2 ms·
Not only is that most meaningful, it olso has the most bang for the buck (saves people the most time), AND is the easiest technically. I wrote a long post abou
by ars 10y ago
Not only is that most meaningful, it olso has the most bang for the buck (saves people the most time), AND is the easiest technically.
I wrote a long post about it before, but basically I expect self driving trucks on dedicated interstate lanes to be the start. Then self driving cars on the same lanes.
Over time all interstates will be self driving. City streets will never be unless we get AI with general intelligence.
- duaneb 10y agoI'm not convinced most human city drivers have general intelligence. I don't see it being much later than other roads.
- loup-vaillant 10y ago> City streets will never be unless we get AI with general intelligence. Driving is likely a much easier problem than artificial general intelligence. Even when it involves evading rampaging toddlers. Sure, if you want perfect safety, you'll need the car to anticipate a great deal —far more than humans currently do, like looking at the walkways as well as the drive lanes. If we merely want something that's safer than a human driver that's probably nothing more than a (huge) engineering feat.
- ars 10y ago> Driving is likely a much easier problem than artificial general intelligence. That isn't actually true. Scenario: Narrow one way road, you get to the bottom of it and there is an ambulance blocking the road. Behind you is a bunch of cars, ahead of you is a few cars. You need to coordinate with other cars to move out of the way, you need to make use of driveways to turn around, you need to know to override the law and got the wrong way on a one way. And that's just one scenario. You need general AI to handle all the different things that happen on city streets. Highways is easier - it's controlled access. And if they block the road it's typically by officials who would have some way to remotely control the self driving cars and tell them what to do (not that that is not a car of worms in itself). > If we merely want something that's safer than a human driver that's probably nothing more than a (huge) engineering feat. Not even close. You would need to do better than 99.99999% perfect to do better than a human. That number is correct BTW - that's how rarely humans make a mistake that leads to a fatality. (Injury rate is not quite that good: 99.999% but that's still quite hard for a computer.) We don't have that level of reliability in a phone, never mind a car. There are some appliances that are that good, but they tend to be very simple.
- loup-vaillant 10y agoEdge. Cases. Such scenarios are rare enough that they could be handled either remotely, or not at all. The ambulance won't get through and its patient will die. Tough luck. But think of the many accidents those automated cars avoided in the first place. It sucks, but it's still worth it. Also, cars don't have to be fully automated. They can still be remotely controlled, or otherwise warn their company that they should call a tow truck. My favourite example is automated trucks: you'll most likely have a central dispatch per region, with a few operators that manage 50 trucks each. Once a truck has a problem the computer can't handle, it just calls the relevant dispatch, where humans take over. Also, automated cars don't have to do better than humans in every dimensions. Safety is paramount, but resilience in the face of unusual situations is not. It is okay for the computer to get you to your destination a bit more slowly, or even not at all from time to time. Even public transportation has way less than 99% reliability for my commute to work, and I still take it.
- ars 10y agoIt's ALL edge cases. Everything. The non edge case are the easy part. It's the edge cases that is hard. Saying it's fine "it's just edge cases" completely ignores the difficulty. > But think of the many accidents those automated cars avoided in the first place. It sucks, but it's still worth it. Did you read the rest of my post? Do you understand just how good the computer would have to be to have any impact at all? I have a feeling you don't. > They can still be remotely controlled No they can't. Wireless internet service is not even remotely close to good enough to make that possible. > Also, automated cars ... every dimensions. Safety is paramount This is why I say highways only. That covers that majority of the use cases, and the most dangerous part, and the easiest part. It's a triple win. The use case for city roads is basically non existent with the exception of self parking. > has way less than 99% reliability That 1% doesn't mean death. It's means slowness. That's not what I mean. The self driving car has to be basically perfect or death is the result. People very much underestimate just how good people are at driving.
- loup-vaillant 10y ago