9 ms·
The problem is that the media almost always use this implicit syllogism: "70% of GDP is consumer spending. Therefore, the economy depends on consumer spending.
by SilasX 10y ago
The problem is that the media almost always use this implicit syllogism:
"70% of GDP is consumer spending. Therefore, the economy depends on consumer spending. Therefore, we need to goose consumer spending if we want to help the economy."
- acqq 10y agoNo, the problem is that the whole western economy can "logically" function only based on "growth" as in "more consumption, more production every year." But math is not on our side: http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article25458.htm http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article25458.htm
- jomamaxx 10y ago'Growth' can continue every year from now until infinity. The capacity for human innovation is unlimited.
- erelde 10y ago"It's not because every human has died that I will die too." I need proof that human innovation potential is unlimited.
- marvin 10y agoWell, obviously not unlimited in the mathematical sense (the ordering of elementary particles in the visible universe is finite), but there is a lot of stuff that the laws of physics allows which we would like to do, but are currently incapable of doing. Just to name a few: Ensure sustainable energy production, halt and reverse global climate change, eradicate all disease and suffering, make aging and death optional, ensure that working for a living is optional, allow all humans the possibility of ethically experiencing most experiences and capabilities available to the richest 0.01%, cure all physical and mental disabilities and enhance human bodies with new senses and physical capabilities, create easily-available artificial intelligence which is at least as capable as the smartest human alive and acts in humanity's interest, and so on.
- jomamaxx 10y agoHeyzeus. On one hand, I guess it's good we have creative, unbounded thinking. Sadly - I'm starting to think that most Engineers have never opened a book outside of Engineering, certainly not any history, ethics, politics or economics books. --> Human potential is definitely unlimited. Since the dawn of recorded history - and even beforehand - we have, by enlarge, almost always been innovating and moving forward. From neolithic, to ancient Egypt, to antiquity, to the Renaissance, Enlightenment, Industrial revolution, Modern era and information era - it's always been moving forward. Even the 'dark ages' were not really dark, only compared to those writing history in East Roman Empire / Byzantium. My Grandparents were born on farms. No electricity. No running water. No radio, tv, cars, radio, internet. They passed away very recently. What makes your skepticism a little funny is that right now on planet earth there is more 'innovation' going on than at any time in all of history. It's like an 'innovation explosion'. It's such a big shift that we are in a new epoch. -----> As for your interesting ideas (aging death option, work only if needed) ... You must be young. I don't think you've met enough types of people yet. Your treatise is missing a moral foundation (arguably), more importantly the nature of life. 'Cures disease'. Is 'dwarfism' a disease? What about being just a little short? What about sagging eyes from age 40-90? What about kids born with super genes? Or blue skin because their parents think it's cool? These ethical questions will have to be answered long before we even start to fix things like 'cancer'. But even then - is cancer at age 80+ really a disease, or is it just literally 'death'? More pragmatically, you're missing the bit about distribution of surpluses. The age old question. "nsure that working for a living is optional". Working for a living is already optional. It's called 'welfare'. Some of my neighbours do it. One guy, on my street collects his welfare every month and spends 4 days high on crack, and then the rest of the month sleeping in the park. Is this what you mean? Because I can assure you that people in this state are not happy, and it's a far more complicated thing than we know. So, should people who work their entire lives, very hard, and take great risk ... have to pay for his crack habit? It's just one example, but it's the biggest issue missed when any of these techie types start to talk about 'the future'. Technology will surely improve our lives on the whole - but the issue of distribution is as old as time, and technology will probably only exacerbate, not solve the issue. At the foundation is both an understanding of human nature - and also a moral cause. The later of which is even harder to found, we do it today by rough consensus, not necessarily by understanding. I wish more techies would study finance and history, I think these conversations would be different and we'd be better at solving problems.