4 ms·
Read to the bottom and you find out what this article is really about: "This all adds to the urgency of overhauling both the private and public pension systems
by tonyedgecombe 10y ago
Read to the bottom and you find out what this article is really about:
"This all adds to the urgency of overhauling both the private and public pension systems to encourage later retirement, by shifting benefits to favor later retirement and reducing tax penalties on earnings for those who are already collecting Social Security. The payoff: a more solvent pension system and a more productive economy."
- toomuchtodo 10y agoWow, isn't that the submarine thesis. When the real solution is to remove the cap on social security taxable wages on income. EDIT: TL;DR Removing the cap at ~$118K/year on social security taxes (any income above that is not taxed for SS purposes) causes Social Security to become immediately solvent in perpetuity. But heh, the highway trust fund is broke too [1], so why would I expect Congress to fix anything else related to tax collection for public services. [1] https://www.transportation.gov/highway-trust-fund-ticker https://www.transportation.gov/highway-trust-fund-ticker
- maxerickson 10y agoIt would also represent a fundamental shift in the program, from social insurance to wealth transfer. Raising the retirement age is an acknowledgement that the actuarial data has changed. And it would push the top marginal tax rates to ~55-60% (40+15+state).
- toomuchtodo 10y agoSocial welfare is social welfare. Taxes are at the lowest levels in (EDIT: modern) history; they must (and should) go up to support the must vulnerable citizens. Or should we continue to allow the top income tiers to siphon from the economy while everyone else is slowly lowered into poverty?
- maxerickson 10y agoThere were no federal income taxes in the US ~100 years ago. Prior to WWI, they rarely exceeded 10%. http://taxfoundation.org/sites/taxfoundation.org/files/docs/fed_individual_rate_history_nominal.pdf http://taxfoundation.org/sites/taxfoundation.org/files/docs/... I'm not necessarily arguing against raising taxes, I'm pointing out that it would be a huge change in the program.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoI believe we're in agreement then.
- maxerickson 10y agoWe seem to have some disagreement about what "in history" means. I also probably wouldn't aim a massively scoped wealth transfer program at enabling earlier retirement (admittedly you haven't stated a preference for this wealth transfer over other sorts of wealth transfer, you've just stated that it would make SS solvent).
- toomuchtodo 10y ago> We seem to have some disagreement about what "in history" means. It appears so; you're looking back 100 years. I'm looking back in modern times (which I'd consider starting around World War 1). > I also probably wouldn't aim a massively scoped wealth transfer program at enabling earlier retirement (admittedly you haven't stated a preference for this wealth transfer over other sorts of wealth transfer, you've just stated that it would make SS solvent). 62 is considered the earliest you can collect social security, with a steep reduction in benefits for the remainder of the collection period. 65 is standard. I don't consider 65 early retirement. If you have a better idea than removing the SS tax cap, I'd love to hear it. Reducing benefits are not an option when existing benefits are barely keeping seniors out of poverty as it is.
- maxerickson 10y ago
- fuzzfactor 10y agoNope, the income cap on SS-taxable income is the unfair wealth transfer that has been going on for some time.
- 6stringmerc 10y agoKind of interesting that sort of conclusion / assertion gets mentioned without inferring that moentary policy is so out of whack that "Saving" the old fashioned way is not a good course of action. Those pension plans were based on about a 7% return, which ain't crazy, but now seems nearly out of reach without significant risk (re: equitites afloat on easy money). Staggering the factors at play here...Fed Policy, Healthcare Inflation, Stagnant Worker Wages...ugh
- yompers888 10y agoIt's very common (a) for 7% to be an unrealistic return for pensions, given their allocations; and (b) for pensions funds to estimate even higher (8 or 9%) growth rates. I can't speak to the majority of pensions funds, but there are State funds that assume 8.5% returns while having 50-60% of the fund in bonds. Those are the Minnesota numbers, and they tend to be pretty good for a State. They're ~75% funded, and that makes them 19th best in the country. If you face the reality that their assumptions are insane, then you have the wrestle with more realistic projections of how much they've really funded.