4 ms·
Great idea! The only puzzling point is the 10 km/h limit. In my experience it's almost impossible to go that slow. Better to set the limit at 20 km/h and cope w
by pmontra 10y ago
Great idea! The only puzzling point is the 10 km/h limit. In my experience it's almost impossible to go that slow. Better to set the limit at 20 km/h and cope with the conditions of the road. It will be slow for bicycles too. It forces bikers to go on the roads for cars or be very patient. Maybe it's the intended effect but I don't approve it.
- masklinn 10y ago> Great idea! The only puzzling point is the 10 km/h limit. In my experience it's almost impossible to go that slow. Are you in europe? Keep in mind most EU drivers drive stick, and most cars in barcelona would be "city" cars, C-segment or below (compact and smaller in US segmentation). Depends on the exact car of course, but in my experience 1st and slow 2nd should be well into that range, and trivial to achieve on flat road (either gas up in 1st, or if the car has enough torque shift to second and idle along).
- honkhonkpants 10y agoThis is actually a big problem in the USA. Everyone has a powerful car with automatic transmission. On level ground these will eventually accelerate to 15MPH unless the driver uses the brake. A manual transmission, or electric drive, is ever so much more civilized.
- vosper 10y agoI'd guess that people in the US spend a lot more time on freeways than Europeans do. A powerful engine is good for that (quietness, ability to overtake / maintain speed on hills). Automatic transmissions are great for freeways because they allow for cruise control. I have a pet theory that if everyone on the freeway used cruise control all the time the freeway would be safer and less stressful. That's one of the reasons I'm looking forward to self-driving cars :) Edit: I would imagine it would be straightforward to restrict the max speed that a vehicle can reach without the drivers foot on the pedal (there may even already be such a rule). The ability to regulate the speed already exists within the cruise control system.
- ghaff 10y agoYou can have cruise control on a stick. I rarely use it but my manual car has it. On most (barring long climbs and descents) freeways with free moving traffic, you pretty much put the stick in top gear and leave it. The big win with an automatic is stop and go traffic.
- vosper 10y agoAre there limitations to cruise control on manual? Presumably if it's a true manual gearbox the car can't shift automatically, so if you were to encounter an upward slope that required a down-shift what happens?
- detaro 10y agoYes, it is limited to what the car can do in that gear, so you have to downshift manually (and re-set the cruise control).
- pmontra 10y agoMy old car had one. It disengaged when I touched brakes or the clutch. I could accelerate and it felt back to the programmed speed when I left the pedal. It never shifted, obviously.
- andrepd 10y agoHuh. I've never thought of that. Lol at that last sentence though :).
- pmontra 10y agoYes, I'm in Europe. Try driving at 10 km/h for 100 m. It's 2.7 m/s, an exercise of patience. I'd prefer a higher limit and be reasonable. I go even slower and stop if the road is full of pedestrians, all of us had to do that sometimes. But 10 km/h with an empty street? 20 km/h would do.
- slazaro 10y agoThe point is that you should only drive on these streets at the beginning and end of your trip, so it would be like slow 100m at the start, then a longer trip, then slow 100m. I don't think that's a problem.
- ghaff 10y agoThe article does note that the plan also includes a lot of new bike lanes. The idea here is for the superblocks to be pedestrian friendly, i.e. they're effectively big sidewalks with a limited amount of slow moving local vehicular traffic. Unless you have segregated lanes, bike traffic under those circumstances can't just zip along as if it's on a road. (Habits in this respect do seem to vary by country. I was just in Japan and found I needed to be very aware on sidewalks because there were a lot of bikes. I needed to be very conscious not to make changes of direction without first checking that there wasn't an approaching bike behind me.)
- paulsutter 10y agoIt's a US publication, so they mention 10mph at first, later explaining that the actual limit it 20kph (12mph).
- _ZeD_ 10y agonope, it's a two phases plan: they will begin with 20Km/h in phase one and then to 10Km/h in phase two
- vertex-four 10y agoFor the record, buses in Glasgow have to travel at 10mph to enter the bus station, and do so with ease. I've been in a car driving at 5mph into a campsite. If you're driving a car beefy enough that it's impossible to do that, in the middle of a city where people respect pedestrian life... maybe it's a better idea to park-and-ride instead?
- masklinn 10y ago> For the record, buses in Glasgow have to travel at 10mph to enter the bus station, and do so with ease. Buses and trucks tend to have gearboxes with lots of gears (e.g. 12 forward and 6 back), so they can afford low gears with very high ratios (engine to wheel rpm) for fine manoeuvres. > If you're driving a car beefy enough that it's impossible to do that Less an issue of power and more an issue of gears count and gears ratio. Also according to other commenters automatic apparently don't truly idle and settle at relatively high speed: someone quoted 15mph unless the driver is actively braking. Even with high power, you can run a stick idle in1st gear and likely not reach 10km/h.
- xefer 10y agoOne of the biggest problems with cars in the city is that they are ridiculously overengineered for that environment. It feels too slow because all that power and speed gives the illusion of control. If it were possible to electronically put cars into "city mode" (low power, acceleration and speed), say, based on GPS coordinates and municipal laws, they could share the public travel ways with more equanimity with other forms of transportation.
- Tharkun 10y agoThis is one of the many reasons why there shouldn't be any cars in a city.
- mtmail 10y agoI think they're referring to a https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Living_street https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Living_street. In Germany that's 6 km/h, walking speed. You don't hit the accelerator at all, if you drive stick shift and use the 2nd gear (e.g. when police stops you) you were already too fast. They teach that in driving school because it's so weird to drive that slow.
- Retric 10y agoIMO, they are better off with raised or lowered pedestrian walkways vs removing streets, but this is more about aesthetics than practicality. As to bikes, they should be on the road anyway.
- ansible 10y agoThat's very expensive, and highly disrupts the walkability of the area.
- Retric 10y agoIt's a network effect, if you abandon street level for a wide area it can work really well. Considering the cost and impact of this change it's worth considering for other city's less focused on tourists.
- lucaspiller 10y agoHong Kong has something like this in the city center and it works well. The entrance to many malls and buildings is on the pedestrian level, above street level. On the other hand in residential areas they just share the streets - the streets are small with lots of bends so it artificially limits the speed at which you can drive.
- mewwts 10y agoOne of the reasons they do this is to fight pollution. Your solution doesn't have the benefit of reducing traffic in an area?
- Retric 10y agoAnything that reduces the number of trips by cars in the city reduces pollution. The downside of their approach is you increase the amount of travel time in car for anyone that makes a trip thus increasing pollution citywide for each trip on average.
- TheCoelacanth 10y agoThe point is for the cars to be going the same speed as pedestrians so that pedestrians can safely use the roads. Cars would use it only to access the interior of the super-block; never to go through the super-block. Think of it as more like driving in a parking lot than like driving on a road.
- collyw 10y agoDriving here, its difficult to get above that speed already. Its a dense city.