3 ms·
"According to a study conducted under the leadership of the Federal Office for Spatial Development, the new alpine tunnel will hardly relieve any pressure on th
by bogomipz 10y ago
"According to a study conducted under the leadership of the Federal Office for Spatial Development, the new alpine tunnel will hardly relieve any pressure on the roads but instead create new rail traffic, as the newspaper “Der Bund” reports."
Isn't the environmental impact of 1000 people traveling from point A to point B via rail far preferable to than 1000 people making the same journey by car? The quote above seems to imply that rail provides no appreciable environmental benefit, I'm finding that hard to believe.
- tallowen 10y agoWhat they're saying is that there will be just as many cars on the road as before and therefore not reducing the environmental impact of the road. I imagined it to be something like this: Old: - Road: 1000 users - Train tunnel: 1000 users New: - Road: 1000 users - Train: 2000 users Although the train is more environmentally friendly than the road, I think the article is saying the impact of adding it is just that more people make the trip rather than the same number of people doing it in a more environmentally friendly way. This is basically the concept of induced demand i.e. build it and they will come.