2 ms·
I wholeheartedly agree with this article's premise (to listen and truly understand conflicting ideas), but its specific approach seems like just subjecting ones
by mindslight 10y ago
I wholeheartedly agree with this article's premise (to listen and truly understand conflicting ideas), but its specific approach seems like just subjecting oneself to emotional warfare. Listening to someone's story will get you an understanding of why they believe something, but not necessarily an understanding of the actual belief.
What if this woman didn't have a compelling personal narrative (infertility) driving her viewpoint, but had instead just copied the advice from a culture with only 2 kyr of success? I'm guessing the author would have likely concluded something less empathetic like the woman was just a victim of backwards thinking.
I think this phase we're going through is mainly people who rely on peer-scoped emotional reasoning having to come to terms with a wider communication scope and get used to the left-brain verbal communication engendered by the Internet. In order to truly understand something, your intellectual gamut must be able to describe it. If you wish to understand a different point a view, you must work at expanding your own logical framework to be able to express the new idea simultaneously with what you already believe. This is not a skill most people have developed, so instead of working to understand, they give in to their gut and treat the differing idea as a threat.