2 ms·
Most of my Linux use for the last several years has been terminal only, so I am way out of touch with how GUI Linux has improved. How is the desktop nowadays? I
by tzs 10y ago
Most of my Linux use for the last several years has been terminal only, so I am way out of touch with how GUI Linux has improved. How is the desktop nowadays? In particular, how is it as far as consistency among programs goes?
For instance, here is a screenshot I took in 2003 showing several the file open dialogs from several different programs: http://i.imgur.com/Wcwaiwu.jpg http://i.imgur.com/Wcwaiwu.jpg
Note that there is almost no consistency between these dialogs. That's because the file open dialog that a program presented was determined by what GUI toolkit the developer picked to use to develop their program.
Compare to Mac and Windows, where file selection dialogs are part of the system, and so almost all applications use them.
People tried to tell me the Linux way was better, because it means the OS vendor wasn't forcing their choice on everyone. Cool...I like choice, but how about putting the choice in the hands of the user, rather than the individual app developers (or rather the GUI toolkit developers)?
It seems to me that the right way to do this is for the system to provide a standardized API for file selection, and provide a way to register multiple implementations, and to provide a way for a user to tell the system which implementation they prefer in general and perhaps for specific programs.
Each toolkit could continue to provide its own implementations of file selection dialogs, but could register those with the system, and access them via the standard API so that if the user prefers the dialogs from a different toolkit the user gets their preferred dialog.