3 ms·
"2. The translations of the tablets seem implausibly precise. How could we possibly know that a particular bit of ancient Sumerian (or whatever it is) translate
by mcguire 10y ago
"2. The translations of the tablets seem implausibly precise. How could we possibly know that a particular bit of ancient Sumerian (or whatever it is) translates as the Anglicized name "Gal Sal" or "Sukkalgir" or (most implausibly) "En-pap X"?"
This is the catalogue data for the tablet: http://cdli.ucla.edu/search/archival_view.php?ObjectID=P005289 http://cdli.ucla.edu/search/archival_view.php?ObjectID=P0052...
(The fourth drawing is of the two (!) cylinder seals "signing" the tablet.)
Weirdly, the best diagram of the writing I can find is on the cover of The Oriental Institute 2010-2011 Annual Report (http://oi.uchicago.edu/sites/oi.uchicago.edu/files/uploads/shared/docs/10_11_AnnualReport.pdf http://oi.uchicago.edu/sites/oi.uchicago.edu/files/uploads/s...). (Yeah, just the front page. There's probably an article in there somewhere.)
This version of proto-cuneiform is a syllabary with glyphs representing "KUR", "SAL", "EN", "PAP", etc. (The "X" indicates a missing glyph; there's a chip off the tablet.)
For translation, Sumerian and Akkadian, both in cuneiform, were used for record keeping and official inscriptions for a very long time, at least through the Persian empire. Sumerian, I think, was used as the language of record for a good while even after Aramaic became the lingua franca of the region. (Sumer was a leading producer of skilled information workers, a.k.a. scribes, through the period of the Persian Empire, at least.) I don't remember the whole story of decoding the languages, but there are many multi-lingual inscriptions and literally tons of these tablets, including a lot of student work, word lists, and other textbook things, and letters to people who spoke other languages (see, for example, the Amarna letters).
As for pronunciation, you've got me there. I assume it's by correspondence with other languages that we do know how to pronounce, or possibly by weaker relationships; Sumerian is (AFAIK) unrelated to other languages, but Akkadian is Semitic and Aramaic (and some other languages) are Indo-European.
- mcguire 10y agoWhoo, hey! Just found this note from the copyright page of the Annual Report: "Overleaf: This text appears to identify two named slaves in the possession of a third individual. The sign for “slaves” in fact derives from two distinct signs, one for male ( ) and one for female ( ) slave. Typical of proto-cuneiform texts, the inscription does not include a preposition or verb, which would clarify the roles of the participants. This ambiguity is, in part, resolved by tablet format and the organization of information into cases. OIM A2513. Clay. Purchased (Jemdet Nasr?). Ca. 3100 bc. 4.6 x 4.6 x 2.4 cm. After Christopher Woods, “The Earliest Mesopotamian Writing,” in Visible Language: inventions of Writing in the Ancient Middle East and beyond , edited by Christopher Woods, p. 39, fig. 2.6 (Oriental Institute Museum Publications 32; Chicago: The Oriental Institute, 2010). Photo by Jean Grant" Pity the glyphs didn't make it through cut-n-paste.
- lisper 10y agoWow, thank you for that amazingly informative reply! I wish I could give you ten upvotes. This is what HN comments should be all about.