3 ms·
There are some considerable weaknesses in concluding causation here. Their theory is a sound proposal, but countries with higher levels of health, also are wea
by CapitalistCartr 17y ago
There are some considerable weaknesses in concluding causation here. Their theory is a sound proposal, but countries with higher levels of health, also are wealthier, more socialist, and other factors. All of which might be relevant.
- pbz 17y agoThey quote Romania as one of the low-masculinity countries while Bulgaria as one of the high, so as somewhat polar opposites. There are very small differences in terms of wealth, health care access, or even physical location between these two countries.
- bh23ha 17y agoThere are very small differences in terms of wealth, health care access, or even physical location between these two countries. Or cultural traditions like Mărţişor: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/M%C4%83r%C5%A3i%C5%9For http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/M%C4%83r%C5%A3i%C5%9For and Martenitsa: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martenitsa http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martenitsa Or ancient history, or recent history, or genetics, etc. This really makes me wonder about the study, and exactly what they measured?
- greenlblue 17y agoTotally agree. There are too many other confounding factors to make any strong conclusions from this.
- mlinsey 17y agoOne possible confounding variable that immediately lept to my mind was a study published sometime in the past couple years indicated that women's preferences change depending on whether they are currently taking hormonal birth control. I believe it did say that more "feminine" characteristics were more attractive when taking such birth control - and these birth control methods are probably more common in countries with better medical systems in general.
- rmk 17y agoYes, I remember reading about this as well... Perhaps it does play a role whose 'share' hasn't been taken into account.