4 ms·
What does corporate donation to political parties imply? No, fuck that. Corporations should be banned from giving money to political parties. Our politicians a
by TheSpiceIsLife 10y ago
What does corporate donation to political parties imply?
No, fuck that. Corporations should be banned from giving money to political parties. Our politicians are supposed to represent our interests as citizens, not our interests as corporations and their employees.
I'm open to changing my mind on this matter if anyone can provide many strong examples of where corporate donation to political parties has lead to demonstrably better outcomes for people at citizens.
- cloverich 10y agoI think the central argument is: corporations must make money to donate, and generally make money by providing a service that people want or need. In that way, corporate interests may be tied to a population's interests. Obviously this could be flawed (to the point of exclusion) in many ways, and I'd enjoy discussion around it. > many strong examples of where corporate donation to political parties has lead to demonstrably better outcomes for people at citizens. I'd bet you could find many strong examples in both directions. I think we'd need either evidence that its systematically one way or the other, or strong logical arguments as to why it would be inevitable (i.e. evidence lacking).
- rayiner 10y ago> Corporations should be banned from giving money to political parties. Corporations are banned from donating to either candidates or national party committees (DNC/RNC). What they're not banned from doing is spending money independently to promote political causes. And I can give you a good example of why that's not a bad thing: had Citizens United gone the other way, the government could have banned the tech company protests against SOPA/PIPA.
- alasdair_ 10y agoSerious question: let's say they DID ban corporations from protesting against particular proposed laws. Would the outcome necessarily be worse for the people of the US overall?
- rayiner 10y agoYes. Corporations are a bulwark against oppressive government. The rise of the commercial class led to the downfall of feudalism and the rise of democracy.
- db48x 10y agoCorporations are just groups of citizens, all of whom have every right to donate money to anyone they want. Why would it be that groups cannot donate when the individuals making up the group can?
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoYour comment, and the other replies, all raise very good points. My initial reaction to corporate lobbying was probably too knee-jerk. I suppose what gets in the way (or in my way, at least) is ideology. If a corporation (or any group of people) lobbys for something I'm in favour of then I'll cheer them, if they lobby for something I'm against I'll yell boo. Biases hey.