatever it's embedded in, but it's so easy to overlook the fact that there are only so many (read: extremely few) ways one can construct a theory with the same predictive power as that of physics which has the same or less number of free variables. Thank you for putting into words something I've tried so hard to verbalize to some of my friends who please themselves with criticizing positivism/post-positivism as being woefully naive (relative to, say, constructivism), yet benefit infinitely from it.
- thanatropism 10y agoMy line of questioning isn't even there. I mean, the standards of "proof" (empirical validation) of physicists are pretty good. But ask any particle physicist and they'll tell you the Standard Model is a hack. It's almost as if it belonged to the same family as epicycles. Moreover -- ask any particle physicist and they'll tell you the empirical work related to LHC is mostly unrelated to the last 40 years of "post-modern" theorizing in physics. In other words: I don't think philosophy should be as concerned with the truth of things (which, well, can't be determined by abstract speculation), but with relevance and significance. Science (as opposed to technology -- and saying technology is powered by science is like saying it's powered by testosterone) is failing pretty hard in remaining relevant. Thus the attacks on religion, linguistics, french philosophy and so on.
- AnimalMuppet 10y ago> So, what you're telling me is that you've just verified the Standard Model by assuming that it was true in the first place? No, we've just verified one part of the Standard Model to be true by assuming the other parts of the Standard Model, which we were already able to test, to be true. That isn't actually circular.