3 ms·
Anti-submarine Warfare: Seek, but shall ye find?
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI always thought Liquid Robotics wave gliders moving around with manowar type tentacles carrying an electric field would make for a nice active/passive sort of monitoring solution.
- CamperBob2 10y agoThese drones seem kind of pointless. Who cares where the enemy subs are during peacetime? The drones will obviously be destroyed the moment hostilities break out. And even then, they will just encourage the development of countermeasures, many of which will be quite trivial to implement. There will be no shortage of plausibly-deniable ways to sabotage them. If nothing else, the enemy will capture its signals for analysis and spoofing, then board the drone and swap out its equipment to report whatever they want us to think.
- ckozlowski 10y ago"These drones seem kind of pointless. Who cares where the enemy subs are during peacetime?" Starting with the mantra, "train like you fight, fight like you train", then knowing how the opponent operates in peacetime will teach you things about how they operate in wartime. The peacetime role of any military is to update it's plans and understanding of an opponent so that they start on day one of a conflict with as much understanding as possible of who they will fight and how.
- chakalakasp 10y agoSubmarines are incredibly important to waging nuclear warfare. 18 US submarines literally contain over a third of the entire active strategic nuclear missile force. Russia has a smaller, but still very significant nuclear force cruising under the waters. If you know where they are when hostilities break out and can sink them before they launch, that offers a huge strategic advantage. It's the biggest high-stakes chess game in existence and it's being played all the time. In a sudden nuclear conflict, there would be no time to destroy the drones. In a long build up to a potential nuclear conflict, destroying them could, in itself, be seen as an act of war. There could certainly be countermeasures, but forcing the enemy to execute countermeasures usually tips the board in your favor in some way. And strategic nuclear submarines don't really get to use many active countermeasures. Their job is to remain hidden until they are called upon to pop up and end the world.
- CamperBob2 10y agoBut all of the data you get from these drones will be bogus, even if the enemy has to construct a fleet of Potemkin submarines to ensure it. When hostilities break out, we will have the strategic advantage of knowing exactly where the enemy's subs aren't. If you know where they are when hostilities break out and can sink them before they launch How exactly do we plan to implement that doctrine? If we strike second, it will be too late. If we strike first, we're the bad guys. In a long build up to a potential nuclear conflict, destroying them could, in itself, be seen as an act of war. And this is a problem in itself. What happens during the next Cuban Missile Crisis, when some random unmanned tracking drone fails for no particular reason?
- _Tetsuo 10y agoIf we strike first, we're the bad guys. Here's a terrifying thought, regarding the nature of war: Being the bad guy doesn't really matter when you win.
- chakalakasp 10y ago>How exactly do we plan to implement that doctrine? If we strike second, it will be too late. If we strike first, we're the bad guys. Both major nuclear superpowers (U.S., Russia) absolutely have a large number of first strike scenarios. Nobody cares about being the "bad guy" in a nuclear war, they just want to be the nation that survives and has the advantage after the initial exchanges.
- tbihl 10y agoIf memory serves, it's 14. The last 4 Ohio boats (Ohio, Michigan, Florida, Georgia) are converted for missions other than strategic deterrence.
- noir_lord 10y agoEven more important for the UK and French nuclear deterrent since our (I'm from the UK) deterrent is entirely submarine based and we usually only have one at sea at any given time (one at sea, one in port/training, one in refit).
- aidenn0 10y agoA significant part of modern strategic nuclear armaments as a deterrent to war is built around the idea that if your enemy doesn't know where your nuclear armed submarines are, then a first strike cannot prevent retaliation.
- CamperBob2 10y agoSure. So in addition to being a silly gimmick that could never possibly work in the real world, with real adversaries, the drones are also destabilizing. Seriously, this is the dumbest idea ever. It's fascinating that people are proposing it and defending it. Stop and think for five seconds about how the US would react if China and Russia started dogging our submarines with automated surface drones.
- ranger207 10y ago>Who cares where the enemy subs are during peacetime? It's very useful to know exactly where potential enemies are at all times. If war broke out tomorrow, we would need know where enemy subs are -- for example, to move carriers out of range or make sure that transports can safely move through an area -- and if we start tracking them now, we can avoid the stresses and constraints of warfare. Maybe the drones will be destroyed immediately, but we would at least have an idea of where to start looking. There will also be lots of countermeasures, but if suddenly half the US drone fleet gets mysteriously tangled in nets, then even that's useful intelligence.
- gaius 10y agoWho cares where the enemy subs are during peacetime? We are never really "at peace" or "at war" (short of nukes actually being in the air), it's a spectrum. It can move quickly tho' and when it does you might not have time to get your act together.
- cameldrv 10y agoThis seems like a pretty expensive solution. We're supposed to spend $20 million on every potentially hostile sub? And that's just to track them since the ship is "for now unarmed." What if we tagged them when we started tracking? Would attaching something to another country's sub be considered an act of war? We could attach an acoustic transponder, maybe a very low power spread-spectrum one that would be hard to detect, perhaps even designed to automatically detach from the boat when the boat surfaced, with thrusters that doubled as generators when the boat was moving. Charge the battery up while moving, when stopped near the surface, dive to avoid detection, then reattach when the boat starts moving again...
- geezerjay 10y ago> We're supposed to spend $20 million on every potentially hostile sub? Nowadays an M1 Abrams tank costs around $8 million. This means that for the price of 3 tanks, they can track and ultimately destroy an enemy asset that costs around $800 million new, can't be replaced, and can destroy an entire fleet of billion-dollar ships. The expense is well justified. Now, if only the US didn't kept wasting billions of dollars in assets that can be destroyed by any navy with a diesel electric sub.
- noir_lord 10y agoGiven that the buy cost of a 100 of these is less than a single carrier and in the ballpark of two SSN's it actually seems like a bargain.