3 ms·
> Say Google did not take the initiative. Would it be better that people have no internet whatsoever than to have Facebook for free? If you allow it, monopolis
by shmerl 10y ago
> Say Google did not take the initiative. Would it be better that people have no internet whatsoever than to have Facebook for free?
If you allow it, monopolists will abuse it. That's what Net neutrality prevents. Network must be equal, no preferential treatment for Facebook or the like. Of course they'll use an excuse of "providing free Internet". But if they care about free access, they should give access to Internet, not to Facebook. They aren't doing that. So what they are doing is simply monopolizing the market. That is not good.
> Moreover, it is each individual who should decide what is better for him
Facebook doesn't let them decide. Because they only provide Facebook. It's an illusion of choice.
- necessity 10y agoHow are they monopolizing the market? It seems that the prevention allowed Google to monopolize the market, instead of competing with Facebook if it was allowed. >Facebook doesn't let them decide. Because they only provide Facebook. It's an illusion of choice. They can decide between having Facebook or not, no one is forcing them to use it. Government is forcing them to not use Facebook. That's an illusion of protection.
- shmerl 10y ago> How are they monopolizing the market? By turning Internet access into Facebook access. Try explaining how it's not a monopoly. > Government is forcing them to not use Facebook. No, government is forcing Facebook to play by the same rules as everyone else. That's fair and necessary. If Facebook wants to be exempt from data caps, then all traffic and services should be.
- necessity 10y ago>By turning Internet access into Facebook access. Try explaining how it's not a monopoly. Any other company can provide internet access, e.g. Google. >No, government is forcing Facebook to play by the same rules as everyone else. That's fair and necessary. Of course, given that there is nn everyone should respect it. My point is that nn is harmful.
- shmerl 10y agoLack of Net neutrality is harmful to competition.