6 ms·
The new Seattle, where everything looks the same
- jseliger 10y agoThere is a related point about housing affordability that I discuss in more detail in "Do millennials have a future in Seattle? Do millennials have a future in any superstar cities" (https://jakeseliger.com/2015/09/24/do-millennials-have-a-future-in-seattle-do-millennials-have-a-future-in-any-superstar-cities/ https://jakeseliger.com/2015/09/24/do-millennials-have-a-fut...). Which, oddly enough, started out as a Reddit comment in a discussion about housing costs and the relationship between housing costs and the economic strain many people feel.
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoThe post title is an inaccurate mutation of an article title that already didn't describe the content.
- natrius 10y agoIn a housing shortage, you don't have to build a nice building to make money. If people are stretching to find a place in a neighborhood they want, you can't charge higher rent for a nicer building. Our priority in boomtowns has been to use our government to create exclusive neighborhoods for the wealthy. People feign surprise when more and more people get excluded from our cities while they fight for laws that exclude people from every single neighborhood. If we care about ending the disgusting practice of government-imposed income segregation, we must make our neighborhoods inclusive, especially near jobs, parks, and transit. In inclusive neighborhoods, we don't exclude people by declaring the neighborhood full by law. You can always add more homes to include more people. Cities full of inclusive neighborhoods will be affordable to all, especially if we use our tax dollars to subsidize homes for those whose needs the market might not meet. Our current practice is to decorate exclusive neighborhoods with subsidized homes and pretend we care about inclusion. It's a lie. Providing homes for everyone in our cities near the things they care about is possible. Building homes that people can afford to make look nice is possible. We've chosen to enforce exclusivity instead. It is unjust.
- int_19h 10y ago>> You can always add more homes to include more people. Can you, though? Any given neighborhood has limited space to build things. At some point, you have to start building high-rises all over to pack more people in. This also has a limit, so beyond that you'd have to start building over parks etc. Of course, without government-imposed zoning laws, you will also have residential units competing with commercial and industrial ones, too... Oh, and who will take care of the extra infrastructure that is required for more people? So it would seem to me that this approach would result in extremely densely packed neighborhoods with poor infrastructure, and undesirable placement of (cheap) residential units next to, say, an industrial park. It would also be pretty effective at inducing more rich flight from urban areas into the suburbs, which is likely to hurt the cities even more (by reducing their tax base). I don't think this is all that simple.
- OrwellianChild 10y agoCities like Seattle are under-built to the point that the vast majority of the land is still single-family zoned, meaning you can only build one home on a plot that may be 2500 sq ft or more. 65% of Seattle's land is still Single-Family. [0] This map will showcase the problem. [1] There is much to be done to make cities like Seattle more livable and affordable before we come anywhere near the density cap you refer to. [0] http://www.seattlemet.com/articles/2015/7/16/white-single-family-neighborhoods-diversity-in-urban-villages http://www.seattlemet.com/articles/2015/7/16/white-single-fa... [1] http://res.cloudinary.com/sagacity/image/upload/v1437089045/race_change_mapping_zna5lh.pdf http://res.cloudinary.com/sagacity/image/upload/v1437089045/...
- natrius 10y ago> Any given neighborhood has limited space to build things. That's fine. A neighborhood full of high rises that no one wants to pay to knock down to build taller is naturally full. The government hasn't declared it to be full the way we do today. > Of course, without government-imposed zoning laws, you will also have residential units competing with commercial and industrial ones, too... Zoning isn't terrible. Density restrictions are terrible. They are explicit exclusion. They are the direct cause of our increasing economic segregation. > Oh, and who will take care of the extra infrastructure that is required for more people? Urban infrastructure is cheaper than suburban infrastructure. We're spending more money on infrastructure today than we would if we stopped excluding people. > It would also be pretty effective at inducing more rich flight from urban areas into the suburbs This just isn't true. Tons of wealthy people want to live in dense urban neighborhoods. That's why they're so expensive. What we should change is allowing people with different amounts of wealth to live in the same neighborhood. Density restrictions make mixed-income neighborhoods illegal: only the highest bidders get scarce homes, so families are forcibly sorted by income into separate neighborhoods. If rich people truly don't want to live in mixed-income neighborhoods, they are the ones who should leave. We shouldn't force others out for their benefit. We used to do that. Now we're doing it to even more families. We aren't repeating the mistakes of our forefathers, we're outdoing them.
- walrus01 10y agoWood framed condos. Ugh. Vancouver learned its lesson the hard way with these, and Seattle will too, in about 20 years. There's a reason the vast majority of buildings in Vancouver are now fully concrete or steel framed.
- scurvy 10y agoWorried about earthquakes? Or city-wide fire? Or termites?
- walrus01 10y agoNoise through floors and ceilings. Creaks and steps and thumps. These buildings all loosen up over time, and if you walk through one under construction you will understand when you see the C grade plywood, particleboard and chipboard.
- cperciva 10y agoAnd the worst thing about Vancouver's 1990s lowrise condos: Water damage. Unfortunately someone imported building plans from southern California which had never been tested in a climate with six months of rain... (But this problem at least Seattle can probably avoid, since it's entirely possible to withstand the climate; you just need a different design.)
- chrismealy 10y agoSeattle's 90s condos all had water damage too (not exaggerating either). Let's see what happens in 10 years.
- cperciva 10y agoVancouver's condos all started leaking within 5 years of construction. With it being 15 years since the building codes changed and not a single similar problem, I think it's safe to say that the new building codes fixed it.
- Spooky23 10y agoI wouldn't blame building codes. It's more to do with how the building industry has changed and consolidated, and has had more regulation pushed at it. (Workers comp, ADA) As information and transport gets cheaper and cheaper, common building plans and prefabrication are replacing architects and buildin crews with factory built material. Also, as liability and labor costs have risen, more and more machines are used. A dozen masons a few years ago are replaced by a boom lift, glassroc/faux finish and 4 guys. That trickles down to other places. You cannot get the variety of bricks that you once could, for example. You cannot build classical building elements because the tradesmen are gone.
- lukeschlather 10y ago"building codes" is an oversimplification. Some building codes are necessary. But some, like height limits, parking requirements, and setbacks, conspire to make it very difficult to profitably build architecturally interesting buildings.
- chrismealy 10y agoPortland's architecture is at a much higher level than Seattle's. It can be done.
- saosebastiao 10y agoAfter reading this blog post [0], I remain completely unconvinced that seattle's generic design problem is caused by anything except zoning. [0] http://seattleurbanism.blogspot.com/2009/10/townhouses-part-2-problem.html?m=1 http://seattleurbanism.blogspot.com/2009/10/townhouses-part-...
- ared38 10y agoHonestly I find his "well done" picture better representative of the sameness I see in new seattle buildings. All the new upscale apartments and condos have the same trendy contrasting blocks of colors and materials. The angles make this one interesting but most use that pattern as a facade over a flat wall. But there's nothing wrong with a city having an architectural style -- in a few decades people may be flocking to see the classic seattle architecture like we go to Miami for art deco.
- trgn 10y agoArt deco was probably the last period before the triumph of utilitarian architecture. A lot has changed since the 30s, the loss of craftmansship, but also the "engineerifying" of the architecture profession. That loss of finesse has been acute, and one way to address this regression, and it's an approach that's been waxing and waning since WW2, is by looking at the building as a sculpture in itself, as opposed to its own art form that can accommodate other fine arts like sculpture or ornamentation. The "well done"-picture is a case in point. The whole building is shaped to pop from a distance, but it will look uninspiring up close. Great architecture, like Miami's art deco, doesn't have this, it looks good at all scales. Smaller buildings get away with simple forms, if you use high quality natural materials that are pleasing to the touch. But generally, the larger a building gets, the more care it requires the architect to introduce a hierarchical order, that gradually refines as you approach. So I don't think Seattle's style will endure, because it isn't sensual up close, and mostly drab from a-far.
- ryporter 10y agoI just moved from downtown Seattle over to Bellevue, and the sea of cranes certainly got on my nerves, but the design of the buildings did not. Many of the new building exteriors have a lot of glass, and I find it rather attractive. I'm far more concerned that we are overbuilding and could end up going the way of Miami circa 2007 than I am about what we are building.
- xenihn 10y agoCan you expand on 2007 Miami? I'm curious.
- keithpeter 10y agoUK: no use of wood frame buildings to my knowledge, all new construction of apartment style housing seems to be concrete floor plate with steel skeleton and concrete central utility/fire exit 'cores'. Styles can still be very boring and samey though. You can almost see the catalogue numbers on the photos.
- nraynaud 10y agoyes, it's incredible how modern buildings in the US ans Europe look the same while their construction is so different. Also, why do we have the same taste in multi-units buildings appearance, while our individual houses keep looking very different?
- arethuza 10y agoWood frame houses can be found in the UK, although they are fairly rare and usually pretty expensive. As for the styles of modern homes - blame the "volume housebuilders", it's like complaining that all Fords look the same.
- nemo44x 10y agoMany of the old listed homes are in fact wood frames. My wife's parents have a home with parts built in the 1400's! Extensions were added on over the years (and they were able to add on their own tasteful extension) but the wood supports and frame are obvious as they show. And they're beautiful, massive pieces of wood that have supported the structure for hundreds of years and will for hundreds more. However, it would be impractical to use those techniques today.
- arethuza 10y agoOf course, I'd forgotten about old houses! I guess that wooden frame style is what "mock Tudor" is imitating.
- quotemstr 10y agoI wish people would get over their fear of "manhattenization" or whatever. Manhattan is a good place. There should be more places with similar density and infrastructure, not more artificial restrictions on construction.
- Analemma_ 10y agoFear of Manhattanization is just NIMBYism and pulling up the drawbridge, nothing more. "I've got my lovely two-story single-family house in an urban core, so buzz off." I agree that people should get over it, but telling people to "get over" being a NIMBY has never worked before and isn't about to start now, unfortunately.
- quotemstr 10y ago> telling people to "get over" being a NIMBY has never worked before Sure it has: you just outvote the NIMBYs. One of the big problems is that cities no longer annex their suburbs. In the Bay Area, the City of San Francisco really should be everything from Golden Gate Park to San Jose. Once you set up coherent governance, you can enact coherent policy. In general, if you feel like society just isn't working like it used to work and you can't figure out why, try to see what's actually done differently now and think about why it might have changed.