4 ms·
Of course Comcast wants to do it. If it makes them more money, don't they have a duty to their shareholders to use that asset to generate profit? It does bothe
by criddell 10y ago
Of course Comcast wants to do it. If it makes them more money, don't they have a duty to their shareholders to use that asset to generate profit?
It does bother me that privacy is turning into something for the wealthy.
I also think about how companies like Facebook gather an unbelievable amount of information about me and use that to generate $15 every 3 months (I'm in the US). I wish I could just pay $5 every month for an ad-free version.
- autokad 10y agois that a bit contradictory to be bothered that privacy is turning into something for the wealthy and yet wish you could pay for your privacy on fb? edit: i think fb would offer that if users would be willing to pay it. something like 400 million daily active users? if t hey could collect 5$ a month off them that'd be a lot of coin
- duaneb 10y agoit still values Facebook less than Netflix, which is not for the rich. I'd easily pay $10/month. But I highly doubt Facebook has ever seriously considered it. It would alter their brand as a data mine to businesses way too much. I highly recommend dns level ad restriction plus heavy stylesheet modification. Just trash the mobile app or route it through an tracking blocking dns proxy. Obviously don't like businesses and never click on ads.
- dhimes 10y agofb made about $1/user/month last year, FYI
- criddell 10y agoMy real point was that they collect so much data about their users and individually it's worth almost nothing. They know a huge amount of stuff about me both online and offline and that's worth $5 this month. It's a little depressing.
- eropple 10y ago> If it makes them more money, don't they have a duty to their shareholders to use that asset to generate profit? Unless explicitly laid out in their corporate charter, no. There is no default effective fiduciary duty to do anything related to profitability, be it "maximize" or otherwise. This is one of the more pernicious myths about the idea of the corporation that needs to be killed.
- ImprovedSilence 10y ago>> here is no default effective fiduciary duty to do anything related to profitability, be it "maximize" or otherwise I'm not entirely sure that's 100% true. I know the one thing I've seen before when "duty" to shareholders comes up: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dodge_v._Ford_Motor_Co https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dodge_v._Ford_Motor_Co.
- eropple 10y ago"Interests of shareholders" does not mean the same thing as "maximizing profits." For example, a forward-thinking Comcast executive could make the argument that the goodwill from not looking like creepy spying dudes hiding in your hedges outweighs the short-term increase in revenue.
- lawnchair_larry 10y agoThat's exactly the same as maximizing profits.
- eropple 10y agoThat depends on where you're standing and what your timeframe is. Which, by itself, is enough to put the boot to the aforementioned pernicious lie: it's impossible to "maximize profit" for the shareholders, because the shareholders aren't unified in purpose.
- pjc50 10y agoThat ruling only really prevents companies from directly giving the money away in defiance of the shareholders. It's about 'means' and 'ends'. It can't meaningfully impose any particular strategy on a company. Think about it for a second: wouldn't profitability maximising oblige all companies to hurtle into whatever new line of business was deemed most profitable at that time - today we're an ISP, tomorrow we're real estate, next week we're hoarding gold?
- mindslight 10y ago> It does bother me that privacy is turning into something for the wealthy. A victim mentality will get you nowhere. From what I know, Comcast is somewhere between $60 and $200 a month. VPN subscriptions are available for less than $5/mo. So privacy from your wireline provider is easily affordable. We're in the age of computational tools. If you don't spend a modicum of effort to use these tools to protect your interests, you can't really complain when you end up disadvantaged from adversarial parties wielding them against you.
- criddell 10y agoOkay, so I'll extend what I said to it bothers me that privacy is turning into something for the wealthy and the technologically inclined.
- mindslight 10y agoIt has little to do with technological inclination, but whether you act to design your own situation rather than just choosing between options that are marketed to you. If you take a look at /r/VPN, you'll see most of the questions are from people who lack technical skills.
- criddell 10y agoIf you know enough to even look for /r/VPN or know that such a thing exists or what it does, you are already way ahead of the game.
- mindslight 10y agoReddit is a mainstream site these days, but sure. The most basic of searches will lead one to articles explaining that there exist various ways of achieving online privacy. At which point one can keep exploring, or ask computer literate friends for recommendations. If somebody spends a decent amount of time on various social sites, is concerned about privacy, and yet does not do this, their primary missing ingredient is motivation. Nothing in the world can compensate for a lack of self-agency. (Not even money as you initially lamented, since it means you're actually more valuable to surveil)
- MichaelGG 10y ago>duty to their shareholders to use that asset to generate profit This is so widely said but almost never applicable. You could say this hurts Comcast's profitability because it damages rep. You could say Google is in flagrant disregard because they invest in new technology. Or Apple, because they donated money to charity. It's simple to see that this must be true: If you could predict which things were profit-generating, then no business would make bad decisions! I don't know what the legal criteria is, but I'm guessing it'd have to be some pretty severe misdeed (huge negligence?) or outright fraud before there's any legal implication. Before that, you'd imagine the board would step in.
- criddell 10y ago> I don't know what the legal criteria is It's whatever the corporate charter says and what executives and the board have communicated to investors. Google doesn't get in trouble (so far) for their X-projects because that's been part of their DNA early on.