4 ms·
I think you make a good point that 'cheap' is very relative to your means and access, and the LES may not have been cheap for _everyone_ even in the 80s. Defin
by jrochkind1 10y ago
I think you make a good point that 'cheap' is very relative to your means and access, and the LES may not have been cheap for _everyone_ even in the 80s. Definitely important to remember.
But I'm inclined to believe Smith that it was cheap for her and people like her in a way present-day NYC isn't, for similar people today. I guess we could try to look up rent statistics over time etc.
> if you want that in NY now you move to crown heights.
Pretty sure Crown Heights ain't affordable anymore either. (idle googling suggests median Crown Heights studio apartment price today is $2000. Yeah. "Studio" means "one room (usually very small) apartment" in U.S. rental listings, not something cool like 'giant warehouse an artist can make into an art studio', heh.)
Maybe somewhere I haven't heard of (cause I don't live in NYC) in Queens or the Bronx? I don't know if you'd have the same access to culture and money living in some far-off non-subway-served part of the Bronx though.
I think Manhattan in the 80s really was kind of unusual in being cheap _and_ still a place with lots of money floating around and cultural institutions. This is unusual. It was sort of a mid-point on the re-organization of American urban geography, with NYC being a special case as usual as the biggest city in the U.S.
- dionidium 10y ago>idle googling suggests median Crown Heights studio apartment price today is $2000. It's not quite that bad. Here are some actual listings for one-bedrooms in Crown Heights that rent between $1500-1700: https://www.padmapper.com/listings/17067721.-1-bedroom-1-bathroom-apartment-at-240-schenectady-avenue-new-york-ny-11213 https://www.padmapper.com/listings/17067721.-1-bedroom-1-bat... https://www.padmapper.com/listings/17206256.-1-bedroom-1-bathroom-apartment-at-49-herkimer-st-new-york-ny-11216 https://www.padmapper.com/listings/17206256.-1-bedroom-1-bat... https://www.padmapper.com/listings/17246561.-1-bedroom-1-bathroom-apartment-at-256-hancock-st-new-york-ny-11216 https://www.padmapper.com/listings/17246561.-1-bedroom-1-bat... But everything is relative. Those apartments would rent for around $700-800 in my city.
- anamoulous 10y agoI don't think it's worth splitting hairs on Crown Heights real estate prices being exorbitant. They are. I moved here two years ago right when the 2nd wave of gentrifiers flooded the area. It's stark. You might be able to get a 1500-1700 if you _compete_ for one because landlords are beginning to mobilize crappy housing stock (like these apartments).
- dionidium 10y agoPlus, let's not forget that $1500 is still a lot of money to most people.
- compiler-guy 10y agoEspecially if you are working as a server in a small restaurant or the floor of a small music shop, which is how starving artists survive while trying to build a career. All the focus on absolute cost misses the income side of the equation, which hasn't kept up with the cost side.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ghaff 10y ago>I think Manhattan in the 80s really was kind of unusual in being cheap _and_ still a place with lots of money floating around and cultural institutions. I think you're probably right. On the one hand, the city was something of a train wreck at the time and certainly there were a lot of areas like the LES and probably Hell's Kitchen, etc. that a lot of people generally stayed away from and were probably relatively cheap. At the same time, Plenty of middle class and wealthier people weren't about to leave Manhattan for a whole host of reasons (finance industry, culture, etc.) in the way that the same cohort was fleeing other cities for the suburbs.
- bradleyjg 10y ago> Maybe somewhere I haven't heard of (cause I don't live in NYC) in Queens or the Bronx? I don't know if you'd have the same access to culture and money living in some far-off non-subway-served part of the Bronx though. Large parts of the southern Bronx are served by subway and still affordable. The have relatively bad crime stats and you may feel out of place but all that was true in the LES in the 80s too. And even if there aren't great commuting options to the financial district or midtown, you don't necessarily need to be in quick commuting distance to take advantage of the proximity to the cultural institutions. It's still going to be far easier for your indie band to get booked into some west village bar if you are based out of some far corner of the Bronx than if you are based out of Cincinnati. And if you develop your own artsy section of the Bronx the millionaires that want to feel cool can take uber up there. All that said, the Bronx runs into the whole "gentrification" debate in a way that I don't think some of these other towns across the rust belt do. I get the sense that in at least some of these cities everyone, or almost everyone, is happy to get any kind of population influx.
- Nav_Panel 10y ago> Large parts of the southern Bronx are served by subway and still affordable Not for long. There's already a hip coffee shop on 134th st right off the 3rd Ave bridge. Things are gonna creep upward pretty quick. Give it 5-10 years and it'll look like Harlem does now.
- justinlardinois 10y ago> "Studio" means "one room (usually very small) apartment" in U.S. rental listings, not something cool like 'giant warehouse an artist can make into an art studio', heh.) As an American it never quite occurred to me how bullshit of a term "studio" is. It's more like "the minuscule size of this apartment makes it more appropriate for an art studio than an actual dwelling."