4 ms·
Non-sensational possible explanation: it's the checksum of a file he sent to a journalist or friend. He deleted the tweet because the receiver saw it. https://
by mtmail 10y ago
Non-sensational possible explanation: it's the checksum of a file he sent to a journalist or friend. He deleted the tweet because the receiver saw it.
https://www.reddit.com/r/conspiracy/comments/4wc9ep/huge_edward_snowden_leak_incoming_he_just_posted/d65vcsm https://www.reddit.com/r/conspiracy/comments/4wc9ep/huge_edw...
- serg_chernata 10y agoI was thinking the same thing. Is there any way to tell?
- appleflaxen 10y agono; not with cryptography, unless you decrypt it / determine what it decrypts.
- matt_wulfeck 10y agoIt's a sha256. It could definitely be a checksum for a file, although hashes like this is not an uncommon way to generate a large, unique password from a small string or phrase. Most passwords can be easily brute forced. A 64-byte string is a lot harder to brute force. I actually think a sha2 is a little bit weird for a file checksum. I would expect md5 or a regular sha1. Or simply send the file with a gpg signature to validate the integrity (provided he still has some sort of trusted public key). Either way any off-the-shelf Mac can generate and verify these checksums. My guess is that Snowden is starting to feel homesick and wants to start the process of returning to the USA. That's why he said "It's time." The tweet could be a password or a code to something but I don't think it's meant to embarrass or expose anybody.
- LeoPanthera 10y agoHow do you know it's a sha256, beyond the length?
- matt_wulfeck 10y agoI don't know for sure. It's 64-length hex string (not 156 like a lot of people are reporting), the same output as a sha256 checksum. Looks an awful lot like somebody opened up a terminal and typed in: > $ echo -n "some password" | shasum -a 256
- Natanael_L 10y agoMD5 is easy to generate collisions for (multiple chosen inputs with the same hash value), and SHA1 also just recently failed in collision security. Nothing odd with SHA256 for somebody like Snowden.
- oneloop 10y agoDon't you find it strange that I'd rely on twitter?
- dredmorbius 10y agoIf you want to send a message (or confirmation) to someone, and don't want to create a track of who it's to, a public posting board is useful. So: Twitter. Any of @Snowden's 2.29 million followers -- or anyone else reading the tweet without following his profile, could be the intended recipient. I first ran across the concept in Robert A. Heinlein's Citizen of the Galaxy. The protagonist is in a bar with another character looking at messages being posted. A name and phone number could well be a coded signal. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizen_of_the_Galaxy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizen_of_the_Galaxy (Heinlein almost certainly took the concept from elsewhere, CotG is based on Kipling's Kim, also about tradecraft. Just reflecting my first association.)
- oneloop 10y agoA) people don't know for sure whether Snowden has access to his twitter account. They're relying on twitter to keep everything in order. B) twitter will know which of Snowdens 2.29 million followers who could have read the tweet, actually read the tweet. Depending on how fast he deleted it and the level of activity of his followers, I'm guessing this number will be in the thousands. Actually, if this was a concerned of Snowden, then it wouldn't make sense to delete it, which makes me think this wasn't a concern for him.
- dredmorbius 10y agoBoth reasonable responses, but not necessarily valid. A is addressed by the nature of a hash. The person who needs to know, will know. Those who don't, can't be sure. If the source of the hash was communicated by other means (out of band), then the hash itself might be serving to confirm that Snowden himself does influence what's sent over that Twitter account. B is possible, yes, though again, the tweet and hash itself can be replicated across multiple systems, and were. You'd have to look not only at Twitter access, but at all recipients of that message across all possibly channels. Though the likelihood of one of Snowden's followers who accessed the tweet while it was up being the intended target is probably fairly high.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]